Understanding MSG: Added vs. Naturally Occurring
Monosodium glutamate, or MSG, is a sodium salt derived from glutamic acid, an amino acid naturally present in many foods. It is used as a flavor enhancer to produce a savory taste known as umami. However, there is a significant distinction between naturally occurring glutamates and added MSG. Naturally occurring glutamates are integral parts of whole foods, while added MSG is a refined additive. For many decades, MSG has been a controversial food additive, but regulatory bodies like the FDA consider it safe when consumed in moderation. The key for consumers is to understand where and how MSG is used in the products they buy and to be mindful of its presence, especially in processed foods like soups.
Where is MSG Commonly Found in Soups?
Not all soups contain added MSG. Its presence is most common in certain types of commercially produced soups, where it is used to intensify and balance flavors cost-effectively.
- Canned Soups: Many large-scale commercial canned soups, such as certain chicken noodle varieties, often contain added MSG. The long shelf life of canned foods makes them ideal candidates for flavor enhancers to ensure a consistent taste profile.
- Instant Soups and Noodles: The flavoring packets in instant noodle cups and dried soup mixes almost always contain MSG to give them a rapid and robust savory flavor. The low nutritional content of many of these products is masked by the flavor boost provided by MSG.
- Restaurant Soups: Some restaurants, particularly fast-food and Asian fusion establishments, may use MSG to enhance the flavor of their broths and soups. It is always best to ask the staff about ingredients if you have concerns.
Identifying Added MSG on a Label
Since the FDA requires that added monosodium glutamate be listed on ingredient panels, you can check labels to make an informed choice. However, manufacturers sometimes use other ingredients that contain naturally occurring MSG without explicitly labeling it as MSG.
Common ingredients that contain naturally occurring MSG:
- Hydrolyzed vegetable protein
- Autolyzed yeast or yeast extract
- Soy extracts
- Protein isolate
Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ) notes that MSG can also be listed under its code number 621. Familiarizing yourself with these terms and numbers is the best way to avoid added MSG if you choose to do so.
Health Considerations and Natural Alternatives
Despite its 'generally recognized as safe' status, some people report short-term, mild reactions after consuming large amounts of MSG. Symptoms may include headaches, flushing, or nausea, leading some to prefer avoiding it. Fortunately, there are many natural ways to create delicious, savory soups without relying on processed additives.
Comparison Table: Added MSG vs. Natural Umami Sources
| Feature | Added MSG (E621) | Natural Umami Sources |
|---|---|---|
| Composition | Sodium salt of glutamic acid, produced via fermentation | Glutamate from whole, unprocessed foods |
| Presence in Soups | Primarily in processed, canned, and instant soups | Naturally occurs when cooking with umami-rich ingredients |
| Perceived Flavor | Purer, more intense umami flavor | More complex, nuanced savory flavor profile |
| Typical Ingredients | Found in seasoning packets, bouillon cubes | Mushrooms, tomatoes, seaweed, anchovies, aged cheese |
| Associated Health Claims | Associated with mild, short-term reactions in sensitive individuals | No adverse health claims related to naturally occurring glutamate |
| Preparation Effort | Added instantly to enhance flavor | Requires simmering or slow cooking to release flavor |
| Sodium Content | Contains about one-third the sodium of table salt | Sodium content varies based on the ingredient and added salt |
Flavorful Soup-Building with Natural Ingredients
- Dried Mushrooms: Dried shiitake mushrooms are an excellent source of concentrated glutamate. Rehydrate them and use the soaking liquid as a flavor-packed stock. Powdering dried mushrooms also creates a versatile seasoning.
- Miso Paste: A fermented paste of soybeans, miso is rich in umami. A spoonful stirred into soup toward the end of cooking adds a deep, savory complexity.
- Parmesan Cheese Rinds: Don't throw away your Parmesan rinds. Simmer them in your soup broth to add a naturally salty and nutty flavor. They can be removed before serving.
- Seaweed (Kombu): The Japanese have used kombu seaweed for centuries to create dashi, a flavorful broth rich in natural glutamates. This is a great, low-sodium option for enhancing broths.
- Tomatoes: Cooking tomatoes, particularly fire-roasted or tomato paste, releases their naturally high glutamate content, adding depth to soups and stews.
- Anchovies: A few mashed anchovies dissolve almost completely into a soup, leaving behind a rich, briny umami taste without being overtly fishy.
- Yeast Extract: Though it sounds manufactured, yeast extract is a natural source of glutamates and a powerful flavor enhancer. Marmite or Vegemite are widely available examples that can add a meaty, savory depth.
How to Reduce MSG in Your Diet
For those who want to avoid or limit added MSG, the most straightforward approach is to reduce your reliance on heavily processed and pre-packaged foods. Cooking from scratch gives you complete control over your ingredients and seasoning. When shopping, pay close attention to the ingredients list on packaged products. For dining out, don't hesitate to ask restaurants about their use of flavor enhancers in their soups.
Conclusion
While many processed soups contain added MSG to boost flavor, it is far from a universal ingredient in all soups. The key lies in understanding the difference between added MSG and the naturally occurring glutamates found in whole foods like mushrooms and tomatoes. By checking ingredient labels and opting for homemade or naturally-flavored alternatives, you can enjoy delicious, savory soups while keeping complete control over what's in your bowl. Armed with this knowledge, you can navigate the soup aisle and menu with confidence, making choices that best suit your personal dietary needs and preferences.