Skip to content

Are G Tube and G Button the Same? Understanding the Key Differences

4 min read

Millions of people globally rely on enteral feeding for nutritional support when oral intake is compromised. A gastrostomy device, whether a tube or a button, is a key component of this nutritional support, which leads many to wonder: Are G tube and G button the same?

Quick Summary

A G-button is a specific type of G-tube, but they are not identical. The main distinction is their physical profile and external appearance, which affects comfort, discreetness, and lifestyle for patients receiving enteral nutrition.

Key Points

  • G-button is a type of G-tube: A G-tube is a general term for gastrostomy tubes, while a G-button is a specific, low-profile version.

  • Low-profile vs. Standard: The main difference is the external appearance; a G-button sits flush with the skin, unlike a standard, longer G-tube.

  • Initial vs. Replacement: A standard G-tube is often placed first to allow the feeding tract to mature, before it is replaced with a G-button.

  • Feeding Method: A G-button requires an extension set for feeding, while a standard G-tube can be accessed directly.

  • Convenience and Lifestyle: G-buttons offer greater freedom of movement and are more discreet, which can improve quality of life for long-term users.

  • Proper Care is Universal: Regardless of the type, both devices require diligent care, including cleaning and flushing, to prevent complications.

In This Article

What is a G-Tube?

A gastrostomy tube, commonly called a G-tube, is a medical device inserted through the abdominal wall directly into the stomach. This allows fluids, nutrition, and medication to be delivered straight into the stomach, bypassing the mouth and esophagus. A G-tube is a necessary nutritional aid for individuals who cannot eat or swallow enough to meet their dietary requirements. G-tubes are generally intended for long-term use, defined as longer than 30 days. A surgeon or gastroenterologist places the tube during a procedure, which can be done surgically, radiologically, or endoscopically, such as a Percutaneous Endoscopic Gastrostomy (PEG). The term 'G-tube' can refer to both a standard-length tube and a low-profile tube (the button). The standard-length G-tube, sometimes called a 'dangler', is often the initial device placed, allowing the gastrostomy tract to heal and mature over several weeks before a low-profile button can be used as a replacement.

Understanding the Standard G-tube (Dangler)

The traditional, or standard-length, G-tube has a more prominent external portion that extends several inches from the abdomen. Inside the stomach, a water-filled balloon or internal bolster holds the tube in place, while a retention disc or clamp on the outside prevents it from sliding further in. This type of tube is sometimes called a 'dangler' because the exterior part hangs freely. For many patients, especially during the initial healing period, a standard G-tube is the preferred option. However, its length can be a disadvantage for active individuals or for those who wish to be more discreet, as it can snag on clothing or objects.

What is a G-Button (Low-Profile G-tube)?

A G-button is a type of gastrostomy tube that is designed to be less obtrusive, making it a popular choice for long-term use after the initial tract has healed. It is a small, low-profile device that sits flush against the skin of the abdomen. Similar to other G-tubes, an internal balloon holds it securely within the stomach. A key feature of the G-button is that it requires a detachable extension set for feeding and administering medicine. When not in use, the button is capped, allowing for greater freedom of movement and making it easier to conceal under clothing. The MIC-KEY® is a well-known brand of a low-profile G-tube.

The Placement and Conversion Process

For most adult patients, a standard G-tube, often a PEG tube, is inserted first. This initial tube is critical for establishing and maturing the gastrostomy tract, the tunnel of skin tissue connecting the stomach to the outside. After several weeks (typically 4-8 weeks), once the tract is fully healed and stable, a healthcare provider can replace the standard G-tube with a low-profile G-button. The conversion process is straightforward and less invasive than the initial placement, often done in a clinic setting without sedation. The old tube is removed, and the new button is inserted through the same stoma.

