Skip to content
Ntro

Is mineral water actually healthy? A closer look at the facts

•
8 min read

According to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), mineral water must contain at least 250 parts per million of total dissolved solids, but its specific mineral profile can vary dramatically depending on the source. This variability raises the question: is mineral water actually healthy, and is it a better choice for your diet than standard tap water?

Quick Summary

The healthiness of mineral water depends on its specific mineral content and the source. While it can provide bioavailable minerals like calcium and magnesium that support bone and heart health, high sodium levels in some brands and potential microplastics in plastic bottles pose risks. Natural water sources are typically purer than processed purified water, but tap water is a safe, regulated, and more sustainable alternative for general hydration.

Key Points

  • Rich in Natural Minerals: Mineral water sourced from underground springs provides bioavailable minerals like calcium and magnesium, which are easily absorbed by the body.

  • Potential Health Benefits: Depending on its mineral composition, drinking mineral water may support bone health, help lower blood pressure, and aid digestion.

  • Check Sodium Levels: Some brands of mineral water have high sodium content, which could be a concern for individuals with hypertension or those on a low-sodium diet.

  • Not a Nutritional Replacement: While beneficial, mineral water does not provide enough minerals to replace a balanced diet and should be viewed as a supplement.

  • Tap Water is a Safe Alternative: For everyday hydration needs, regulated tap water is a safe, affordable, and more environmentally friendly choice compared to bottled mineral water.

  • Consider Microplastic Risk: Bottled water, including mineral water, can contain microplastics. Consumers concerned about this can choose glass-bottled options.

In This Article

What is Mineral Water and How Does It Compare to Other Water?

Mineral water originates from protected, underground sources like springs and aquifers and contains a naturally occurring cocktail of minerals and trace elements. Unlike most tap water, it undergoes minimal processing and cannot have minerals artificially added. The specific combination of minerals, such as calcium, magnesium, and sodium, is what gives each brand its unique taste and potential health benefits. In contrast, purified water is often sourced from tap water and heavily processed through methods like reverse osmosis, which strips it of contaminants but also removes beneficial minerals. Tap water, while highly regulated for safety in many regions, has a variable mineral content depending on the local source and treatment methods.

The Health Benefits of Mineral Water

Consumption of certain mineral waters has been linked to several health advantages, largely due to their specific mineral composition.

  • Bone Health: The calcium in mineral water is highly bioavailable, meaning the body can absorb it effectively, sometimes better than calcium from dairy products. A study involving postmenopausal women found that regular consumption of calcium-rich mineral water was associated with significantly higher bone mass density.
  • Heart Health: Evidence suggests that mineral water rich in magnesium and calcium may help lower blood pressure in individuals with borderline hypertension and low mineral levels. Some studies in postmenopausal women have also linked consumption of carbonated mineral water to a reduction in LDL ('bad') cholesterol and an increase in HDL ('good') cholesterol.
  • Digestive Health: For individuals with constipation or indigestion, mineral water containing magnesium and sulfate can be beneficial. Magnesium helps draw water into the intestines, softening stools and promoting more regular bowel movements. Bicarbonate in the water can also aid digestion by neutralizing stomach acid.

Potential Risks and Concerns

Despite its benefits, mineral water is not without potential drawbacks. Consumers should consider these factors when making a choice.

  • High Sodium Content: Some mineral water brands can be high in sodium, which is a concern for individuals with high blood pressure or those on a low-sodium diet. It is crucial to read the nutritional label to check the total dissolved solids and sodium content.
  • Acidity and Dental Health: Sparkling mineral water is naturally more acidic than still water due to the presence of carbonic acid. While significantly less harmful than sugary sodas, this acidity can cause minor erosion of tooth enamel over time, especially with frequent consumption.
  • Microplastics: Bottled water, regardless of its source, is a known contributor to microplastic ingestion. These small plastic particles can leach from the plastic container into the water, particularly when exposed to heat or stored for extended periods. While the long-term health effects are still being researched, some studies suggest potential links to inflammation. Choosing glass-bottled mineral water can mitigate this risk.
  • Cost and Environmental Impact: Mineral water is considerably more expensive than tap water and has a higher environmental footprint due to bottling, packaging, and transportation. For most daily hydration needs, tap water is a far more sustainable and cost-effective option.

Mineral Water vs. Tap Water: A Comparison Table

Feature Mineral Water Tap Water
Source Protected underground springs and aquifers. Surface (rivers, lakes) and underground sources.
Mineral Content Varies by source, often higher in essential minerals like calcium, magnesium, and potassium. Highly variable by location; can contain minerals but generally in lower amounts.
Processing Minimal processing, can be filtered for toxic substances but minerals are not added. Treated with chemical disinfection (e.g., chlorine) and filtration to meet safety standards.
Regulation Regulated by the FDA (in the U.S.) for bottled water standards. Regulated by the EPA (in the U.S.) under the Safe Drinking Water Act.
Cost Significantly more expensive due to sourcing and packaging. Inexpensive and readily available.
Environmental Impact Higher carbon footprint from manufacturing and transportation of bottles. Low environmental impact; delivered via existing infrastructure.

How to Choose and Consume Mineral Water Wisely

If you decide to incorporate mineral water into your diet, here are some tips to help you make an informed and healthy choice:

  1. Read the Label: Check the mineral analysis and look for a Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) value. Higher TDS indicates more minerals. Also, pay attention to the sodium content if you are watching your intake.
  2. Source Matters: The source determines the unique mineral profile and taste. Some brands come from volcanically active regions rich in minerals, while others have a more balanced composition. Choosing glass-bottled water is also a more sustainable and microplastic-free option.
  3. Consider Your Needs: If you are an athlete or have certain mineral deficiencies, mineral water can help replenish electrolytes and nutrients. However, it is not a substitute for a balanced diet.
  4. Balance with Tap Water: For daily hydration, tap water remains the most affordable and environmentally friendly choice. Reserve mineral water for occasional consumption to supplement your mineral intake or for taste preference.

