Skip to content

Can you drink mineral free water? Separating Fact from Fiction

4 min read

While water's role is hydration, studies show it can also be a source of essential minerals, making the long-term consumption of mineral free water a topic of health concern. This guide explores the facts behind drinking water with no mineral content.

Quick Summary

This article examines the safety of consuming water devoid of minerals, like distilled or reverse osmosis water. It covers potential health risks, such as nutrient deficiencies and electrolyte imbalances, and contrasts it with mineral-rich alternatives.

Key Points

  • Generally Safe for Short-Term Use: Drinking mineral free water, like distilled water, is safe for short periods, especially if your diet is mineral-rich.

  • Long-Term Consumption Risks: Exclusive long-term consumption can potentially lead to mineral deficiencies (calcium, magnesium) and electrolyte imbalances.

  • Impact on Taste and Hydration: The absence of minerals can give water a 'flat' taste, which may reduce your desire to drink and potentially hinder effective hydration.

  • Mitigation with Remineralization: Many modern reverse osmosis (RO) systems include a remineralization stage to add beneficial minerals back into the water.

  • Diet Compensates for Mineral Loss: A healthy, balanced diet rich in fruits and vegetables is the best way to ensure you receive sufficient minerals, offsetting the lack in demineralized water.

  • WHO Highlights Risks: The World Health Organization (WHO) has published reports outlining potential health risks associated with the long-term consumption of demineralized water.

In This Article

Understanding Mineral Free Water

Mineral free water, often referred to as demineralized water, is any water that has had its mineral ions removed through a purification process. The most common types are distilled water and reverse osmosis (RO) water. While they offer exceptional purity by removing contaminants, they also eliminate beneficial minerals such as calcium, magnesium, and potassium.

How Water Becomes Mineral Free

Several processes are used to produce demineralized water for various applications, from laboratories to specific medical devices.

  • Distillation: This is one of the oldest and most effective purification methods. Water is boiled into steam, and the steam is then collected and condensed back into liquid form. Any impurities and minerals with a higher boiling point than water are left behind.
  • Reverse Osmosis (RO): RO systems use a semipermeable membrane to remove dissolved solids and contaminants. A high-pressure pump forces water through the membrane, leaving the minerals behind. Many modern RO systems include a remineralization stage to add minerals back for taste and health benefits.
  • Deionization: This process uses specialized ion-exchange resins to remove mineral ions from the water. Deionization effectively removes charged mineral particles but may not remove uncharged organic molecules or microorganisms.

The Risks of Long-Term Consumption

For short-term consumption, such as during a temporary tap water contamination issue, drinking mineral free water is generally safe, especially if you get sufficient minerals from a balanced diet. However, long-term or exclusive consumption raises several health concerns highlighted by organizations like the World Health Organization (WHO).

Potential Health Issues Associated with Demineralized Water

  • Mineral Deficiencies: While water is not our primary source of minerals, its contribution can be significant. Long-term intake of demineralized water can lead to a deficiency in essential minerals like calcium and magnesium, which are crucial for bone health and proper muscle function.
  • Electrolyte Imbalance: The body tightly regulates its electrolyte balance. Drinking water with very low mineral content can disrupt this balance, potentially increasing urine output and excretion of important electrolytes like sodium, potassium, and chloride. This can lead to tiredness, weakness, and muscular cramps.
  • Impaired Taste and Thirst: Many people find the taste of mineral free water flat and unappealing. This can discourage adequate water consumption, potentially leading to suboptimal hydration.
  • Aggressive Nature: Mineral free water is highly reactive and can leach metals and other substances from plumbing and containers, which could increase exposure to toxic metals like lead.
  • Nutrient Loss in Cooking: When used for cooking, demineralized water can pull minerals from vegetables, cereals, and meat, significantly reducing the mineral content of the food you consume.

