Cream of Chicken Soup vs. Broth-Based Chicken Soup: A Comparison for Colds
When dealing with a cold or cough, many turn to the soothing warmth of chicken soup. While traditional chicken soup is widely recommended, the cream-based version is a subject of debate. The primary concerns focus on its dairy content and its potential effects on mucus and congestion. Understanding the differences between these two soup types can help determine the best option when feeling under the weather.
The Science Behind Why Soup Helps
All warm soups offer general benefits when sick. The heat and steam can clear nasal passages and ease a sore throat. The liquid, whether broth or cream-based, aids in hydration, crucial for fighting infection and thinning mucus. Nutrient-rich ingredients, such as vegetables, garlic, and onions, provide antioxidants and vitamins that support the immune system.
The Case Against Cream-Based Soups
The primary reason some advise against cream of chicken soup for colds is its high dairy content. A widely held belief is that dairy products increase or thicken mucus, which can worsen congestion and cough symptoms. Some studies have investigated this claim; however, while evidence is mixed, some individuals report thicker mucus after consuming dairy. For those with severe chest congestion or a productive cough (a cough with phlegm), the added cream could potentially make the cough less effective. Additionally, cream-based soups often have more fat, which might not be ideal if the stomach is sensitive during an illness.
The Benefits of Broth-Based Soups
Broth-based chicken soups, typically featuring a clear broth with chicken, noodles, and vegetables, are traditionally favored for several reasons. The clear liquid is excellent for hydration and is less likely to exacerbate feelings of congestion. Homemade broth, especially if made from bones, may contain anti-inflammatory properties that can help reduce upper respiratory tract inflammation. The simple, non-fatty nature of broth also makes it easier to digest for a weakened stomach.
The Verdict on Cream of Chicken Soup
Is cream of chicken soup definitively off-limits? Not necessarily. The impact of dairy on mucus is highly individual. For those who do not experience increased congestion with dairy, warm, creamy soup can be comforting and provide much-needed calories and nutrients when a full meal is unappealing. A homemade version made with low-sodium chicken broth and a moderate amount of milk or cream can be a nutritious option. However, if the cold is marked by significant nasal or chest congestion, or if prone to thicker mucus when consuming dairy, a broth-based soup might be the safer and more effective choice for symptom relief. A lighter, homemade cream soup can also be made using coconut milk or a smaller amount of cream to get the creamy texture without much dairy.
Making the Right Choice: Factors to Consider
Selecting the right soup when sick depends on the symptoms and dietary needs. The best approach is to listen to the body and choose the soup that provides the most comfort and relief.
Symptom-Specific Considerations:
- For Nasal Congestion: Steam from any hot soup helps loosen mucus, but a broth-based soup avoids the potential for dairy to thicken it. Spices such as garlic, ginger, and hot peppers can also help clear sinuses.
- For Sore Throat: A smooth, creamy soup is soothing for an irritated throat, as its texture is gentle. However, any warm liquid provides relief.
- For Nausea or Upset Stomach: A light, broth-based soup is generally easier on the digestive system. Fatty, cream-based soups may be too rich.
- For Appetite Loss: The comforting and familiar taste of either soup can be beneficial. Cream of chicken soup provides more calories in a small serving, which is helpful when eating very little.
A Simple Comparison: Broth vs. Cream Soup
| Feature | Broth-Based Chicken Soup | Cream of Chicken Soup |
|---|---|---|
| Effect on Mucus | Thins mucus; generally better for congestion. | May thicken mucus in some individuals; not ideal for heavy phlegm. |
| Hydration | Excellent source of rehydrating fluids and electrolytes. | Good source of hydration, but rich texture may feel heavier. |
| Digestibility | Very easy to digest; light on the stomach. | Can be harder to digest due to higher fat content, especially if stomach is sensitive. |
| Nutrients | Rich in vitamins, minerals, and protein, especially if homemade with vegetables. | Provides protein and fat for energy, plus vitamins from added vegetables. |
| Comfort Factor | Provides a familiar, soothing warmth. | Offers a rich, decadent comfort, especially when a fuller meal is desired. |
Creating a Healthier, Homemade Cream of Chicken Soup
If preferring the creamy texture but having concerns about dairy, several alternatives are available. Using a dairy-free alternative such as unsweetened almond milk, coconut milk, or cashew cream creates a rich, soothing soup. Combining this with low-sodium chicken broth, lean chicken, and plenty of immune-boosting vegetables such as carrots, celery, and garlic results in a powerful meal for fighting off sickness. Focus on healing ingredients—the chicken, vegetables, and hydrating broth—and reducing any elements that may cause discomfort. The warmth and nourishment will remain, with the added benefit of avoiding a potential aggravator.
Conclusion
While traditional broth-based chicken soup is the preferred choice for cold and cough relief, cream of chicken soup isn't entirely off-limits, but there are considerations. The main risk is that dairy can thicken mucus for some people, which could worsen congestion and coughing. If dairy exacerbates symptoms, a clear, broth-based soup is the better option. However, if dairy does not negatively impact symptoms and there is a craving for extra richness and calories, a homemade cream of chicken soup with healthy ingredients can be a comforting, nutritious option. Ultimately, both offer crucial hydration and warmth to support recovery. The best choice is the one that offers the most comfort and aids in rest and healing.
Visit Healthline for more home remedies for cold and flu symptoms.
