Skip to content

Is Subway Healthy for Losing Weight? A Complete Guide

4 min read

According to a 2013 UCLA Health study, adolescents consumed nearly as many calories at Subway as at McDonald's when ordering full meals. This fact challenges the long-held belief that Subway is inherently diet-friendly, prompting a deeper look into the question: Is Subway healthy for losing weight?

Quick Summary

Achieving weight loss with Subway depends heavily on your choices. Learn how to select the right bread, lean proteins, and plenty of vegetables while avoiding high-calorie additions like creamy sauces, cheese, and large portions.

Key Points

  • Smart Customization: The key to a healthy Subway meal is customizing your order by choosing lean proteins, whole grains, and plenty of fresh vegetables.

  • Avoid Calorie Bombs: Creamy sauces, excess cheese, and processed meats can quickly turn a sub into a high-calorie meal. Opt for low-fat condiments and skip or minimize cheese.

  • Choose Lean Protein: Stick with lean protein sources like oven-roasted turkey, rotisserie-style chicken, or roast beef to maximize protein intake without excess fat.

  • Fill Up on Veggies: Load your sub or salad with extra vegetables to increase fiber and nutrient content, promoting satiety and overall health.

  • Watch Your Portion: Select a 6-inch sub or a salad over a footlong to control your calorie intake effectively.

  • Beware of Sides: High-calorie sides and drinks like cookies and soda can negate the health benefits of your meal. Stick to water or unsweetened drinks.

In This Article

The Weight Loss Equation: Calories In vs. Calories Out

Weight loss fundamentally comes down to expending more calories than you consume, a state known as a calorie deficit. While the quality of your calories matters for overall health, the total number of calories you eat is the primary factor for losing weight. Subway's highly customizable menu presents both a major opportunity and a major pitfall. You have the power to build a nutritious, calorie-controlled meal, but you can also easily create a sandwich that rivals or exceeds the calorie count of a burger and fries from a traditional fast-food joint. The key is to be an informed consumer and know what choices best support your goals.

Customization is Key: How to Build a Better Sub

Your journey to a healthier Subway meal begins with thoughtful selections at every step. By focusing on whole foods and minimizing processed additions, you can stay on track with your diet.

Choosing Your Base

  • Bread: The type of bread you choose has a significant impact on your meal's calorie and fiber content. Opt for a 6-inch sub instead of a footlong to control your portion size. Hearty Multigrain or 9-Grain Wheat bread are the best options, offering more fiber to keep you feeling full longer compared to white bread. A 'No Bready Bowl' is an excellent, low-carb alternative, removing the bread entirely.
  • Meat and Protein: Stick to lean proteins that provide a satisfying, high-protein filling without excessive fat. Good options include Oven Roasted Turkey, Black Forest Ham, Rotisserie-Style Chicken, or Roast Beef. Be cautious with processed meats like salami and pepperoni, and note that the tuna sub often contains high-fat mayonnaise, significantly increasing its calorie count.
  • Veggies: This is where you can load up guilt-free. Ask for extra spinach, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, onions, and jalapeños. The more vegetables, the more fiber, vitamins, and minerals you add to your meal, enhancing its nutritional profile. Avocado can be a great addition for healthy fats, but be mindful of its calorie contribution.

Mindful Toppings and Dressings

  • Sauces: This is one of the easiest ways to sabotage a healthy meal. Creamy sauces like Ranch, Chipotle Southwest, and mayonnaise are high in calories and saturated fat. Instead, opt for lighter dressings. Yellow mustard, vinegar, or the Subway vinaigrette are lower-calorie choices. Order your dressing on the side and use it sparingly to further control calories.
  • Cheese: While cheese adds flavor, it also adds calories and saturated fat. Consider skipping cheese entirely or asking for a smaller portion to save calories. Natural cheddar or mozzarella are often better than highly processed slices.

Sides and Drinks

  • Sides: Forgo high-calorie cookies and sugary sodas. A bag of applesauce or baked chips is a much better choice if you need a side. A bottle of water is always the smartest drink option.

Comparison Table: A Tale of Two Subs

To illustrate how ordering choices can drastically change your meal, consider the nutritional differences between a typical high-calorie order and a carefully customized low-calorie alternative.

Item High-Calorie Order (Footlong Chicken Bacon Ranch) Low-Calorie Order (6-inch Oven Roasted Turkey)
Base Italian Herbs & Cheese Bread (High Calorie) 9-Grain Wheat Bread (Higher Fiber, Lower Calorie)
Protein Chicken & Bacon Ranch Melt (High Fat, Sodium) Oven Roasted Turkey (Lean Protein)
Veggies Standard amount Double the amount of spinach, lettuce, peppers
Cheese Monterey Cheddar & Swiss No Cheese (Saves Calories & Fat)
Sauce Ranch Sauce Yellow Mustard & Vinegar (Low Calorie)
Add-ons Bag of chips, Cookie, Large Soda Bottled Water, Applesauce Pouch
Typical Result High in calories, fat, and sodium; very high sugar content from drink and cookie. Balanced nutrients, lower in calories, fat, and sodium; higher in fiber.

The Final Verdict: Is Subway Right for Your Weight Loss?**

Yes, Subway can be a healthy option for weight loss, but it is not a 'magic' fast-food solution. It requires conscious, educated decision-making. Unlike other fast-food chains where healthy options are limited, Subway offers a wide array of fresh vegetables and lean proteins that can form the basis of a balanced, low-calorie meal. The danger lies in mindlessly adding high-calorie extras like creamy dressings, excess cheese, and sugary sides. By adhering to smart ordering practices—opting for smaller portions, lean protein, loads of veggies, and light sauces—you can make Subway a convenient and supportive part of your weight loss journey. Remember, the true power of Subway for weight loss is in your hands.

For more detailed nutritional information on specific menu items, you can always visit the official Subway nutrition calculator before you order.

Conclusion

Making Subway a healthy choice for weight loss is entirely dependent on your customization. It's not the restaurant itself but the choices you make within it that determine whether your meal is a balanced, calorie-conscious part of your diet or a high-fat, high-sodium indulgence. Focus on the core components of lean protein and fresh vegetables, and be mindful of portion sizes and high-calorie dressings to make Subway work for you.

Frequently Asked Questions

The healthiest bread option is typically the 9-Grain Wheat or Hearty Multigrain, as they offer higher fiber content which can help you feel fuller for longer. A 6-inch portion is recommended for calorie control.

The lowest calorie sauces at Subway are mustard, vinegar, and the Subway vinaigrette. You should avoid creamy, mayonnaise-based dressings like Ranch or Chipotle Southwest.

No, despite being fish, the tuna sub is often premixed with a high-calorie mayonnaise blend, making it one of the higher-fat and higher-calorie options on the menu. Leaner protein choices like turkey or chicken are better.

Yes, but you should do so in moderation. Cheese adds calories and fat. Consider skipping it or requesting a smaller portion of natural cheese like mozzarella to keep your calorie count low.

Subway salads can be a very healthy, low-carb alternative, but their calorie count depends entirely on toppings and dressing. You can easily make a high-calorie salad by adding too much creamy dressing, cheese, and high-fat protein.

A recommended high-protein, low-calorie order is a 6-inch Oven Roasted Turkey on 9-Grain Wheat bread, loaded with all vegetables, and topped with a small amount of yellow mustard.

While Subway offers more customizable, seemingly healthier options than many traditional burger-focused fast-food chains, it is not guaranteed to be lower in calories. Studies have shown that total calorie intake can be similar depending on ordering choices.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.