What's the Difference Between Udon and Lo Mein?
At first glance, both udon and lo mein are popular wheat-based noodles from Asia, but they hail from different countries and are used in distinct ways. Udon noodles are a Japanese staple, while lo mein noodles are a classic of Chinese-American cuisine. Understanding their fundamental differences is key to appreciating each noodle for its unique qualities.
The Noodle Itself: Ingredients and Texture
Udon noodles are thick, chewy Japanese noodles made from wheat flour, water, and salt. The thickness and specific texture can vary by region in Japan, from the square-shaped Inaniwa udon to the broad, flat Hoto noodles. Their simple ingredients give them a mild flavor, which allows them to absorb the rich flavors of broths and sauces easily. Udon's texture is famously soft and slippery, with a characteristic chewy 'bounce'. They are most often found fresh, dried, or frozen in markets.
Lo Mein noodles, on the other hand, are Chinese egg noodles made from wheat flour, water, and egg. The inclusion of egg gives them a distinct springy, chewy texture that is different from udon's softness. They are typically round and yellow-tinted, similar to spaghetti in appearance. The egg also provides a richer, creamier mouthfeel than the simpler udon noodle.
Key Characteristics in a list format:
-
Udon:
- Origin: Japan
- Main Ingredients: Wheat flour, water, salt
- Texture: Thick, soft, and chewy with a slippery surface
- Flavor Profile: Mild, absorbing flavors from broth
- Best For: Hot soups, stir-fries, and cold dipping dishes
-
Lo Mein:
- Origin: Chinese-American cuisine
- Main Ingredients: Wheat flour, water, egg
- Texture: Round, springy, and chewier than udon
- Flavor Profile: Slightly creamy with a richer flavor, holds up well to thick sauces
- Best For: Stir-fried and tossed noodle dishes
Cooking Method: Tossed vs. Simmered
The cooking method is the most crucial difference between udon and lo mein. Their names give it away: lo mein literally translates to "tossed noodles," while udon is often simmered directly in broth.
For lo mein, the egg noodles are pre-boiled until just al dente, then drained and set aside. The other ingredients—protein, vegetables, and sauce—are stir-fried separately in a wok. The cooked noodles are then added at the very end and gently tossed to coat them in the rich sauce. This process ensures the noodles remain soft, chewy, and coated in the thick sauce, rather than absorbing it completely like a sponge.
For udon, the preparation depends on whether it's a hot or cold dish. In hot preparations like Kitsune Udon or Curry Udon, the noodles are often simmered directly in the flavorful broth, allowing them to soften further and absorb the liquid. For cold dishes like Zaru Udon, the noodles are boiled and chilled, then served with a dipping sauce on the side. The cooking method for udon is less about stir-frying and more about the delicate balance of the noodle and its accompanying broth.
Comparison Table: Udon vs. Lo Mein
| Feature | Udon | Lo Mein |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Japanese | Chinese-American |
| Key Ingredient | Wheat flour, water, salt | Wheat flour, water, egg |
| Texture | Soft, thick, and chewy | Springy, firm, and chewier |
| Typical Dish | Soups (Kake Udon), Stir-fries (Yaki Udon), Cold dishes (Zaru Udon) | Saucy tossed noodle stir-fries (often with beef, chicken, or vegetables) |
| Cooking Method | Boiled and simmered in broth, or boiled and chilled | Boiled separately, then tossed with sauce at the end |
| Sauce Interaction | Absorbs broth flavors | Coated in thick, rich sauce |
| Flavor Profile | Mild, clean taste | Creamier, richer flavor |
| Appearance | White, thick strands | Yellow-tinted, round strands |
Which Noodle is Right for You?
Choosing between udon and lo mein is a matter of personal preference and the dish you want to create. Here's a guide to help you decide:
-
Choose Udon if:
- You crave a comforting, brothy soup. Udon's ability to soak up dashi or other broths makes it the perfect vessel for a warming, flavorful meal.
- You prefer a softer, more slippery texture in your noodles. The thick, chewy nature of udon is a unique sensation.
- You want a cleaner, more delicate flavor that complements subtle broths and ingredients like tempura or fried tofu.
-
Choose Lo Mein if:
- You want a heartier, richer noodle dish. The egg content gives lo mein a more substantial feel.
- You love dishes with a thick, savory sauce that coats every strand. The tossing method is designed specifically for this effect.
- You prefer a more assertive, springy chew in your noodles that stands up to stir-fried ingredients.
Conclusion: No Winner, Just Delicious Choices
Neither udon nor lo mein is inherently "better" than the other; they are simply different, each serving a distinct purpose in their respective cuisines. Udon offers a mild, soft, and comforting experience ideal for soups, while lo mein provides a rich, springy, and savory bite perfect for saucy stir-fries. The best noodle for you depends on what you're making and what flavors you're seeking. The next time you're at a restaurant or grocery store, you'll be equipped to make an informed choice based on more than just appearance, creating a more satisfying and authentic culinary experience.
Where to find your noodles
Fresh and dried noodles for both udon and lo mein can be found at most Asian grocery stores and even in the international food aisles of many large supermarkets. For a wider selection, particularly for fresh udon and specific regional varieties, an Asian market is your best bet. You can also order high-quality noodles online from specialty retailers. Find out more about the different types of Asian noodles here.
