Sickness and Health-Related Exemptions
Islamic jurisprudence allows for breaking a fast due to various health conditions, based on the Quranic verse (Al-Baqarah: 184). The nature of the illness dictates the course of action.
Temporary Illness
Individuals with temporary illnesses like severe flu or fever who fear fasting will worsen their condition can break their fast. They must make up these fasts later (Qada). This applies to potential real harm, not minor discomfort.
Chronic or Permanent Illness
Those with chronic conditions posing significant health risks from fasting are permanently exempt. Instead of making up fasts, they pay Fidya, which is feeding one poor person per missed day.
Pregnancy and Breastfeeding
Pregnant and breastfeeding women are exempted if fasting might harm them or their baby. If the mother's health is at risk, she makes up the fast later. If only the baby's health is feared, she makes up the fasts and pays Fidya.
Travel and Other Conditions
Travel is another valid reason for exemption to ease hardship.
Valid Traveling Conditions
The journey must be long enough to shorten prayers and for a legitimate purpose. A traveler can choose whether to fast, but if fasting causes extreme difficulty, breaking it may be disliked or even obligatory. Opinions differ on breaking a fast if travel begins after dawn.
Menstruation and Post-natal Bleeding
Fasting is forbidden for women during menstruation or post-natal bleeding. They must break their fast and make up the missed days later.
Old Age
Elderly individuals who are too frail to fast are exempted and must pay Fidya for each missed day.
Comparison of Expiation and Compensation
Compensation for a broken fast varies depending on the reason. The table below outlines the actions required for different scenarios.
| Reason for Breaking Fast | Temporary Illness | Chronic Illness/Old Age | Pregnancy/Breastfeeding | Travel | Menstruation | Intentional Without Valid Excuse |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Action Required | Make up missed days (Qada) | Pay Fidya (feed one poor person per day) | Qada (and possibly Fidya if harm is feared for the baby) | Qada | Qada | Kaffarah (expiation) and sincere repentance |
| Conditions | Hope of recovery | No hope of recovery or extreme difficulty | Fear of harm to mother or baby | Meeting defined travel criteria | During menstrual cycle | Deliberate, without valid justification |
Other Situations
Other circumstances may permit or require breaking a fast.
Intense Hunger or Thirst
Breaking a fast is allowed for intense, unbearable hunger or thirst posing a serious health risk, with the day to be made up later.
Compulsion or Duress
Being forced to break a fast under threat is exempted from sin, but the fast must still be made up later.
Unintentional Breaking
Eating or drinking due to forgetfulness does not break the fast. The individual should continue fasting, as it's considered divine provision.
Conclusion
Islamic law offers merciful exemptions for breaking fasts due to illness, travel, pregnancy, and other hardships, ensuring health and safety are prioritized. Compensation like Qada or Fidya is required, while intentional breaking without valid reason necessitates Kaffarah. Understanding these rules helps Muslims observe their obligations responsibly. Consulting professionals is advisable for complex cases. For more information, the Zakat Foundation discusses valid exemptions for not fasting during Ramadan.(https://www.zakat.org/valid-exemptions-for-not-fasting-ramadan).