Skip to content

Understanding and Choosing: Which is the best isotonic drink?

4 min read

During intense exercise lasting over 60 minutes, your body can lose more than a litre of fluid per hour through sweat, along with essential electrolytes. An isotonic drink is formulated to replace these losses effectively, offering a crucial combination of hydration and energy. Finding the right one, however, depends entirely on your specific athletic needs and body's response.

Quick Summary

This guide details the purpose of isotonic drinks, comparing them to hypotonic and hypertonic options. It covers key ingredients, provides a comparison table of different types, explores popular commercial brands and a homemade recipe, and offers tips for choosing the ideal drink for your training.

Key Points

  • Isotonic Defined: Isotonic drinks have a solute concentration similar to blood plasma, enabling fast absorption of fluid and nutrients during exercise.

  • Energy and Electrolytes: They provide quick-release carbohydrates for energy and replace key electrolytes like sodium lost through sweat, helping to prevent fatigue and cramps.

  • When to Use: Isotonic drinks are best suited for intense exercise lasting over 60 minutes, while plain water or hypotonic drinks are better for shorter, less intense activity.

  • Commercial vs. Homemade: You can choose from various commercial options like Gatorade, Powerade, or SiS gels, or easily make a cost-effective natural version at home with water, juice, and salt.

  • Test Before Race Day: Always test a new drink during training to ensure it doesn't cause gastrointestinal distress, as personal tolerance varies.

  • Best Choice is Personal: The 'best' drink depends on your activity type, duration, ingredient preferences, and how your body responds to specific formulations.

In This Article

What is an Isotonic Drink?

An isotonic drink is a specially formulated beverage with a concentration of carbohydrates (typically 6-8%) and electrolytes that is similar to the concentration found in human blood, or plasma. The term 'iso' means equal, which refers to the equal osmotic pressure between the drink and your body's fluids. This balanced concentration allows for rapid absorption of both fluid and nutrients into the bloodstream, making it highly effective for hydrating and fuelling the body during sustained, high-intensity exercise.

The Importance of Electrolytes and Carbohydrates

When you sweat, you lose more than just water; you lose crucial electrolytes like sodium, potassium, and magnesium. Sodium, in particular, is vital for maintaining fluid balance and stimulating your body's thirst mechanism. Isotonic drinks help replenish these lost minerals to prevent dehydration and muscle cramps. Furthermore, the carbohydrates provide a quick, accessible source of energy to replenish depleted glycogen stores, delaying the onset of fatigue during endurance activities. The ideal carbohydrate intake for high-intensity exercise lasting over an hour is typically 30-60 grams per hour.

Isotonic vs. Hypotonic vs. Hypertonic Drinks

Choosing the best sports drink depends on your specific activity. The tonicity of a drink—whether it's isotonic, hypotonic, or hypertonic—determines its absorption speed and primary function.

Comparing Drink Types

Feature Isotonic Drink Hypotonic Drink Hypertonic Drink
Concentration Similar to blood plasma (approx. 6-8% carbs) Lower than blood plasma (<6% carbs) Higher than blood plasma (>8% carbs)
Absorption Speed Fast. The balanced concentration promotes efficient absorption. Very Fast. Fluid is absorbed most rapidly. Slowest. The high concentration draws fluid into the gut.
Primary Goal Balanced hydration and energy replenishment. Rapid hydration. Primarily energy (carbohydrate) replenishment.
Best For High-intensity exercise lasting over an hour (e.g., marathon running, cycling). Short, low-intensity exercise or hot climates where dehydration is the main concern. Post-exercise recovery to replenish glycogen or carb-loading before an event.

Popular Commercial Isotonic Drinks and Powders

Several commercial options are available, each with its own benefits and features. Many now come in convenient powders or gels.

