Skip to content

Does EDTA in Canned Food Inhibit Mineral Absorption?

3 min read

According to the U.S. FDA, calcium disodium EDTA is safe within regulated limits, typically approved up to 165 ppm in foods. This compound is used to prevent spoilage, but a common concern is whether EDTA in canned food inhibits mineral absorption.

Quick Summary

This article explores the effects of EDTA in canned foods, differentiating between types and addressing its minimal impact on mineral absorption at low, regulated levels. It clarifies its role as a preservative and chelating agent.

Key Points

  • Minimal Absorption: Only a very small amount of ingested EDTA is absorbed by the digestive tract, with the majority being excreted, posing a minimal risk of affecting mineral levels in healthy individuals.

  • Acts as a Chelating Agent: The primary function of food-grade EDTA is to bind to trace metal ions in the food itself, preventing oxidative reactions that cause spoilage, discoloration, and loss of flavor.

  • Regulated and Safe: The U.S. FDA and other regulatory bodies have approved EDTA for use in food within strict, safe limits, determining that at these low levels, it is not harmful to health.

  • Can Enhance Iron Absorption: When used as a fortificant (specifically NaFeEDTA), EDTA can actually increase the bioavailability and absorption of iron, especially from plant-based diets high in mineral-inhibiting compounds like phytates.

  • No Effect on Other Minerals: Studies in infants and adults have shown that at typical food-use levels, EDTA does not significantly impact the absorption of other key minerals like zinc, copper, or calcium.

  • Potential for High Doses: Concerns about mineral depletion are associated with extremely high-dose intake (often used in chelation therapy for heavy metal poisoning) and not with the minimal amounts found in canned goods.

  • Specific Health Conditions: Animal studies suggest that in the presence of severe intestinal inflammation, EDTA at high doses could be detrimental, though this is not applicable to the general healthy population.

In This Article

Understanding EDTA: What It Is and Why It's in Canned Food

EDTA, or ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid, is a widely used food additive and chelating agent that binds to metal ions to prevent oxidative degradation, preserving color, flavor, and shelf life in canned goods. Calcium disodium EDTA (CaNa2EDTA) is the common food-approved form.

The Mechanism of Chelation and Mineral Interaction

CaNa2EDTA binds to excess metal ions in food and the bond with calcium is weak enough to break during digestion. EDTA is poorly absorbed, with only about 5% entering the bloodstream before rapid kidney excretion. Most passes through the body, not significantly affecting mineral balance at regulated levels. Ferric sodium EDTA (NaFeEDTA) is used in fortification and can enhance iron absorption, especially in meals high in phytates, which inhibit mineral uptake.

Scientific Findings on EDTA and Mineral Absorption

Studies show minimal impact of food-level EDTA on mineral absorption in humans. For instance, a 2005 study found NaFeEDTA did not affect the absorption of zinc, copper, calcium, or magnesium in infants. Another study in Mexican women showed no significant difference in zinc absorption with added EDTA in tortillas. These findings indicate minimal risk of mineral deficiency in healthy individuals from EDTA in canned food. However, high doses or pre-existing intestinal inflammation may pose issues. A 2021 animal study on inflammatory bowel disease models showed high doses of EDTA worsened inflammation, but these doses were far above typical food exposure.

Comparison of Mineral Absorption with and without EDTA

Feature Mineral Absorption with Food-Level EDTA Mineral Absorption without EDTA
Mineral Chelation Binds excess free metal ions in the food to prevent spoilage. Naturally occurring inhibitors like phytates can bind to minerals, reducing absorption.
Effect on Iron Sodium iron EDTA (NaFeEDTA) can significantly increase iron absorption, especially in plant-based, high-phytate meals. Iron absorption can be inhibited by natural compounds such as phytic acid in plant-based foods.
Effect on Other Minerals (Zinc, Calcium) Human studies show no significant impact on the absorption of zinc, copper, or calcium at food-grade levels. Absorption is dependent on the overall meal composition, including other dietary factors.
Excretion Over 95% of ingested EDTA is poorly absorbed and rapidly excreted by the kidneys. The body regulates mineral excretion as part of its normal metabolic processes.
Health Context Generally safe for healthy individuals, as demonstrated by regulatory approvals and long-term use. Absorption is a normal physiological process, though it can be influenced by diet and individual health.

Potential Concerns and Regulatory Standards

While generally recognized as safe (GRAS), concerns exist regarding high doses of disodium EDTA potentially causing digestive upset and mineral depletion. However, the amounts in canned foods are significantly lower than adverse effect levels seen in animal studies, which can be 100 times the acceptable daily intake (ADI) for humans. Regulatory bodies like the EFSA and U.S. FDA set strict limits on EDTA use in food. Choosing fresh, whole foods can help reduce intake of food additives.

Conclusion

Research and regulation confirm that EDTA in canned food does not inhibit mineral absorption in healthy individuals at approved levels. It acts as a preservative by binding metals, and its poor absorption prevents interference with mineral balance. Certain EDTA compounds can even boost iron bioavailability. While very high doses could disrupt mineral status, typical dietary exposure is safe.

How to Check for EDTA in Your Food

Check food labels for "Calcium Disodium EDTA" or "Disodium EDTA". In some countries, it may be listed as E385. Choosing fresh foods avoids additives. Manufacturers can provide information if labels are unclear.

Center for Science in the Public Interest: EDTA is a good resource for further information on food additives.

A Final Note for Specific Health Conditions

EDTA in canned food is not a concern for healthy people. However, those with chronic intestinal inflammation should consult a healthcare professional, as high-dose animal studies suggest potential exacerbation of inflammation, though these levels exceed typical dietary intake. A balanced, whole-food diet is key for optimal mineral intake for most consumers.

Frequently Asked Questions

EDTA (ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid) is a chelating agent used as a preservative in canned food. It binds to trace metal ions, which prevents them from causing spoilage, discoloration, and rancidity, thereby extending shelf life.

No, at the low, regulated levels found in canned food, EDTA does not cause mineral deficiencies in healthy individuals. The compound is poorly absorbed and rapidly excreted, and it is the calcium-bound form (CaNa2EDTA) that is typically used, further reducing any potential for it to deplete minerals.

No, studies indicate that at standard dietary levels, EDTA has no significant effect on the absorption of minerals like zinc, copper, or calcium. However, specific compounds like sodium iron EDTA are sometimes used to enhance the absorption of iron.

For healthy individuals, EDTA is considered safe at the amounts found in food, according to the U.S. FDA and EFSA. However, in very high doses, it can cause digestive issues. Animal studies also suggest caution for individuals with pre-existing intestinal inflammation.

While it's the same chemical compound, the form and dosage are vastly different. The EDTA in food is a small, regulated amount, while chelation therapy involves high intravenous doses under medical supervision for treating heavy metal poisoning.

The most direct way to avoid EDTA is to choose fresh, unprocessed whole foods over canned or heavily processed products. Always check the ingredient list on packaged goods for 'Calcium Disodium EDTA' or 'Disodium EDTA'.

Yes, regulatory bodies like the FDA and JECFA have evaluated and deemed EDTA safe for consumption within approved limits across different age groups, including infants and children.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.