Understanding Red 33: A Global Perspective on Carmoisine
Red 33 is a synthetic red azo dye, also known as Carmoisine or E122, used to impart a pink, red, or maroon color to various products. Its status varies significantly depending on the country. While some nations have banned or restricted its use in foods, it remains a common colorant in many others. For consumers, this means that checking product labels is essential, especially when purchasing imported goods or traveling abroad.
Foods Containing Red 33 (Carmoisine)
In regions where it is approved for use, Red 33 is found in a wide range of food products, thanks to its low cost and high color intensity. Its water-solubility makes it a versatile ingredient for manufacturers. It is particularly common in items that are heat-processed or fermented.
Confectionery and Sweets:
- Colored candies, gummies, and lollipops.
- Jellies, jams, and fruit preparations.
- Pastries, cakes, and biscuit rolls.
Beverages:
- Fruit-based drinks, cordials, and some sodas.
- Flavored milk beverages, including strawberry milk.
- Certain alcoholic beverages, like fruit wines.
Dairy and Desserts:
- Some yogurts and flavored melted cheeses.
- Ice creams, puddings, and other desserts.
Processed Foods and Condiments:
- Processed fish products and crustacean pastes.
- Certain sauces and mustards.
- Some breakfast cereals with colorful pieces.
Differentiating Red 33 from Other Dyes
It is important not to confuse Red 33 with other red dyes, such as the now-banned Red 3 (Erythrosine) in the U.S. or the widely used Red 40 (Allura Red AC). Each of these dyes has a unique chemical composition and regulatory history. Red 33 is an azo dye, a class of synthetic colorants often scrutinized for potential health effects, though regulatory bodies in some regions, like the EFSA, have deemed it safe within specified limits.
Comparison of Common Red Dyes
| Feature | Red 33 (Carmoisine) | Red 3 (Erythrosine) | Red 40 (Allura Red AC) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classification | Azo dye, E122 | Xanthene dye, E127 | Azo dye, E129 |
| Regulatory Status (USA, 2025) | Not on approved food list | Banned in food and ingested drugs | Approved for use in food |
| Common Uses | Confectionery, drinks, dairy (where permitted) | Former use in maraschino cherries, candy | Wide range of foods, drinks, and cosmetics |
| Vegan Status | Vegan dye | Vegan dye | Vegan dye |
| Potential Health Concerns | Linked to hyperactivity in studies with benzoates | Linked to cancer in rat studies | Linked to hyperactivity in some studies |
How to Identify Red 33 on Labels
Navigating ingredient labels can be challenging, but there are specific names to look for. Red 33 will be listed under its common name, its E-number, or its specific chemical name.
- Carmoisine: The most common name for this food additive.
- E122: The European food additive numbering system designation.
- CI 17200: The Color Index International name, often used on cosmetics and sometimes mentioned for food-grade quality.
- Acid Red 14: Another name for the dye.
Potential Health Considerations
While approved for use by some regulatory bodies, some studies have raised concerns about the potential effects of azo dyes, including Carmoisine. Research, notably the Southampton study, suggested a link between artificial food colors (including some azo dyes like Carmoisine) and increased hyperactivity in children when consumed in conjunction with sodium benzoate. For those sensitive to salicylates or with asthma, azo dyes can sometimes elicit intolerance or allergic reactions. As with any food additive, individual reactions can vary.
The Vegan Status of Red 33
For those following a vegan diet, it's relevant to know that Red 33 is a synthetic dye and is not derived from animal products. Unlike some other red colorings, such as carmine (which is derived from cochineal beetles), Carmoisine is suitable for vegans and vegetarians. This distinction is important for those avoiding animal-derived ingredients for ethical or dietary reasons.
Conclusion: Informed Choices for the Aware Consumer
Understanding what foods contain Red 33 is the first step toward making informed dietary choices, particularly for those concerned about artificial additives. Because its use and regulations differ internationally, reading labels is the most reliable way to monitor intake. For consumers in regions where it is permitted, being aware of common product categories and the various names under which it appears is key. While regulatory bodies have established safety parameters, personal sensitivity and dietary preferences should always guide individual choices. With awareness, consumers can navigate the global food market confidently, whether avoiding Red 33 or simply understanding its presence in common products.
Center for Science in the Public Interest: The Red 3 Scandal