Skip to content

Is filtered water the same as purified water? Understanding the key differences

5 min read

Over 1.1 billion people worldwide lack access to an improved drinking water supply, highlighting the critical importance of understanding water treatment methods. Deciphering if filtered water is the same as purified water is a crucial step towards making an informed choice for your personal health and nutrition.

Quick Summary

Explores the fundamental distinction between filtered and purified water, detailing the different processes, levels of contaminant removal, and impact on mineral content, enabling informed hydration decisions.

Key Points

  • Filtered vs. Purified: Filtered water removes larger particles and chemicals like chlorine, while purified water undergoes a more rigorous process to remove virtually all contaminants, including microscopic pathogens.

  • Purification Methods: Common purification methods include reverse osmosis, distillation, and deionization, which are more thorough than standard activated carbon filters used for filtration.

  • Mineral Content: Standard filtration typically retains healthy, naturally occurring minerals, whereas purification, especially reverse osmosis and distillation, can remove these beneficial minerals.

  • Safety vs. Taste: Purified water offers a higher level of safety for vulnerable individuals but can have a 'flat' taste; filtered water often tastes better and is sufficient for improving the quality of already safe tap water.

  • Maintenance is Key: Both systems require proper maintenance, as unmaintained filters can harbor bacteria and reduce effectiveness over time, potentially worsening water quality.

  • Informed Choice: Your best choice depends on local water quality, health needs, budget, and preference for mineral content, rather than assuming the terms are interchangeable.

In This Article

What is Filtered Water?

Water filtration is a treatment process that reduces or removes specific contaminants to improve water's taste, odor, appearance, and overall quality. This is achieved by physically or chemically reducing the presence of unwanted substances. In many cases, filtration is the first step in a more comprehensive water treatment process, acting as a line of defense against visible particles and common chemical contaminants.

Common Filtration Technologies

  • Mechanical Filtration: A straightforward method that physically traps contaminants based on their size. Sediment filters, for instance, remove larger particles like sand, silt, and rust, often serving as a pre-filter in multi-stage systems.
  • Absorption Filters: These rely on a medium like activated carbon, which uses adsorption to trap contaminants on its surface. Activated carbon is highly effective at removing chlorine, volatile organic compounds (VOCs), pesticides, and improving taste and odor.
  • Ceramic Filters: Made from a porous ceramic material, these filters can remove bacteria, protozoa, and larger sediment by blocking them from passing through.

Limitations of Filtration

While effective for many common issues, standard filtration systems are not foolproof. Their pore size is often too large to block microscopic contaminants like certain bacteria and viruses, which can pose risks if the goal is to make potentially unsafe water potable. Furthermore, if not regularly replaced, filters can become breeding grounds for bacteria, potentially making the water quality worse than the untreated tap water.

What is Purified Water?

Purified water undergoes a more rigorous process than filtration, designed to remove almost all impurities and contaminants. To be considered purified in the U.S., the water must have a Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) level no greater than 10 parts per million, a much stricter standard than for filtered water. This advanced treatment ensures a higher level of purity and safety, which is particularly beneficial in areas with questionable water quality.

Common Purification Technologies

  • Reverse Osmosis (RO): This advanced membrane filtration system forces water through a semi-permeable membrane that removes a wide array of contaminants, including heavy metals, salts, nitrates, and microscopic pathogens. A notable side effect is the removal of beneficial minerals.
  • Distillation: This process involves boiling water and collecting the resulting steam. Impurities with a higher boiling point than water are left behind in the boiling vessel, leaving behind very pure, demineralized water.
  • Deionization: A process using ion-exchange resins to remove charged ions from water. It's often used in conjunction with other methods to achieve a very high level of purity.
  • Ultraviolet (UV) Purification: Using UV-C light, this method inactivates bacteria, viruses, and other microorganisms by damaging their DNA. UV purification is highly effective against microbial risks but leaves no residual disinfectant and does not remove other types of contaminants.