Conclusion

So, is mineral water actually healthy? The answer is nuanced. Yes, natural mineral water can be a healthy source of bioavailable minerals like calcium and magnesium that support bone, heart, and digestive health. However, the healthiness depends heavily on the specific brand's mineral composition, with some being high in sodium. It is not a magical elixir and is not a replacement for a balanced diet rich in fruits, vegetables, and whole grains. For everyday hydration, tap water is a safe, regulated, and more eco-friendly option. Ultimately, the choice between mineral and tap water is a personal one, influenced by individual mineral needs, budget, and environmental concerns.

To make an informed decision, it's wise to consider both the potential benefits and the drawbacks of mineral water and to not overlook the safety and affordability of regulated tap water for most daily hydration needs. For more details on the bioavailability of calcium from mineral water, you can consult research published in the National Library of Medicine.

Key Takeaways

  • Bioavailable Minerals: Mineral water provides naturally occurring minerals like calcium and magnesium that are easily absorbed by the body.
  • Supports Heart and Bone Health: Some studies suggest that certain mineral waters can help lower blood pressure and improve bone density.
  • Risk of High Sodium: Brands vary widely in mineral content; some have high sodium levels unsuitable for those with high blood pressure.
  • Not a Replacement for Diet: The mineral content in water, while beneficial, is not sufficient to replace a balanced diet for essential nutrients.
  • Tap Water is a Viable Alternative: For general hydration, tap water is a safe, controlled, and more environmentally friendly choice compared to bottled mineral water.
  • Consider Sparkling Water Acidity: The carbonic acid in sparkling varieties can be slightly corrosive to tooth enamel, though it's less damaging than soda.
  • Potential Microplastic Exposure: Plastic bottled water, including mineral water, can contain microplastics that may leach into the water. Glass bottles offer a safer alternative.

FAQs

Question: How does mineral water differ from spring water? Answer: While both come from underground sources, mineral water must contain at least 250 parts per million of naturally occurring dissolved solids, whereas spring water is simply collected from a spring without a specified mineral threshold.

Question: Can I get all the minerals I need from mineral water? Answer: No, the mineral content in water is not high enough to meet your full daily mineral requirements. It should be seen as a supplement to a nutrient-dense diet, not a replacement.

Question: Is sparkling mineral water bad for your teeth? Answer: Sparkling mineral water contains carbonic acid, which makes it slightly acidic. Over time, frequent consumption can cause minor erosion of tooth enamel, but it is much less damaging than sugary soft drinks.

Question: Is it okay to drink mineral water every day? Answer: For most people, drinking mineral water daily is safe, provided you monitor the sodium content. However, for general hydration, tap water is a more cost-effective and environmentally friendly option.

Question: How can I choose a low-sodium mineral water? Answer: Check the nutritional label for the sodium content. Brands with lower Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) generally have less sodium, but it's best to look at the specific sodium value listed.

Question: Is mineral water better for hydration than regular water? Answer: While both are excellent for hydration, mineral water contains natural electrolytes that can aid in rehydration, especially after exercise or significant sweating. For most daily needs, however, regular water is sufficient.

Question: Does bottled mineral water pose any risks from the plastic? Answer: Yes, studies have found microplastics in bottled water, which can leach from the plastic container. Opting for glass bottles is a way to avoid this potential risk.

Citations

Frequently Asked Questions

You can check the Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) on the label, typically measured in parts per million (ppm). A higher TDS indicates more dissolved minerals. Some labels may also explicitly state 'low' or 'high' mineral content.

Both mineral and regular water are effective for hydration. Mineral water may offer a slight advantage for replenishing electrolytes due to its natural mineral content, which is beneficial after heavy sweating.

Some research indicates that microplastics can leach from plastic bottles, particularly when exposed to heat. While the long-term effects are unknown, opting for mineral water in glass bottles can mitigate this risk.

Yes, mineral water that is rich in magnesium and sulfate can help with constipation by drawing water into the intestines, which softens stools and promotes regularity.

For individuals with gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD), the carbonation in sparkling mineral water can cause bloating or worsen symptoms. Still mineral water is often a better choice for those with sensitive digestive systems.

Yes, for those with lactose intolerance or who follow a plant-based diet, calcium-rich mineral water can be a valuable and highly bioavailable source of supplemental dietary calcium.

Mineral water is significantly more expensive due to sourcing, bottling, and transportation. For most daily hydration needs, tap water is a cheaper, more sustainable option, and the higher cost of mineral water is only justified if you have specific mineral supplementation goals.

References

  1. 1
    Health Benefits of Mineral Water - WebMD
  2. 2
    Mineral Water: Benefits, Nutrition, and Risks - Health
  3. 3
    Is mineral water more healthful? Benefits and side effects - Medical News Today
  4. 4
    Exploring the Potential Benefits of Natural Calcium-Rich Mineral ... - National Institutes of Health
  5. 5
    Tap water vs mineral water: which is healthier? - Galaxus
  6. 6
    Is Mineral Water Good For Hydration? - Best dietitian in Chandigarh
  7. 7
    How to Shop for Bottled Water, According to a Certified ... - Eater
  8. 8
    Mineral Water vs Tap Water: What's the Difference? - Soda Sense
  9. 9
    What's The Difference Between Mineral Water and Purified ... - Bottling India

Related Topics:

#nutrition diet #health benefits #electrolytes #dietary minerals #healthy hydration #Bottled Water #mineral water #tap water

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.