  • Science in Sport (SiS) Go Isotonic Energy Gels: Claimed as the world's first isotonic gels, they deliver carbohydrates quickly without the need for extra water, minimizing the risk of bloating.
  • Gatorade: A traditional and widely available sports drink. While Gatorade Thirst Quencher fits the isotonic profile, options like Gatorlyte offer more sodium for heavy sweaters, and Gatorade Zero provides electrolytes without added sugar.
  • Momentous Fuel: An option prioritizing quality, natural ingredients with a specific glucose-to-fructose ratio for optimal carbohydrate utilization.
  • Powerade: Another major player with an isotonic formula providing carbohydrates and electrolytes. Some versions, like Mountain Blast Zero, offer a no-sugar alternative.
  • Skratch Labs Sport Hydration Drink Mix: Praised for its natural ingredients and balanced taste, it provides a good mix of carbohydrates and electrolytes.

The DIY Approach: A Homemade Isotonic Drink Recipe

For those who prefer to avoid artificial ingredients or save money, a homemade isotonic drink is a simple and effective alternative.

Ingredients:

  • 1 litre of water
  • 3 tablespoons of honey or sugar (approx. 70g)
  • 1/4 teaspoon of salt (for electrolytes)
  • Juice of one orange or lemon (for flavour and potassium)

Instructions:

  1. Combine all ingredients in a litre bottle or pitcher.
  2. Shake or stir thoroughly until the salt and sugar are fully dissolved.
  3. For extra flavour, add fresh herbs like mint or ginger.
  4. Chill and serve. This provides a natural, customisable isotonic solution.

How to Choose the Best Isotonic Drink for Your Workout

With numerous options, consider these factors to find the right fit for your body and training goals:

  • Consider the intensity and duration of your exercise. Isotonic drinks are best for sessions lasting over 60 minutes. For shorter or less intense workouts, plain water is usually sufficient.
  • Evaluate ingredient quality. If avoiding artificial flavours, colours, and sweeteners is a priority, choose brands with transparent labelling or make a homemade version.
  • Look at the electrolyte balance. Some people are heavier sweaters or have saltier sweat. In this case, a drink with a higher sodium content may be more beneficial.
  • Test for gut tolerance. What works for one person may cause stomach upset for another. It is crucial to test new products during training, not on race day, to ensure it agrees with your digestive system.
  • Assess taste and texture. You are more likely to stay properly hydrated if you enjoy the flavour and texture of your drink.

Conclusion: Personalisation is Key

There is no single best isotonic drink that suits everyone. The ideal choice depends on your athletic demands, personal tolerance, and ingredient preferences. For elite endurance athletes, trusted brands like SiS offer a precise, science-backed fuelling strategy. For those seeking a budget-friendly or natural alternative, a simple homemade recipe is an excellent option. Ultimately, listening to your body and matching your hydration strategy to the intensity and duration of your activity is the key to optimal performance and recovery.

Visit Precision Hydration for more information on choosing the right sports drink for your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

The main benefit is the ability to replace both fluids and carbohydrates simultaneously. While water rehydrates, an isotonic drink also provides a quick source of energy, which is vital for maintaining performance during intense, prolonged exercise.

Use an isotonic drink for intense exercise lasting more than an hour, where both energy and hydration are needed. Opt for a hypotonic drink for quick rehydration during shorter, less intense sessions or in very hot weather where rapid fluid absorption is the priority over energy.

No, it is not recommended for casual hydration. Isotonic drinks contain calories from added sugars, which can lead to unnecessary weight gain if consumed when not needed for intense physical activity. Plain water is best for general hydration needs.

An effective isotonic drink should contain a blend of water, a carbohydrate source (like maltodextrin or glucose), and key electrolytes, especially sodium, to aid hydration and prevent muscle cramps.

Yes, a homemade isotonic drink can be highly effective. It offers a natural, customisable, and cost-effective way to achieve the optimal balance of carbohydrates and electrolytes needed for performance without artificial additives.

Some commercially available isotonic drinks, particularly in large volumes or in hot conditions, can cause gastrointestinal upset due to their carbohydrate concentration and artificial ingredients. Individual tolerance can also play a role.

Test new drinks during your training sessions, not on race day. This allows you to assess how your body reacts, especially regarding flavour, consistency, and potential stomach issues. Start with smaller amounts and build up as you train.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.