The Fundamental Role of Hydration with Gels
Energy gels are a concentrated source of carbohydrates designed to provide a rapid energy boost during sustained physical activity. For these concentrated sugars to be effectively absorbed and utilized by your body, they must be adequately diluted. During intense exercise, your body diverts blood flow away from the digestive system and towards your working muscles. This makes the digestive system more sensitive and less efficient at processing concentrated substances. Consuming a highly concentrated gel without water forces your body to pull existing water from your bloodstream and tissues into the digestive tract to dilute the sugars. This can lead to worsening dehydration, slowing the absorption of carbohydrates, and causing gastrointestinal (GI) distress.
Classic vs. Isotonic: The Critical Difference
Not all gels are created equal, and the type of gel you use dictates your hydration strategy. Differentiating between classic and isotonic gels is the most important step in preventing on-the-go stomach issues.
Classic Energy Gels
- Composition: These are thicker, more concentrated gels containing a higher carbohydrate load and less water.
- Hydration Rule: You must drink water with classic gels. A common recommendation is 4 to 6 ounces of plain water per gel to help with absorption and prevent stomach upset. Without water, these gels can be very difficult for your body to process, leading to the risk of cramps, bloating, and diarrhea.
Isotonic Energy Gels
- Composition: These gels have a thinner consistency because they are pre-mixed with water and electrolytes to be at a similar concentration to your body's fluids.
- Hydration Rule: You do not need to take additional water specifically to aid the gel's absorption. This offers convenience for runners who don't want to carry a water bottle. However, this does not mean you can neglect your overall hydration plan. You still need to drink water or other fluids regularly throughout your exercise to replenish what is lost through sweat.
Risks of Improper Gel Consumption
Skipping water with a non-isotonic gel can lead to a host of problems that can quickly derail your performance:
- Gastrointestinal Distress: The most common issue, manifesting as bloating, cramping, nausea, or diarrhea. This is a direct result of the gut pulling water from other parts of the body to process the concentrated sugar.
- Ineffective Fueling: The absorption of the gel is delayed, meaning the quick energy boost you're seeking is not delivered efficiently.
- Worsening Dehydration: Your body's fluid balance is compromised as water is diverted from the bloodstream, hindering performance and increasing the risk of heat-related illness.
- Energy Crash: A flood of simple sugars without proper absorption can lead to a rapid spike and subsequent crash in blood sugar levels.
How to Create a Smart Fueling Strategy
To maximize the benefits of energy gels while minimizing risks, follow these best practices:
- Practice in Training: Never try a new gel or fueling strategy on race day. Use your training runs to test different brands, gel types, and your hydration plan to see what your stomach tolerates best.
- Time Your Intake: For activities over 60-90 minutes, start fueling early. Take your first gel around 45-60 minutes into the exercise, and then every 30-45 minutes thereafter.
- Use Water, Not Sports Drinks: When consuming a classic gel, pair it with plain water. Do not wash a gel down with a sports drink, as the combined high sugar concentration can overload your digestive system.
- Sip, Don't Chug: Take small, consistent sips of water with your gels rather than large gulps. This helps maintain fluid balance and supports digestion.
Comparison: Classic vs. Isotonic Gels
| Feature | Classic Energy Gel | Isotonic Energy Gel |
|---|---|---|
| Water Required? | Yes, with every gel packet. | No, pre-mixed with water. |
| Carbohydrate Density | High | Lower |
| Consistency | Thicker, denser | Thinner, more fluid-like |
| Primary Purpose | Compact, quick energy source | Energy and hydration support |
| Convenience | Less convenient without water access | More convenient for runners without water |
| Risk of GI Distress | High, if taken without water | Low |
| Best Use Case | Endurance athletes with a solid hydration plan | Runners who want to avoid carrying extra fluid for gel consumption |
Conclusion: The Bottom Line on Gels and Water
Ultimately, the question of whether you should drink water with gels depends on the type of gel. For traditional, non-isotonic gels, the answer is a definitive yes—it is essential for digestion, absorption, and preventing stomach issues. For isotonic gels, while it is not strictly necessary for absorption, you must still maintain adequate hydration throughout your workout with either water or an electrolyte drink. The key to successful fueling is to train your gut, understand your gel type, and consistently pair traditional gels with water during your endurance activities. Neglecting this crucial hydration step can lead to a frustrating end to your race or long training session. For more expert advice on endurance nutrition, visit Runner's World.