Is it All Bad? The Counterargument

Some argue that the minerals in tap water are inorganic and not easily absorbed by the body anyway, claiming most essential minerals come from food. They contend that removing contaminants is the more important function of water purification. However, studies show that mineral ions from water are highly bioavailable, and even a small supplemental intake can be important, especially for those with mineral-deficient diets. The safest approach is a balanced one.

Comparison of Water Types

Feature Mineral-Free Water (Distilled/RO without remineralization) Mineralized Water (Tap/Spring)
Mineral Content Virtually none. Removes essential minerals like calcium and magnesium. Contains naturally occurring minerals, varying by source.
Purity Extremely pure. Removes virtually all contaminants, pesticides, and bacteria. Good, though quality depends on the source and treatment. Can contain trace contaminants.
Taste Often described as 'flat' or 'bland' due to lack of minerals and dissolved gases. Varies by source and mineral composition; generally preferred for taste.
Health Effects (Long-term) Potential for electrolyte imbalance and mineral deficiencies. Can reduce food's mineral content when cooking. Provides supplementary minerals. Not associated with the same deficiency risks.
Hydration Effectively hydrates, but absorption might be less efficient due to lack of electrolytes. Enhanced hydration due to electrolyte content aiding water absorption.
Cost Can be cheaper to produce at home via an RO system, but equipment and filter replacement adds costs. Varies greatly, from inexpensive tap water to pricier bottled mineral water.

Hydrating Effectively and Safely

If you use a water purifier that strips minerals, such as a reverse osmosis system, there are steps you can take to ensure your hydration is still beneficial to your body.

  • Add Minerals Back: Use a system with a remineralization cartridge or add electrolyte drops to your water.
  • Enhance with Natural Flavors: Add slices of lemon, lime, cucumber, or mint to improve the taste and add a small amount of vitamins and antioxidants.
  • Focus on a Balanced Diet: Ensure your diet is rich in fruits, vegetables, and other mineral-rich foods to compensate for any mineral loss from your water.
  • For Athletes, Consider Electrolyte Drinks: During intense or prolonged exercise, simply drinking demineralized water might not be enough to replenish lost salts and electrolytes through sweat. Consider a sports drink formulated to restore balance.

Conclusion

While drinking mineral free water is safe for short-term use and provides clean hydration, relying on it exclusively for long periods carries potential health risks, primarily related to mineral deficiencies and electrolyte imbalance. The best approach for most people is to hydrate with water that retains or has added back its essential minerals, supplementing a healthy, balanced diet. For those using advanced home purification systems, opting for a model that includes a remineralization stage is a simple and effective way to enjoy the benefits of pure water without the drawbacks of demineralization.

Authority Links

For further information on the topic of demineralized water and health, the World Health Organization (WHO) provides reports on the issue.

Frequently Asked Questions

Mineral free water, like distilled water, has had all minerals and contaminants removed. Purified water can be produced through various methods (like reverse osmosis) but may have minerals added back in, making it not truly mineral free.

While highly debated, the theory that mineral free water actively pulls significant minerals from the body is largely considered a myth. However, the body naturally excretes minerals, and drinking water without any minerals does not help replenish them, which can become problematic over time if not compensated for by diet.

If your diet is rich and balanced with a sufficient intake of minerals from food, the occasional or even regular consumption of mineral free water is not considered harmful. Most mineral intake comes from food, and your diet can compensate for the lack of minerals in the water.

Using demineralized water for cooking can cause a significant loss of minerals from food items like vegetables, as the water actively draws them out. Using mineral-rich water can help retain these nutrients.

No, athletes should not rely solely on mineral free water, especially after intense workouts. Through sweat, they lose essential electrolytes like sodium and potassium, which mineral free water does not replace. Consuming electrolyte-fortified drinks is a safer option.

Yes, mineral free water is highly reactive and aggressive due to its low mineral content. It can leach metals from plumbing and fittings, potentially contaminating the water with toxic metals.

For most people, tap water that meets local quality standards is a good option. Alternatively, a reverse osmosis system with a remineralization filter or bottled mineral water provides the benefits of purity along with essential minerals.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.