Key Differences Between G-tubes and G-buttons

Feature Standard G-Tube (Dangler) G-Button (Low-Profile G-Tube)
Appearance Features an exterior tube that extends several inches from the abdomen. Sits flush with the skin, appearing as a small, cap-like button.
Convenience Can be cumbersome for active individuals and more prone to accidental snagging. More discreet, comfortable, and less likely to be snagged, offering greater mobility.
Feeding Method Feeding is typically done directly through the tube's port. Requires a separate extension set to attach to the button for feeding or medication.
Initial Placement Often used as the initial device to establish a mature gastrostomy tract. Generally placed after the initial tract has matured, replacing the standard G-tube.
Maintenance Requires careful management to prevent pulling or snagging on the extended tube. The low profile reduces the risk of accidental removal; care focuses on the button and stoma site.

Choosing the Right Device

The choice between a standard G-tube and a G-button is determined by the patient's individual needs, lifestyle, and medical considerations. A standard G-tube is necessary for initial placement to ensure proper healing of the tract. For long-term use, the G-button offers a more discreet and convenient solution, which can significantly improve a person's quality of life. It is especially beneficial for children and active adults. A healthcare team, including a dietitian and surgeon, will help guide patients and caregivers in selecting the most suitable device.

Nutritional Considerations and Care

Regardless of the device type, managing nutritional intake is a critical aspect of care. A dietitian will create a specific feeding plan, determining the type of formula, feeding schedule (bolus or continuous), and fluid requirements. Proper care of the gastrostomy site is also crucial to prevent complications such as leakage, infection, or granulation tissue.

General Care Instructions

  • Daily Cleaning: Gently wash the stoma site daily with mild soap and water, ensuring the area is kept clean and dry.
  • Flushing: Flush the tube with water before and after each feeding and medication to prevent clogging.
  • Balloon Volume: For devices with an inflatable balloon, check the water volume weekly to ensure it is properly inflated and securing the device.
  • Extension Set Care: For G-button users, properly clean and store the extension sets, and ensure the right size is used.
  • Monitoring: Regularly inspect the skin around the site for redness, swelling, or drainage, which can indicate a complication.

Conclusion

While a G-tube is a general term for any gastrostomy feeding tube, a G-button is a specific, low-profile type of G-tube. The fundamental difference lies in their external design: the standard G-tube has a long, visible exterior component, whereas the G-button sits discreetly against the skin. Both serve the same nutritional purpose, but the G-button offers enhanced comfort, mobility, and aesthetic appeal for long-term use after the initial placement. Understanding this distinction is key for patients and caregivers managing enteral nutrition to make informed decisions about their care.

For more information on living with enteral feeding, consider consulting the Oley Foundation, a non-profit organization that provides support and resources.

Frequently Asked Questions

A G-button isn't inherently better, but it offers advantages for long-term use, such as greater comfort, discretion, and less risk of accidental pulling compared to a standard G-tube. The choice depends on a patient's individual needs and lifestyle.

The initial standard G-tube is typically replaced with a G-button after the stoma tract has healed and matured. This process usually takes about 4 to 8 weeks.

No. Once the initial gastrostomy tract is healed, a G-button can be replaced by a healthcare provider in a clinic setting. The procedure is less invasive than the initial placement.

A G-button requires an extension set, which is a tube that temporarily connects to the button's port to administer food, fluids, or medication. The set is removed and the button capped when feeding is complete.

Common complications for both devices can include site leakage, infection, and the formation of granulation tissue around the stoma. Monitoring the site and maintaining proper hygiene can help prevent these issues.

For children, a G-button is often preferred for its low-profile design. It's less cumbersome and reduces the risk of entanglement during play, while being easier to conceal under clothing.

This depends on the patient's underlying condition and swallowing ability. For some, oral intake may be restricted, while others may be able to continue eating and drinking small amounts. This should be discussed with a healthcare provider.

Both G-tubes and G-buttons are held in place inside the stomach by a balloon or bolster. For a standard G-tube, an external retention disc also helps keep it secure.

A PEG (Percutaneous Endoscopic Gastrostomy) refers to a specific procedure for placing a G-tube. The PEG is one type of G-tube, often a standard 'dangler' model, placed endoscopically.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.