Skip to content

Does 5 Guys Give a Lot of Fries? The Generous Scoop Explained

7 min read

Since 1986, it has been a tradition at Five Guys to include an extra scoop of fries with every order. This practice, often referred to as the 'topper,' is a strategic move designed to make customers feel like they are receiving an exceptional value. So, when you ask, 'Does 5 Guys give a lot of fries?', the resounding answer is yes, and it's by design.

Quick Summary

Five Guys intentionally includes an extra scoop of fries in every order to create the illusion of receiving more for your money. This well-established psychological tactic is already factored into menu prices, making generous portions a key part of their brand identity and customer experience.

Key Points

  • Generous Portions: Five Guys intentionally provides extra fries, often referred to as a 'topper,' with every order.

  • Marketing Strategy: This over-filling is a deliberate psychological tactic to make customers feel they are getting an excellent deal.

  • Factored into Price: The cost of the extra fries is already included in the menu pricing, so it is not a free bonus.

  • Consistency: Providing abundant fries has been a Five Guys tradition since 1986.

  • Customer Perception: The overflowing bag enhances the customer's perceived value and contributes to brand loyalty.

  • Portion Control Hack: You can request "no topper" to receive only the fries that fit inside the cup.

In This Article

The Strategy Behind the Generous Fry Portions

It's a familiar sight for Five Guys diners: a cup full of perfectly cooked fries, with a heaping scoop of extra fries piled into the bottom of the brown paper bag. This 'topper' is not a mistake or a kind gesture from an overly-generous employee, but a calculated marketing strategy. By providing such an abundant serving, Five Guys cultivates a sense of value and customer satisfaction that differentiates them from competitors. Founder Jerry Murrell famously stated that he wants customers to feel like they received too many fries, training his managers that if no one is complaining about the portion size, they aren't serving enough.

Why Do They Do It? The Psychology of Perceived Value

The core of Five Guys' fry strategy lies in a psychological principle known as perceived value. Even though the extra fries are already factored into the total price, customers feel as though they are getting a bargain or an unexpected bonus. This positive feeling encourages repeat business and positive word-of-mouth marketing, turning customers into brand advocates. The fries, which are relatively inexpensive to produce, become a powerful tool for brand loyalty. The overflowing portions contribute to the company's identity as a place that offers high-quality food with generous, satisfying servings.

Breaking Down the Fry Preparation

Five Guys takes its fry preparation very seriously, and it's a key part of what makes their fries so beloved. The process involves several steps:

  • Sourcing: Five Guys sources its potatoes from farms located north of the 42nd parallel, which is known for producing high-quality potatoes.
  • Hand-Cut: The potatoes are hand-cut daily in each restaurant, ensuring freshness and consistency.
  • Soaking: The cut potatoes are soaked in water to remove excess starch, which helps create a crispier final product.
  • Double Cooking: The fries are cooked twice in 100% refined peanut oil. The first cook, or 'pre-cook,' par-fries the potatoes. The second, or 'final cook,' is done just before serving to achieve the iconic firm exterior and soft, mashed potato-like interior.

Comparison: Five Guys vs. Other Fast Food Fries

To understand just how generous the portion sizes are, a comparison to other fast-food chains is essential. The following table highlights the differences in approach and portion size perception.

Feature Five Guys McDonald's Burger King
Portion Size Perception Abundant, overflowing, with an extra scoop in the bag. Standardized, consistent, and predictable portion sizes. Standardized portions, but often perceived as smaller than Five Guys'.
Cost Strategy Higher overall menu price with fries factored in, relying on perceived value for satisfaction. Lower individual item prices, focusing on value bundles and combos. Similar to McDonald's, uses value meals to drive sales.
Fries Composition Hand-cut, fresh potatoes, twice-cooked in peanut oil for a unique texture. Processed from potato granules and cooked in a blend of oils for consistent crispiness. Processed fries cooked in a blend of oils, with a slightly different flavor profile.
Brand Identity Known for fresh ingredients, generous portions, and a 'more is more' philosophy. Known for speed, consistency, and low prices. Focuses on value and flame-grilled taste.
Customer Feeling Happy, satisfied, and feeling like they got a good deal. A standard, predictable side that meets expectations. A standard side, often overshadowed by the burger itself.

Can You Get Less Fries? A Hack for Controlling Portions

For some, the sheer volume of fries at Five Guys can be overwhelming. A former employee revealed a simple way to get a more standard-sized portion: order your fries "with no topper". This request ensures you will receive only the fries that fit into the cup, omitting the extra scoop in the bag. It's a useful tip for anyone watching their portion sizes or simply trying to avoid food waste.

Conclusion: More than Just Fries

The generous fry portions at Five Guys are no accident; they are a deliberate, well-executed marketing strategy that has become a core part of the brand's identity. By creating the illusion of over-delivery, Five Guys builds customer loyalty and enhances the overall dining experience. The overflow of hand-cut fries, served piping hot in a simple paper bag, has become a trademark of the Five Guys experience, making the question "Does 5 Guys give a lot of fries?" one of the most delightfully answered in fast-food culture.

