Understanding Phytic Acid and Phytase
Phytic acid, or phytate, is the primary storage form of phosphorus in many plants, especially grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds. It is considered an 'anti-nutrient' because it can bind to essential dietary minerals such as iron, zinc, calcium, and magnesium, making them less available for absorption by the body. Humans lack sufficient levels of the enzyme phytase in their digestive tracts to effectively break down phytic acid. Breakdown (dephytinization) is primarily achieved through specific food preparation techniques that activate the food's own enzymes or introduce external ones.
Key Factors Influencing Phytic Acid Breakdown
Several factors influence the effectiveness and speed of phytic acid reduction:
- Method: Soaking, sprouting, and fermentation have different effects.
- Food Type: Natural phytase content varies; rye and wheat are high, oats and brown rice are lower.
- Temperature: Phytase is most active in warm conditions (45-65°C / 113-149°F).
- pH Level: An acidic medium (pH 5.0-6.0) is ideal for phytase.
- Time: Duration of preparation correlates with reduction.
How Long to Break Down Phytic Acid: Method-Specific Timelines
Soaking Grains and Legumes
Soaking involves submerging food in water, often with an acidic medium, to activate natural phytase enzymes.
- Soaking Time: Typically 7-24 hours. Longer soaks (up to 36 hours for some legumes) with water changes may be used.
- Conditions: Warm water and adding acid (vinegar, lemon juice) increase efficiency. A study on chickpeas showed a 47-55% reduction with a 2-12 hour soak.
- Effectiveness: Best for foods with high inherent phytase like rye and wheat, and for beans/legumes.
Sprouting (Germination)
Sprouting activates natural phytase to break down phytic acid and release minerals.
- Sprouting Time: Significant reduction occurs within days. Malting millet for 72-96 hours reduced phytic acid by 23.9-45.3%. Significant reduction in cereals can take around 10 days.
- Process: Initial soaking (12-24 hours), followed by rinsing and keeping moist until sprouts appear.
- Benefits: Reduces phytic acid and can increase nutritional value.
Fermentation
Fermentation, especially lactic acid fermentation, is highly effective. Organic acids create an ideal environment for phytase.
- Fermentation Time: Sourdough bread fermented for 4-8 hours at a warm temperature can significantly reduce phytic acid in whole wheat (up to 60%+). Longer fermentation (around 12 hours) can almost eliminate phytates in whole rye bread.
- Mechanism: Uses both the food's enzymes and microbial phytases.
- Applicability: Excellent for flours (sourdough) and fermented products like tempeh.
Cooking and Pressure Cooking
Cooking alone offers moderate reduction, but it's less effective than other methods. Cooking legumes for an hour can reduce phytic acid up to 80%, especially after soaking. Pressure cooking is very effective, particularly after soaking.
Comparison of Phytic Acid Reduction Methods
| Method | Typical Duration | Effectiveness | Best For | Considerations | | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |\n| Soaking | 7-24 hours | Moderate to high | Legumes and high-phytase grains | Enhanced by warm, acidic water. Discard soaking water. |\n| Sprouting | 1-10 days | High | Grains, legumes, seeds | More labor-intensive but increases overall nutrition. |\n| Fermentation (Sourdough) | 4-12 hours | Very High | Flour, especially whole wheat and rye | Requires active starter; warm temperatures are beneficial. |\n| Cooking/Pressure Cooking | 1 hour+ | Moderate | Legumes | Less effective alone; best with prior soaking. |
Choosing the Right Method for Your Food
For daily cooking of legumes, overnight soaking and cooking are usually sufficient for a balanced diet. Sourdough fermentation is most effective for whole grain flours high in phytates like rye and wheat. Soaking and dehydrating nuts and seeds can be an option for large quantities. The best method depends on the food and dietary needs; those with mineral deficiencies or diets high in phytates may benefit from more aggressive techniques.
For brown rice, which has lower natural phytase, accelerated fermentation can be highly effective (up to 96% reduction). An 8-hour soak with an acidic medium also provides notable reduction before cooking.
Conclusion
Breaking down phytic acid is time and method-dependent. Soaking takes several hours, fermentation 4 to 24 hours, and sprouting multiple days. For most people with varied diets, traditional methods like soaking and cooking are adequate to improve mineral availability. However, individuals with specific concerns might benefit from longer or advanced techniques like fermentation. Proper food preparation helps maximize nutrient absorption from plant foods.