Skip to content

Do Shake Shack do milkshakes? An in-depth look at their signature shakes

3 min read

First established as a humble hot dog cart in 2001, Shake Shack expanded its menu to include its now-iconic milkshakes when it opened its first permanent kiosk in 2004. Since then, the brand has become renowned for these thick, hand-spun treats, which are a signature part of their offerings today.

Quick Summary

Shake Shack offers a variety of hand-spun milkshakes made from its rich, dense frozen custard, alongside a rotating selection of seasonal and limited-edition flavors. The core menu features classics like vanilla and chocolate, with malting available. These premium-ingredient shakes are a beloved complement to the chain's savory items.

Key Points

  • Signature Shakes: Shake Shack is well-known for its hand-spun milkshakes, which are a signature part of its menu.

  • Frozen Custard Base: The key ingredient is house-made frozen custard, giving the shakes a denser, richer, and creamier texture than typical ice cream.

  • Classic & Seasonal Flavors: The menu includes classic flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and black & white, along with a rotating selection of limited-edition options.

  • Quality Ingredients: Shake Shack uses premium ingredients, including real sugar and milk without artificial hormones, to create their shakes.

  • Malted Option: Customers can order any classic shake to be malted, adding a toasted flavor.

  • Founded with Shakes: The restaurant added milkshakes to its menu when it became a permanent kiosk in Madison Square Park in 2004, solidifying their importance from the beginning.

In This Article

Shake Shack's Core Milkshake Offerings

The short answer is a resounding yes, Shake Shack absolutely does milkshakes, and they are a cornerstone of the brand's identity. Made with high-quality, house-made frozen custard spun fresh daily, their milkshakes are thicker and richer than standard fast-food varieties. This custard, a blend of milk, cream, and egg yolk, gives the shakes their signature dense and creamy texture. While the specific menu can vary by location and season, a few classic flavors are almost always available across Shake Shack's global presence.

Classic Shake Flavors

The permanent shake menu provides a foundation of timeless options. Many are variations on vanilla and chocolate, showcasing the versatility of the custard base.

  • Vanilla Shake: A creamy and straightforward classic made with real vanilla.
  • Chocolate Shake: A rich and decadent chocolate shake, praised by fans for its flavor.
  • Black & White Shake: A fan-favorite blend of vanilla custard and rich chocolate fudge sauce.
  • Cookies & Cream Shake: Vanilla custard hand-spun with chocolate cookie crumbles.
  • Strawberry Shake: Real strawberries are blended with the vanilla frozen custard.
  • Coffee Shake: Features dark roast coffee blended into the vanilla frozen custard.

The Difference: Frozen Custard vs. Ice Cream

To truly appreciate what makes Shake Shack's milkshakes so special, it's helpful to understand the primary ingredient: frozen custard. Unlike standard ice cream, which uses only milk and cream, frozen custard is made with the addition of pasteurized egg yolks. This ingredient provides a smoother, denser, and richer consistency, with less air whipped into the final product. Shake Shack is committed to using premium ingredients, with no corn syrup in its vanilla and chocolate custard. This focus on quality ingredients translates directly into a more flavorful and luxurious milkshake experience.

Seasonal and Limited-Time Shake Flavors

Beyond the standard menu, Shake Shack frequently introduces creative seasonal and limited-edition shakes to keep things exciting. These offerings often incorporate unique ingredients and flavor combinations. For example, past and potential future seasonal shakes might include:

  • Campfire S'mores Shake: Featuring vanilla frozen custard blended with graham crackers, chocolate, and marshmallow fudge chunks.
  • Triple Chocolate Brownie Shake: Made with vanilla custard, brownies, fudge, and chocolate chunks.
  • Mint Cookies & Cream: A refreshing take on a classic flavor combination.

These limited-time options provide a reason for repeat visits and allow customers to try something new, often tied to specific seasons or partnerships. Customers can check the menu online or at their local Shack to see the current seasonal offerings.

Customization and Malted Options

Shake Shack also allows for some customization of their shakes. A popular option is to have any classic shake made malted. A malted shake adds a distinctive, toasted flavor that many people enjoy. Customers can also ask for specific mix-ins or variations, though options may be limited depending on the location. This level of personalization allows customers to create their ideal shake.

The Milkshake Menu: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature Shake Shack Milkshake Standard Fast Food Milkshake
Base Dense, rich, house-made frozen custard (includes egg yolks) Standard, airy soft-serve ice cream
Texture Thicker, smoother, and creamier with a velvet-like consistency Lighter, thinner, and less dense due to more air
Ingredients Premium, with real sugar, no corn syrup, and cage-free eggs for vanilla and chocolate custard Often made with corn syrup and artificial ingredients
Flavor Variety A robust menu of classic, seasonal, and unique limited-time flavors A more basic, consistent menu with fewer options
Hand-Spun Shakes are hand-spun to order Often machine-made with a pre-mixed shake base

Conclusion: The Shack's Iconic Shakes

To conclude, Shake Shack is not only in the business of making milkshakes, but it has also elevated the fast-food milkshake into a premium dessert category. From its humble beginnings as a hot dog cart that expanded its menu to include its signature frozen custard shakes, the company has always put a high emphasis on quality ingredients and flavor. The foundation of rich, hand-spun frozen custard, combined with classic, limited-edition, and customizable flavor options, solidifies Shake Shack's reputation as a go-to destination for a decadent and delicious shake. Whether you prefer the timeless simplicity of a vanilla shake or are eager to try a new seasonal creation, Shake Shack offers a shake for every taste. For more on the brand's history and values, you can visit their website.

Shake Shack Official Website

Frequently Asked Questions

Shake Shack milkshakes are made with house-made frozen custard, not standard ice cream. Frozen custard is a richer and denser frozen dessert that includes egg yolks, giving the shakes their extra creamy texture.

Frozen custard is a type of frozen dessert similar to ice cream but made with milk, cream, and egg yolks. This ingredient combination results in a smoother, richer, and denser product than regular ice cream.

Shake Shack offers classic flavors such as vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, black & white, cookies & cream, and coffee. They also introduce new seasonal and limited-edition flavors throughout the year.

Yes, Shake Shack offers the option to 'make it malted' with any of their classic hand-spun milkshakes.

No, while both are made with frozen custard, they are different. A milkshake is hand-spun and sipped, while a concrete is a very thick dessert blended with mix-ins and typically eaten with a spoon.

Milkshakes were added to the menu in 2004 when Shake Shack moved from a hot dog cart to a permanent kiosk in New York's Madison Square Park.

No, Shake Shack sources its dairy from farmers who pledge not to use artificial growth hormones, ensuring premium ingredients in their vanilla and chocolate custards.

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.