Skip to content

Is Ice Lolly Good for Sickness? Understanding the Pros and Cons

4 min read

According to a 2024 survey, popsicles were listed among the top sick-day comfort foods for both children and adults. While ice lollies offer a soothing sensation for a sore throat and can help with hydration, their overall benefit for sickness depends on their ingredients and the specific illness. This article explores the pros and cons of using ice lollies for sickness and provides tips for choosing or making healthier options.

Quick Summary

This guide covers the advantages and disadvantages of eating ice lollies when you are sick, focusing on their role in soothing a sore throat, providing hydration, and offering calories when appetite is low. It details potential drawbacks like high sugar content and dairy. The article also provides a comparison table of different types of frozen treats.

Key Points

  • Hydration: Ice lollies are an excellent way to get fluids into someone who is sick, especially those with a fever or low appetite.

  • Sore Throat Relief: The cold sensation provides a temporary numbing effect that soothes a painful, inflamed throat.

  • Consider Sugar Content: Many commercial ice lollies are high in refined sugar, which can cause inflammation and weaken the immune system.

  • Choose or Make Healthy Options: Homemade ice lollies from 100% fruit juice, fruit puree, and electrolytes offer better nutritional value with less added sugar.

  • Beware of Dairy: Dairy-based frozen treats like ice cream can sometimes increase mucus thickness, potentially worsening congestion for some individuals.

  • Emotional Comfort: Eating a familiar, comforting treat like an ice lolly can provide a mental boost when feeling unwell.

  • Electrolytes are Beneficial: For significant fluid loss due to fever or vomiting, electrolyte-enhanced ice lollies help replenish essential minerals.

In This Article

The Soothing Benefits of Ice Lollies

When battling a cold, flu, or other illness, an ice lolly can provide several immediate benefits that contribute to overall comfort and recovery. The primary advantages relate to hydration and symptom relief. The cold temperature offers a numbing effect, which is particularly welcome for those suffering from a sore, inflamed throat. Sucking on a frozen treat can be more appealing than drinking plain water, especially for children who are reluctant to consume fluids when they feel unwell. This can help combat dehydration, a common risk with fevers and vomiting.

Furthermore, for individuals with a reduced appetite, a small frozen treat can provide a boost of energy from the sugar, helping to sustain the body while it fights off infection. For those experiencing nausea, cold, odorless foods like ice lollies can often be tolerated more easily than solid foods with strong smells. Electrolyte-infused ice lollies, which can be made at home, offer an even greater benefit by replenishing essential minerals lost through fever and sweating.

Potential Drawbacks and Healthier Alternatives

While ice lollies can be beneficial, they are not without their downsides. Many commercially available ice lollies are loaded with refined sugar, which can cause inflammation and potentially suppress the immune system's effectiveness. This can work against the body's healing process. Additionally, some ice lollies contain dairy, which can make mucus feel thicker for some people, worsening congestion and cough symptoms. Artificial colors and flavors are also common in store-bought varieties, and while their direct impact on illness recovery is debated, opting for natural ingredients is generally preferable.

For a healthier approach, consider homemade alternatives using 100% fruit juice, pureed fruit, and natural sweeteners like honey (avoiding honey for children under one year). These can provide vitamins and antioxidants along with hydration. For those concerned about sugar, low-sugar or no-sugar-added options are available, or you can even opt for plain ice chips for a simple, hydrating fix.

The Role of Ice Lollies in Different Illnesses

Not all sicknesses are the same, and the usefulness of an ice lolly can vary. For a sore throat, the numbing effect is often immediate and effective, regardless of the cause. When dealing with a fever, the cold treat helps with cooling and hydration. For gastrointestinal issues like a stomach bug or vomiting, starting with small, bland, and cold foods is often recommended. However, sugary treats can sometimes aggravate an upset stomach, so a simple ice lolly made from plain water or electrolyte solution is a safer bet.

It's important to listen to your body. Some people find that cold foods offer immense comfort, while others prefer warm liquids. Choosing what feels most soothing to you is key. The emotional comfort derived from a familiar, pleasant treat can also contribute positively to your mental well-being when you are feeling ill.

Comparison Table: Frozen Treats for Sickness

Feature Commercial Ice Lolly Homemade Fruit Pop Frozen Yogurt/Ice Cream Electrolyte Popsicle
Primary Benefit Soothing, hydration Nutrients, hydration Calories, soothing Rehydration, minerals
Potential Con High sugar, artificial ingredients Some sugar (from fruit) Dairy, fat, high sugar Flavor (less appealing)
Best For Temporary relief, low appetite Vitamin boost, natural option Soothing severe sore throat Preventing dehydration
Risk of Mucus Thickening Low to medium (dairy-dependent) None High None
Nutritional Value Low High (from whole fruit) Varies greatly Specific minerals

Making Your Own Healthy Ice Lollies

For maximum control over ingredients, making your own ice lollies at home is the best option. This ensures you avoid excessive sugar, artificial dyes, and unnecessary additives. A simple recipe can involve blending fresh or frozen fruit (like berries or mango) with a hydrating liquid such as coconut water, herbal tea, or even a small amount of diluted, low-sugar juice. Adding a dash of fresh grated ginger can be particularly beneficial for nausea. Pouring the mixture into popsicle molds and freezing them overnight creates a genuinely healthy and soothing treat.

For extra immune support, some recipes include vitamin-rich ingredients like pineapple (containing bromelain, which may help thin mucus), honey for its antimicrobial properties (for adults), or even a little citrus juice for Vitamin C. Remember to use caution with honey and avoid it for children under one year of age.

Conclusion

Ultimately, whether an ice lolly is “good” for sickness depends on the context and the ingredients. As a simple way to increase fluid intake and provide immediate, temporary relief for a sore throat or fever, it can be a useful and comforting option. However, excessive sugar in many store-bought varieties can be counterproductive to the healing process and may lead to increased inflammation. For the healthiest choice, opt for a homemade version using natural, whole ingredients like fruit and electrolytes to maximize benefits while minimizing drawbacks. Always listen to your body's specific needs, but don't underestimate the power of a small, soothing treat to boost spirits and aid recovery.

An authoritative outbound link to a credible health resource is beneficial here: Mayo Clinic - Sore Throat: Diagnosis and Treatment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, ice lollies are an effective way to stay hydrated when sick, especially for individuals who are reluctant to drink plain water or are suffering from fever and vomiting. For the best results, consider electrolyte-infused options.

Generally, no. The cold temperature from an ice lolly can provide a temporary numbing effect that helps to soothe and reduce the pain associated with a sore throat. However, it's best to choose options with lower sugar content to avoid potential inflammation.

Excessive refined sugar can contribute to inflammation and potentially suppress the immune system, making it harder for your body to fight off infection. For this reason, homemade or low-sugar ice lollies are preferable to heavily sweetened commercial products.

Yes, ice lollies are often a great way to encourage sick children to take in fluids and soothe sore throats. Parents are encouraged to offer homemade or 100% fruit juice varieties to control sugar intake.

While the connection is debated, some people report that dairy products can make their mucus feel thicker. If you find this is the case for you, it's best to stick to water- or fruit-based ice lollies and sorbets until you feel better.

A homemade fruit pop made with pureed fruit, 100% juice, or electrolyte solution is a better, more nutritious alternative. Adding ingredients like ginger or Vitamin C-rich fruits can also provide additional benefits.

For some, the cold, bland nature of a simple ice lolly can be easier to stomach than solid food, providing some calories and fluid. Starting with small sips or bites is a good approach.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.