Understanding the Sugar Refining Process and Bone Char
For many ethical consumers, the process of how food is made is just as important as the final product. When it comes to sugar, the use of bone char is a major concern, particularly for vegans and vegetarians. Bone char is a porous, black, granular material produced by charring animal bones, typically from cattle, at very high temperatures. It is used as a decolorizing filter to produce the clean, white crystals of refined sugar. While no bone particles remain in the finished sugar, the use of an animal-derived product in the process is a deal-breaker for many.
The Refining Methods Used by C&H
C&H Sugar, a brand of cane sugar, is owned by ASR Group, one of the world's largest cane sugar refiners. In a 2021 update, the Vegetarian Resource Group confirmed that ASR Group uses multiple decolorization methods across its refineries.
- Cow Bone Char: This traditional method is used to filter and whiten the sugar syrup for many of the company's conventional refined white and brown sugar products.
- Ion Exchange Resin: A synthetic, non-animal-derived alternative to bone char, this method uses a polystyrene bed for filtration.
- Granular Activated Carbon (GAC): This method uses a carbon filter derived from coal or coconut husks and is also bone char-free.
Because ASR Group uses a combination of these methods, and product sourcing can vary, it is difficult to know with certainty how any given bag of conventional refined C&H sugar was produced. This is why specific labeling becomes critical for consumers who wish to avoid bone char.
Which C&H Sugar Products Are Bone Char-Free?
Fortunately, for consumers looking to avoid bone char, C&H does offer products that do not use this process. Your best strategy is to look for these specific labels on the packaging:
- Certified Organic Sugar: By USDA standards, certified organic sugar cannot be processed using bone char. Therefore, C&H's Certified Organic Sugar is a safe choice.
- Washed Raw Sugar: According to reports, specific C&H Washed Raw Sugar is processed without bone char filtration, though availability can be limited.
- Beet Sugar: While C&H exclusively sells cane sugar, it's worth noting that any product labeled as 100% beet sugar is always bone char-free. Beet sugar does not require the extensive decolorization process that cane sugar often does.
Comparing C&H Sugars and Alternatives
To better understand your options, here is a comparison of different sugar types and how they are processed with regard to bone char.
| Sugar Type | Source | Uses Bone Char? | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| C&H Conventional White Sugar | Cane | Yes, likely | Refined to achieve its white color. |
| C&H Conventional Brown Sugar | Cane | Yes, likely | Refined white sugar with molasses added back. |
| C&H Certified Organic Sugar | Cane | No | Organic certification prohibits the use of bone char. |
| C&H Washed Raw Sugar | Cane | No | Processed without bone char, though availability varies. |
| Beet Sugar | Beets | No | Never filtered using bone char during its refining process. |
| Turbinado Sugar | Cane | No | A raw sugar with molasses left on; not put through bone char filters. |
Finding Vegan Alternatives to C&H Sugar
If you prefer to avoid C&H products altogether due to bone char use, there are many alternatives available. Beyond checking for C&H's specific organic and raw varieties, consider these options:
- 100% Beet Sugar: Many store-brand granulated sugars in the Midwest and other parts of the U.S. are 100% beet sugar and are therefore bone char-free. Some brands specifically label their product as beet sugar.
- Wholesome Sweeteners: This brand is known for its wide range of vegan-friendly and organic sugar products.
- Florida Crystals®: As a sister company to C&H under ASR Group, Florida Crystals offers bone char-free options, including organic and conventional varieties.
- Sugar in the Raw: A turbinado sugar product, it does not use bone char during its processing.
- Coconut Sugar: Made from the sap of coconut palms, this unrefined sweetener is naturally bone char-free.
For more information on sugar production and vegan standards, a reliable resource is The Vegetarian Resource Group at https://www.vrg.org.
Conclusion
In summary, while C&H Sugar uses bone char in the processing of its standard refined white and brown sugars, it also offers vegan-friendly options for ethical consumers. To ensure your purchase is bone char-free, always opt for C&H's Certified Organic or Washed Raw sugar varieties. Alternatively, choosing 100% beet sugar or brands specifically marketed as vegan provides a sure way to avoid any animal-derived processing aids. Being a conscious consumer involves staying informed about food production practices, and with a little label reading, it's simple to find a sugar that aligns with your values.