What Is MSG?
Monosodium glutamate, or MSG, is the sodium salt of glutamic acid, a common and naturally occurring amino acid. It is used as a flavor enhancer to intensify the savory, or umami, taste in food. Glutamate is found naturally in a huge variety of foods, from meat and cheese to tomatoes and mushrooms. While the commercial product is made through fermentation, the body metabolizes added MSG and natural glutamate in the exact same way. The widespread association of MSG with Chinese food is largely due to historical misinformation and prejudice.
The Myth of Chinese Restaurant Syndrome
The widespread fear of MSG largely stems from a 1968 letter published in the New England Journal of Medicine. An individual described experiencing symptoms like numbness and heart palpitations after eating at a Chinese restaurant and speculated that MSG could be the cause. This anecdote, combined with anti-Asian sentiment prevalent at the time, fueled the concept of 'Chinese Restaurant Syndrome'. Despite extensive scientific research, this syndrome has been debunked, and no reliable link between MSG consumption and these symptoms has been consistently established.
Where the Fear Came From
- Anecdotal evidence: The initial rumor was based on a single letter, not scientific studies.
- Media amplification: The media picked up the story and amplified the fears, ignoring the lack of scientific backing.
- Racial bias: Anti-Chinese and anti-Asian prejudice of the era played a significant role in vilifying Chinese cuisine and the ingredients used.
Natural vs. Added Glutamate
It's important to understand the difference between intentionally added MSG and glutamate that occurs naturally in many ingredients. Many foods common in Chinese cuisine and around the world are naturally rich in glutamate, which provides a savory flavor even without any added MSG.
Natural sources of glutamate
- Soy Sauce: A staple in Asian cooking, soy sauce is a fermented product with high levels of natural glutamate.
- Mushrooms: Dried and fresh mushrooms, especially shiitake, are a potent source of umami flavor.
- Seaweed: A traditional ingredient in East Asian broths, seaweed was the original source from which MSG was isolated.
- Tomatoes: Used in countless cuisines globally, tomatoes have high levels of natural glutamate, contributing to their deep flavor.
- Cheese: Aged cheeses like Parmesan are packed with natural glutamate, which is why they are so savory.
The Restaurant Practice: A Mixed Bag
While it is a myth that all Chinese restaurants use MSG, the practice is not uncommon, especially in Americanized Chinese restaurants where it is used for efficiency and cost-effectiveness. However, it is far from an exclusively Chinese practice, with many processed foods and other cuisines using it as well. Many higher-end or more traditional restaurants achieve deep flavor profiles using time-intensive methods and high-quality ingredients, not relying on added MSG. Customers can and should inquire if a restaurant uses MSG and can often request it to be omitted from their dish.
| Feature | Restaurants that use added MSG | Restaurants that do not use added MSG |
|---|---|---|
| Flavor Profile | Rapidly enhances umami flavor. Can sometimes produce a generic savory taste if overused. | Builds deep umami flavor from high-quality, whole ingredients, such as stocks, fermented sauces, and fresh produce. |
| Cooking Process | May be added as a shortcut to boost flavor, particularly in milder sauces or broths. | Relies on fresh ingredients, skilled technique, and longer cooking processes to develop complex flavors naturally. |
| Natural Glutamate | Still present in ingredients like soy sauce, even if extra MSG is not added. | Still present in ingredients like soy sauce, mushrooms, and other umami-rich components. |
| Marketing | May or may not disclose its use. Some may use pre-made sauces or seasoning packets that contain MSG. | May advertise 'No Added MSG' to appeal to health-conscious customers. |
The Verdict: Dispelling the Myth
The notion that all Chinese food contains MSG is a simplified and false stereotype with roots in xenophobia. Glutamate is a natural part of many global cuisines, and whether added artificially or present naturally, it is a safe ingredient for the vast majority of the population. The deep, savory flavors of Chinese food come from a combination of fresh ingredients, time-honored cooking techniques, and fermented products rich in natural glutamate. The best way to know what is in your food is to ask your chef or opt for fresh, unprocessed ingredients when cooking at home.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the belief that all Chinese food contains MSG is a myth fueled by historical bias and misinformation. While MSG is a common food additive used in some Chinese restaurants, it is also widely used in processed foods and other cuisines worldwide. Glutamate, the key component of MSG, is a naturally occurring compound found in many traditional Chinese ingredients like soy sauce and mushrooms. The human body processes natural and added glutamate identically, and regulatory bodies have deemed it safe for consumption. Ultimately, the savory taste of Chinese cuisine is a testament to its rich ingredients and culinary techniques, not solely a reliance on a single additive.