The Financial Calculation

While the practice seems purely generous, it's also financially sound. As one Quora user explained, potatoes and soda are the cheapest items on a fast-food menu. By pricing the burgers higher to cover costs, the company can afford to be generous with the low-cost, high-volume fries. This allows Five Guys to create a reputation for abundance without significantly impacting their bottom line. The psychological impact on the customer is the real ROI, making them feel they received more than their money's worth and justifying the overall price. This savvy business model proves that sometimes, the best marketing is the simplest: giving the customer a little bit more. https://www.fiveguys.com/support-hub/faqs/

Does 5 Guys give a lot of fries? The Generous Scoop Explained

It's a familiar sight for Five Guys diners: a cup full of perfectly cooked fries, with a heaping scoop of extra fries piled into the bottom of the brown paper bag. This 'topper' is not a mistake or a kind gesture from an overly-generous employee, but a calculated marketing strategy. By providing such an abundant serving, Five Guys cultivates a sense of value and customer satisfaction that differentiates them from competitors. Founder Jerry Murrell famously stated that he wants customers to feel like they received too many fries, training his managers that if no one is complaining about the portion size, they aren't serving enough.

Why Do They Do It? The Psychology of Perceived Value

The core of Five Guys' fry strategy lies in a psychological principle known as perceived value. Even though the extra fries are already factored into the total price, customers feel as though they are getting a bargain or an unexpected bonus. This positive feeling encourages repeat business and positive word-of-mouth marketing, turning customers into brand advocates. The fries, which are relatively inexpensive to produce, become a powerful tool for brand loyalty. The overflowing portions contribute to the company's identity as a place that offers high-quality food with generous, satisfying servings.

Breaking Down the Fry Preparation

Five Guys takes its fry preparation very seriously, and it's a key part of what makes their fries so beloved. The process involves several steps:

  • Sourcing: Five Guys sources its potatoes from farms located north of the 42nd parallel, which is known for producing high-quality potatoes.
  • Hand-Cut: The potatoes are hand-cut daily in each restaurant, ensuring freshness and consistency.
  • Soaking: The cut potatoes are soaked in water to remove excess starch, which helps create a crispier final product.
  • Double Cooking: The fries are cooked twice in 100% refined peanut oil. The first cook, or 'pre-cook,' par-fries the potatoes. The second, or 'final cook,' is done just before serving to achieve the iconic firm exterior and soft, mashed potato-like interior.

Comparison: Five Guys vs. Other Fast Food Fries

To understand just how generous the portion sizes are, a comparison to other fast-food chains is essential. The following table highlights the differences in approach and portion size perception.

Feature Five Guys McDonald's Burger King
Portion Size Perception Abundant, overflowing, with an extra scoop in the bag. Standardized, consistent, and predictable portion sizes. Standardized portions, but often perceived as smaller than Five Guys'.
Cost Strategy Higher overall menu price with fries factored in, relying on perceived value for satisfaction. Lower individual item prices, focusing on value bundles and combos. Similar to McDonald's, uses value meals to drive sales.
Fries Composition Hand-cut, fresh potatoes, twice-cooked in peanut oil for a unique texture. Processed from potato granules and cooked in a blend of oils for consistent crispiness. Processed fries cooked in a blend of oils, with a slightly different flavor profile.
Brand Identity Known for fresh ingredients, generous portions, and a 'more is more' philosophy. Known for speed, consistency, and low prices. Focuses on value and flame-grilled taste.
Customer Feeling Happy, satisfied, and feeling like they got a good deal. A standard, predictable side that meets expectations. A standard side, often overshadowed by the burger itself.

Can You Get Less Fries? A Hack for Controlling Portions

For some, the sheer volume of fries at Five Guys can be overwhelming. A former employee revealed a simple way to get a more standard-sized portion: order your fries "with no topper". This request ensures you will receive only the fries that fit into the cup, omitting the extra scoop in the bag. It's a useful tip for anyone watching their portion sizes or simply trying to avoid food waste.

Conclusion: More than Just Fries

The generous fry portions at Five Guys are no accident; they are a deliberate, well-executed marketing strategy that has become a core part of the brand's identity. By creating the illusion of over-delivery, Five Guys builds customer loyalty and enhances the overall dining experience. The overflow of hand-cut fries, served piping hot in a simple paper bag, has become a trademark of the Five Guys experience, making the question "Does 5 Guys give a lot of fries?" one of the most delightfully answered in fast-food culture.

The Financial Calculation

While the practice seems purely generous, it's also financially sound. As one Quora user explained, potatoes and soda are the cheapest items on a fast-food menu. By pricing the burgers higher to cover costs, the company can afford to be generous with the low-cost, high-volume fries. This allows Five Guys to create a reputation for abundance without significantly impacting their bottom line. The psychological impact on the customer is the real ROI, making them feel they received more than their money's worth and justifying the overall price. This savvy business model proves that sometimes, the best marketing is the simplest: giving the customer a little bit more. https://www.fiveguys.com/support-hub/faqs/

Frequently Asked Questions

Five Guys adds an extra scoop of fries, known as a 'topper,' to every order to make customers feel like they are getting a great deal and more for their money.

No, the cost of the extra fries is already factored into the overall menu price. It's a psychological tactic to create the illusion of receiving more than you paid for.

Yes, providing the extra scoop of fries has been a tradition at Five Guys since its founding in 1986 and is part of their standard procedure.

Yes, regardless of whether you order a small, regular, or large fry, you will receive an extra scoop of fries in the bag. The size of the 'topper' varies slightly with the order size.

To get a smaller, more standard portion, you can request your fries "with no topper." This tells employees to only fill the cup and not add the extra scoop to the bag.

Five Guys cooks their fries in 100% refined peanut oil. This oil is used for both the pre-cooking and final cooking stages.

Five Guys states that their fries are prepared with fresh potatoes and cooked in 100% peanut oil. The fries themselves are gluten-free, but cross-contamination is a risk in the kitchen environment.

Since Five Guys fries are not heavily breaded, they absorb less oil. The hot, fresh fries are served in an open cup with a topper in the bag, which can cause some oil to seep through the paper bag.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.