Skip to content

Should you be in a calorie surplus when sick?

4 min read

When you're sick, your body's energy demands increase significantly as your immune system fights off infection. This raises the question: should you be in a calorie surplus when sick to support recovery, or is it better to stick to maintenance calories?

Quick Summary

Your body's energy needs increase during illness to fuel the immune response. Providing adequate nutrition is key to supporting recovery and preventing muscle loss.

Key Points

  • Immune System Requires Extra Energy: Your metabolism increases when you're sick, especially with a fever, as your body uses extra calories to fight infection.

  • Avoid a Calorie Deficit: Intentionally restricting calories can lead to muscle breakdown for energy, which is counterproductive to recovery and immune function.

  • Listen to Your Appetite: Don't force yourself to eat if you have no appetite. Instead, focus on small, frequent, nutrient-dense snacks and liquids.

  • Prioritize Hydration: Dehydration is a major risk during illness. Ensure you are drinking plenty of fluids, including water, broth, and electrolyte-rich drinks.

  • Focus on Nutrient-Rich Foods: Foods packed with vitamins (A, C, D) and minerals (zinc, selenium) are crucial for supporting your immune system's fight against infection.

  • Don't Fear Temporary Weight Fluctuation: Short-term changes in weight due to illness are normal and will stabilize once you've recovered and your appetite returns.

In This Article

The Energetic Demands of a Sick Body

When your body is fighting an illness, it enters a state of heightened activity that requires a significant amount of energy. Your immune system, which is your body's primary defense mechanism against pathogens, goes into overdrive. This metabolic acceleration helps your body produce immune cells, antibodies, and inflammatory responses necessary to combat the infection.

A fever, for instance, is a deliberate mechanism by the body to make it a less hospitable environment for viruses and bacteria. To raise and maintain this elevated body temperature, your metabolism speeds up, burning a greater number of calories than usual. This increased energy expenditure is non-negotiable for the healing process, and failing to provide the necessary fuel can prolong your recovery and weaken your body's defenses.

The Dangers of a Calorie Deficit

Some people may be tempted to restrict calorie intake while sick, especially if their physical activity is reduced due to bed rest. However, this is generally not recommended. During an infection, the body may derive up to 30% of its caloric needs from breaking down muscle and protein stores if dietary intake is insufficient. This can lead to significant muscle mass loss, which is particularly detrimental as protein is a critical component for building immune cells and repairing tissues. In contrast, providing enough energy prevents this catabolic state and supports the body's natural healing mechanisms.

The Strategic Approach to Fueling Recovery

Instead of focusing on a traditional 'calorie surplus' for weight gain, the goal during illness is to achieve a strategic nutritional surplus to fuel your immune system and prevent muscle loss. This involves prioritizing nutrient-dense, easy-to-digest foods, especially when appetite is suppressed.

Recommended Foods and Habits

Here are some practical ways to support your body's increased needs when you're sick:

  • Stay Hydrated: Dehydration is a common risk, especially with fever, vomiting, or diarrhea. Drink plenty of fluids like water, herbal tea, broths, and coconut water to replenish electrolytes.
  • Eat Small, Frequent Meals: A full meal can be overwhelming when you have a poor appetite. Opt for smaller, nutrient-packed snacks every few hours to provide a steady supply of energy.
  • Prioritize Protein: Ensure you consume adequate protein to preserve muscle mass. This can come from sources like chicken soup, eggs, yogurt, or protein supplements.
  • Include Immune-Supporting Nutrients: Load up on vitamins and minerals that aid immune function, such as Vitamin C (citrus fruits, berries), zinc (shellfish, nuts), and Vitamin D (fatty fish, fortified dairy).
  • Opt for Soothing Foods: Foods that are gentle on your digestive system are ideal. Bland foods like bananas, rice, applesauce, and toast are great for settling an upset stomach.

Comparing Nutritional Approaches During Illness

Approach Rationale During Illness Pros Cons Best For
Strategic Nutritional Surplus Fuel the immune system, repair tissue, prevent muscle loss. Supports rapid recovery, maintains muscle mass, provides essential nutrients. Can be difficult with low appetite or nausea. Most individuals with typical illness.
Calorie Deficit None, despite reduced physical activity. May lead to temporary weight loss (fat and muscle). Risks muscle breakdown, prolongs recovery, weakens immune response. Not recommended.
Maintenance Calories A decent compromise if a surplus is challenging. Prevents significant muscle breakdown. May not provide enough energy for optimal immune function, potentially delaying recovery. Mild illness with no appetite changes.

Listen to Your Body, Not a Strict Plan

The most critical advice is to listen to your body's signals. If your appetite is completely gone, forcing yourself to eat a large calorie surplus will likely do more harm than good, potentially leading to nausea or vomiting. Instead, focus on small, nutrient-dense fluids and gradually reintroduce more solid foods as your appetite returns. Recovery is the priority, and temporary deviations from a long-term calorie plan are completely acceptable. Your body is remarkably resilient, and a few days of different eating patterns will not derail your overall health and fitness goals. For severe or prolonged illness, always consult a healthcare provider for personalized nutritional advice.

Conclusion

While the concept of a dedicated calorie surplus might sound like a strategy for bodybuilding, the principle of providing your body with sufficient energy is crucial when sick. Your immune system requires extra fuel to mount an effective defense, and a deficit can lead to detrimental muscle breakdown and a delayed recovery. By focusing on hydration, frequent nutrient-rich meals, and listening to your body's appetite cues, you can strategically fuel your body and get back on your feet faster. Remember, the ultimate goal is not to strictly adhere to a calorie count but to provide the necessary support for your body's primary function: healing. For more information on immune-supporting foods, you can explore resources like Healthline's guide on the topic.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, your body burns more calories when sick because your immune system requires a lot of energy to fight off infection. A fever, for example, significantly increases your metabolic rate.

If you have no appetite, don't force yourself to eat large meals. Focus on consuming small, frequent, nutrient-dense foods and fluids that are easy to digest, such as broths, smoothies, and soft fruits.

Unintentional weight loss during illness can be a sign of insufficient caloric intake, which may cause your body to break down muscle tissue for energy. It's important to provide your body with the nutrients it needs to prevent this and support recovery.

The best foods are nutrient-dense and easy to digest. Options include chicken soup, broths, leafy greens, citrus fruits for Vitamin C, yogurt with probiotics, and bland foods like bananas and rice for an upset stomach.

Even without a fever, your immune system is still working hard and requires extra energy. While the calorie burn is less significant, focusing on a strategic, nutrient-dense intake is still recommended to support healing.

While extra calories can be beneficial, focusing on nutrient-dense foods is more important for recovery. Highly processed or fatty junk foods can be harder to digest and may lack the specific vitamins and minerals needed for proper immune function.

Protein is very important when you're sick. It is crucial for repairing damaged cells and producing antibodies and immune cells to fight infection. Insufficient protein can lead to muscle loss.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.