Understanding BHT's Dual Nature
Butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT) is widely known and used as a synthetic antioxidant in the food, cosmetic, and pharmaceutical industries. It is added to products to prevent oxidation, thus extending shelf life. However, scientific research has increasingly revealed that BHT is not exclusively a man-made chemical; it also has a surprising array of natural origins. This dual nature—being a lab-synthesized compound for commercial use and a naturally occurring substance in various organisms—is a key distinction that is important for consumers and researchers alike. The discovery of natural BHT sources highlights a fascinating aspect of biochemistry and offers potential avenues for exploring new, naturally derived antioxidants.
Microscopic Producers: Algae and Cyanobacteria
Several species of phytoplankton, including the green algae Botryococcus braunii, are known to produce BHT naturally in freshwater ecosystems. Additionally, three specific cyanobacteria species – Cylindrospermopsis raciborskii, Microcystis aeruginosa, and Oscillatoria sp. – have been identified as BHT producers. Environmental factors, such as higher light intensity, can increase BHT production in phytoplankton, suggesting a role in protecting against photooxidative stress. This indicates that these microorganisms use BHT as a natural defense mechanism.
Fungal Emissions in Olive Oil Production
Specific fungi that colonize olives during storage have been found to emit volatile compounds, including BHT. Research on fungi isolated from stored olives showed that eleven out of fourteen strains produced BHT, with Aspergillus conicus emitting particularly high levels. The BHT produced by these fungi may contribute to the stability and shelf life of olive oil.
Higher Plants with Natural BHT
Natural BHT has also been identified in some higher plants and fruits. The pericarp of the lychee fruit contains naturally produced BHT. The shrub Cytisus triflorus, found in the Mediterranean region, also contains BHT in its aerial parts. Another plant known to contain BHT is the halophyte Mesembryanthemum crystallinum. While detected in other plants and insects, the exact origin (plant or associated microorganism) is not always clear.
The Commercial Contrast: Natural vs. Synthetic BHT
Despite the existence of natural BHT, the version used commercially is primarily synthetic. While chemically identical, they differ significantly in origin, production, and cost.
| Feature | Natural BHT | Synthetic BHT | 
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Produced by living organisms (e.g., algae, fungi, specific plants). | Artificially synthesized in laboratories through chemical reactions. | 
| Production Scale | Exists in very small, biologically relevant quantities; not produced on an industrial scale. | Mass-produced in large industrial plants to meet high commercial demand. | 
| Cost | Not commercially viable to extract and purify from natural sources due to low yields. | Highly affordable due to efficient, large-scale industrial manufacturing processes. | 
| Primary Role/Use | Functions as a natural antioxidant and protective compound for the host organism. | Added to commercial products (food, cosmetics, etc.) to extend shelf life and prevent oxidation. | 
| Commercial Availability | Not available as a commercial ingredient for industrial use. | The standard commercial form readily used by many industries worldwide. | 
What This Means for Consumers and Industry
For consumers, the natural sources of BHT are primarily of scientific interest as commercial products use the synthetic version. However, for the industry, the discovery of natural BHT sources is relevant to the growing demand for natural ingredients and 'clean label' products. Understanding how organisms naturally produce BHT can guide research into developing new, sustainable natural antioxidants as alternatives to synthetic additives.
Conclusion
While predominantly known as a synthetic industrial additive, butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT) is also produced naturally by various organisms. Freshwater algae and cyanobacteria, certain fungi found on olives, and specific plants like lychee and Cytisus triflorus all contribute to the natural occurrence of BHT, using it as a protective antioxidant. The quantities of natural BHT are too low and costly for commercial use, so the synthetic version remains the industry standard. However, the identification of these natural sources is valuable for research into developing natural and sustainable alternatives to synthetic additives.