Skip to content

Should You Stay in a Calorie Deficit When Sick? Here's What Science Says

4 min read

Studies have shown that extreme calorie restriction can impair immune function, making you more susceptible to infections and potentially prolonging your illness. So, when facing the question, "should you stay in a calorie deficit when sick?" the resounding answer from health professionals is a clear no. During illness, your body needs extra energy and nutrients to fight off pathogens and repair itself effectively.

Quick Summary

Prioritizing adequate nutrition during illness is vital for a strong immune response and a quicker recovery. Maintaining a calorie deficit while sick can weaken immunity and lead to negative side effects. Instead of focusing on weight goals, concentrate on providing your body with nutrient-dense foods, hydration, and rest to support its healing processes.

Key Points

  • Prioritize Recovery: When sick, your primary goal should be healing, not weight loss. Continuing a calorie deficit will hinder your body's ability to fight off infection effectively.

  • Immunity Needs Fuel: Your immune system requires a significant amount of energy and nutrients to function optimally. A calorie deficit starves your body of the resources it needs to recover.

  • Risk of Nutrient Deficiencies: Restricting calories when ill can lead to deficiencies in essential vitamins and minerals, which can prolong your sickness.

  • Listen to Your Body: Focus on eating nutrient-dense, easy-to-digest foods when you are hungry. Small, frequent meals are often better than large ones.

  • Hydrate, Hydrate, Hydrate: Staying well-hydrated with water, broths, or herbal teas is crucial, especially with fever, vomiting, or diarrhea.

  • Don't Stress About Weight: A short-term shift in focus will not derail your long-term goals. Your weight may fluctuate due to inflammation and fluid retention, but this is temporary.

  • Rest is Essential: Giving your body the rest it needs is one of the most important things you can do to support your immune system and promote a fast recovery.

In This Article

Why Your Body Needs More Energy When Sick

When you're fighting an illness, your body's metabolic demands increase significantly. The immune system is a high-energy machine, requiring a boost in calories and nutrients to function optimally and combat pathogens. White blood cells, antibodies, and other immune responses require a continuous supply of fuel. Restricting your calorie intake during this time forces your body to divert resources away from fighting the infection towards basic survival, thereby slowing down your recovery process and potentially extending the duration of your illness.

The Immune System's Energy Demands

  • Increased Metabolic Rate: Your body may naturally burn more calories as it works to fight an infection, sometimes even causing a fever. This increased energy expenditure is necessary to power the immune response.
  • Protein Turnover: The immune system uses proteins to create antibodies and new cells. Maintaining adequate protein and calorie intake helps preserve muscle mass and ensures your body has the building blocks it needs.
  • Nutrient Allocation: Essential micronutrients like Vitamin C, Zinc, and Vitamin D are critical for a healthy immune system. A calorie deficit, especially a severe one, can lead to nutrient deficiencies that further compromise your body's defenses.

The Risks of Maintaining a Calorie Deficit When Ill

Continuing to actively restrict calories when you are sick can have several negative consequences that far outweigh any potential weight loss benefits. Health should always be the priority, and the following risks illustrate why a strict deficit is counterproductive during illness:

  • Impaired Immune Function: A significant or prolonged calorie deficit is known to weaken the immune system, making it more difficult for your body to recover. Animal studies have shown that calorie-restricted subjects are more susceptible to severe infections.
  • Nutrient Deficiencies: Lowering your food intake also reduces your intake of essential vitamins and minerals crucial for recovery. This can exacerbate symptoms and lengthen the healing process.
  • Muscle Loss: When your body is not getting enough calories from food, it will start to break down muscle tissue for energy. This is especially true for those with low body fat stores.
  • Increased Fatigue: A lack of sufficient calories can lead to debilitating fatigue, lethargy, and a general feeling of weakness, which are already common symptoms of illness. Adequate energy is needed to support basic bodily functions and combat the illness.
  • Prolonged Illness: By putting additional stress on your body, a calorie deficit can hinder your body's ability to recover efficiently, potentially leading to a longer and more severe illness.

Prioritizing Recovery Over Restriction

Instead of stressing over your calorie goals, the focus during illness should be on providing your body with the fuel it needs. A few days of eating at or near your maintenance calories will not derail your long-term progress. In fact, it's a necessary pause that ensures you can get back on track faster once you are well. Listen to your body and honor its signals, even if your appetite is low.