Filtered Water vs. Purified Water: A Comparison

Feature Filtered Water Purified Water
Primary Process Physical barrier, activated carbon absorption Advanced processes like Reverse Osmosis, Distillation, or Deionization
Purity Level Reduces contaminants like chlorine, sediment, and some chemicals; taste and odor are improved Removes almost all contaminants, including bacteria, viruses, heavy metals, and dissolved solids
Mineral Content Generally retains natural, beneficial minerals like calcium and magnesium Most processes, especially RO and distillation, remove beneficial minerals along with contaminants
Cost Typically more affordable for initial setup and maintenance, especially for basic pitcher or faucet filters Higher initial investment for comprehensive systems like RO or distillation units
Taste Often has an improved, pleasant taste due to chlorine and impurity reduction Can have a 'flat' taste due to the removal of nearly all dissolved minerals
Key Concern May not protect against microscopic pathogens like bacteria and viruses if water is heavily contaminated Removal of beneficial minerals can be a consideration for some nutritional goals

Nutritional Impact: Choosing the Right Water for Your Diet

The choice between filtered and purified water often comes down to your personal health needs, local water quality, and nutritional goals. For many, the enhanced taste and reduced chlorine from a simple filter system are sufficient. Filtered water retains the natural mineral content, which can be a nutritional bonus, though the importance of minerals from water versus food is often debated. If your diet is rich in minerals, the trace amounts in water may be less critical. However, if you rely on mineral intake from your drinking water, a filter might be the better choice.

On the other hand, purified water, particularly through Reverse Osmosis, offers a significantly higher degree of contaminant removal. This is critical for individuals in areas with compromised water sources or those with weakened immune systems who need to minimize exposure to any potential pathogens. While purified water is exceptionally clean, the removal of minerals can change its taste profile, which some find bland. For those concerned about this, re-mineralization cartridges are available for some purification systems to add minerals back into the water.

Making an Informed Choice

To decide whether filtered or purified water is right for you, consider these factors:

  • Assess Your Water Source: The quality of your municipal tap water is the first and most important consideration. Some areas have higher levels of heavy metals, pesticides, or other contaminants, making a purifier a safer bet. A water quality report can provide detailed information about your local water supply.
  • Evaluate Your Health Needs: If you or a family member have a compromised immune system or are pregnant, a purification system that removes pathogens like bacteria and viruses offers greater peace of mind.
  • Consider Your Budget: Filtration systems typically have a lower entry and maintenance cost compared to whole-house or under-sink purification units. Weigh the long-term cost benefits, as both options are generally more cost-effective than relying on bottled water.
  • Prioritize Sustainability: Investing in either a filter or purifier reduces reliance on single-use plastic water bottles, significantly lowering your environmental footprint. The choice between filtered and purified water still offers a much more sustainable option than continuous bottled water consumption.

Conclusion

The question, “is filtered water the same as purified water?” has a clear answer: no. Filtered water uses a less intensive process to remove larger particles and improve taste, while purified water goes a step further by using advanced methods like reverse osmosis or distillation to eliminate nearly all contaminants, including microscopic ones. Your ideal choice depends on your starting water quality, specific health concerns, and personal preferences regarding taste and mineral content. By understanding these key distinctions, you can select the best option to meet the needs of your nutrition diet and ensure your hydration is as healthy as possible.

For more detailed information on municipal water standards in the United States, you can visit the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) website.

Frequently Asked Questions

Purified water is considered safer because it removes a higher percentage of contaminants, including microscopic organisms like viruses and bacteria. Filtered water is sufficient for improving the taste and odor of already safe tap water, but may not protect against pathogens in heavily contaminated sources.

Reverse osmosis (RO) is a process used to produce purified water. It uses a semi-permeable membrane to remove a very high percentage of dissolved solids and contaminants, which goes beyond standard filtration.

The main difference lies in the degree of processing. Filtration uses a porous medium to physically block particles, while purification adds more advanced stages, such as membrane separation (RO) or distillation, to remove nearly all impurities, including dissolved solids and pathogens.

Purification processes typically include filtration as an initial step. You do not need to re-filter water that has already been purified, as it has already undergone a much more thorough treatment.

Boiling water kills most heat-sensitive pathogens like bacteria and viruses, effectively sterilizing it. However, it does not remove chemical toxins, heavy metals, or dissolved solids, and can actually concentrate them as some water evaporates.

In processes like reverse osmosis and distillation, both beneficial and harmful minerals are removed, which can result in a 'flat' taste. Some advanced systems include a re-mineralization stage to add select minerals back to the water.

Both in-home filtration and purification systems are significantly more environmentally friendly than bottled water, as they reduce plastic waste. The environmental impact of producing the filter media or running the system is a factor, but far less than that of single-use plastic bottles.

Some people prefer filtered water because it retains the natural, healthy minerals that are removed during many purification processes. The taste is also often preferred, as it is not as 'stripped' of flavor as purified water can be.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.