The Founding Fathers of Calorimetry
Joseph Black and Antoine Lavoisier
Scientific interest in heat and energy grew in the 18th century. Scottish chemist Joseph Black introduced the concepts of latent and specific heat around 1761, paving the way for later calorimetry. Building on this, French chemist Antoine Lavoisier and mathematician Pierre-Simon Laplace created the first ice calorimeter in the 1780s. This device measured heat by quantifying melted ice. They used it to show that respiration in a guinea pig was similar to combustion, comparing the animal's heat production to burning charcoal. Lavoisier coined the term 'calorimeter'.
The First Definition: Nicolas Clément
While Lavoisier provided the experimental basis, the term 'calorie' was formally defined by French chemist Nicolas Clément between 1819 and 1824. In lectures, he defined the calorie as the heat needed to raise the temperature of 1 kilogram of water by 1°C. This definition, corresponding to the modern kilocalorie, circulated among engineers and was later recognized in dictionaries, though it created confusion with the smaller calorie unit.
Refinement and Expansion in the 19th Century
The Mechanical Equivalent of Heat
In the 1840s, James Prescott Joule showed that mechanical work could generate heat, establishing the conservation of energy and demonstrating that heat is a form of energy. His work proved energy could be converted between forms.
The Birth of Nutritional Science
Applying calorimetry to nutrition advanced with German physiologists like Carl Voit and his student Max Rubner in the 1880s. Rubner built an advanced calorimeter and showed that the energy from burning food matched the energy from animal metabolism. His work solidified the understanding that bodies get energy from food's caloric content, establishing modern nutritional science.
Wilbur O. Atwater and the Bomb Calorimeter
The bomb calorimeter, developed by Pierre Eugene Berthelot in the 1870s, precisely measures food's energy content. It works by igniting a food sample in a sealed container within a water bath and measuring the water's temperature change. American chemist Wilbur Olin Atwater popularized this for nutrition in the late 19th century, analyzing many foods and developing the Atwater system of assigning caloric values to macronutrients.
The Lingering Confusion of 'Calorie'
Confusion has persisted due to the 'small calorie' (cal) and the 'large calorie' (Cal or kcal).
| Feature | Small Calorie (cal) | Large Calorie (kcal or Cal) | 
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Heat for 1 gram of water by 1°C. | Heat for 1 kilogram of water by 1°C. | 
| Relationship | 1000 small calories = 1 large calorie. | 1 large calorie = 1000 small calories. | 
| Usage Context | Chemistry/physics, largely replaced by joule. | Nutrition, simplified to "calorie" on labels. | 
| Energy Equivalence | 4.184 joules. | 4.184 kilojoules. | 
Marcellin Berthelot suggested using a capitalized 'Calorie' for the larger unit in the 1870s. This is common today, but scientists often prefer the joule (J), the SI unit for energy.
Conclusion: A Legacy of Measurement
From early ice calorimeters to modern bomb calorimeters, the discovery and measurement of calories have been vital to understanding heat, energy, and nutrition. The term's evolution reflects the interdisciplinary nature of science. Despite some historical confusion in terminology, the ability to quantify food energy remains a cornerstone of nutrition science.
Further Research
For those interested in a more in-depth look at the evolution of food energy units, including the work of Atwater, the following article provides extensive historical context: Does the history of food energy units suggest a solution to 'calorie confusion'?.