A better strategy involves:

  • Eating when you're hungry: Don't force yourself to follow a rigid schedule. Opt for smaller, more frequent meals if a large meal is too much.
  • Focusing on nutrients: Choose foods that are easy to digest and packed with vitamins, minerals, and protein. Soups, broths, and easily digestible fruits are excellent options.
  • Staying hydrated: Water, herbal teas, and broths are crucial for staying hydrated, especially with fever, vomiting, or diarrhea.
  • Getting plenty of rest: Your body's primary focus should be on healing. Exercising or pushing yourself during this time can be detrimental.

Comparison: Calorie Deficit vs. Nutrient-Focused Recovery When Sick

Feature Calorie Deficit During Illness Nutrient-Focused Recovery Outcome
Energy Levels Low, increased fatigue Restored, stable energy Faster recovery with less fatigue
Immune System Impaired function Supported, stronger response Better able to fight off illness
Nutrient Intake Deficient, lacking essential vitamins Adequate, packed with healing nutrients Avoids deficiencies, aids healing
Muscle Mass At risk of breakdown Preserved with adequate protein Prevents loss of lean muscle
Recovery Time Potentially prolonged Faster and more efficient Quicker return to health
Mindset Stress about weight and calories Focus on listening to the body Reduced mental stress

A Nutritious Diet for Faster Healing

While your appetite might be low, making sure you eat some of the right foods is key to a faster recovery. Here are some examples of nutrient-dense options to consider:

  • Hydrating Fluids: Soups, bone broth, coconut water, and herbal teas provide both fluids and electrolytes, helping with hydration and soothing symptoms.
  • Protein-Rich Foods: Lean chicken, fish like salmon, eggs, and legumes supply the amino acids needed to rebuild and repair tissues.
  • Vitamin C Sources: Citrus fruits, berries, peppers, and leafy greens are loaded with vitamin C, a powerful immune-boosting antioxidant.
  • Zinc-Rich Foods: Shellfish, beef, nuts, and seeds provide zinc, which can reduce the duration of some respiratory illnesses.
  • Easy-to-Digest Carbs: Options like bananas, rice, and oats are gentle on the stomach and provide a good source of energy.
  • Probiotics: Yogurt with live and active cultures can help replenish gut bacteria, which can be affected by illness or antibiotics.

Remember to listen to your body and choose foods that you can tolerate. Don't worry if your appetite is low; focus on small, frequent servings of nutrient-rich foods and fluids.

Conclusion

When illness strikes, the primary goal should be a full and speedy recovery, not weight loss. Continuing a calorie deficit when sick is a counterproductive strategy that puts additional stress on your body, impairs your immune system, and can prolong your illness. Instead, shift your focus to providing your body with the energy, hydration, and nutrient-dense foods it needs to heal. A few days of prioritizing your health will not undo your progress and will allow you to return to your fitness goals with renewed strength and energy. Listen to your body, rest, and fuel your recovery with nourishing foods. For more detailed information on eating extra calories when sick, refer to MedlinePlus, a service of the U.S. National Library of Medicine.

Frequently Asked Questions

It is unlikely that you will gain a significant amount of fat by eating at your maintenance calories for a few days while you recover. Any temporary weight increase on the scale is often due to inflammation or fluid retention and will likely resolve once you are feeling better.

If you have a very low appetite, focus on consuming fluids and small, frequent portions of easily digestible, nutrient-dense foods. Broths, soups, and fruits like bananas can provide energy and hydration without overwhelming your stomach.

No, you should not exercise when you're sick, especially if you have a fever. Exercise places additional stress on your body, diverting energy away from your immune system. Rest is crucial for a speedy recovery.

Good foods include nutrient-rich options like chicken soup, bone broth, bananas, rice, oatmeal, lean protein sources (fish, eggs), and fruits and vegetables high in Vitamin C.

Yes, your body's metabolic rate can increase as your immune system works hard to fight off infection, meaning you may burn more calories than usual. This is why consuming adequate calories is so important during illness.

You should take a break from your calorie deficit for as long as it takes to feel fully recovered. This could be a few days for a minor cold or longer for a more serious illness. Listen to your body and resume your deficit only when you have returned to your normal energy levels.

Yes, by weakening your immune system and depriving your body of the necessary nutrients and energy, continuing a calorie deficit can potentially prolong your illness and slow down your recovery process.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.