Deciphering Dysphagia: Understanding the Different Frameworks
When a healthcare professional, such as a Speech-Language Pathologist (SLP), diagnoses dysphagia, they determine the appropriate diet texture based on swallowing ability. The term "Level 2 dysphagia" can refer to different things depending on which dietary framework is used: the older National Dysphagia Diet (NDD) or the newer International Dysphagia Diet Standardisation Initiative (IDDSI).
The National Dysphagia Diet (NDD) Level 2: Mechanically Altered
The NDD was the primary framework in the U.S. until the adoption of the more standardized IDDSI system. Under the NDD, a Level 2 diet is known as "Mechanically Altered". This involves modifying regular foods to make them soft, moist, and easy to chew.
- Food Texture: Foods are ground, chopped, or mashed into small pieces, typically no larger than 1/4 inch.
- Key Characteristics: The food is moist and cohesive, meaning it sticks together well and doesn't separate into a thin liquid and a solid portion.
- Chewing Ability: This diet is for individuals who have some chewing ability but struggle with hard, tough, or crunchy foods.
The International Dysphagia Diet Standardisation Initiative (IDDSI) and Level 2
The IDDSI is the current global standard, providing a more detailed and consistent framework. In the IDDSI system, a Level 2 designation applies specifically to liquids, while the solid food equivalent for the NDD Level 2 is IDDSI Level 5. This is a crucial distinction that healthcare providers communicate to ensure patient safety.
- IDDSI Level 2: Mildly Thick Liquids
- Consistency: Mildly thick drinks flow slower than thin liquids (Level 0) and slightly thick liquids (Level 1) but can still be consumed from a cup or with a straw.
- Purpose: These liquids are easier to control in the mouth for individuals who have difficulty managing thinner fluids safely.
- Testing: The IDDSI flow test, using a 10 mL syringe, is the standard method for checking the thickness.
- IDDSI Level 5: Minced and Moist Solids
- Consistency: This level corresponds to the NDD's mechanically altered diet, with foods finely minced or mashed and always combined with a moist sauce or gravy.
- Particle Size: Food particles must be small, typically no larger than 4mm for adults, and the texture must be soft and easy to mash with a fork.
Foods for a Mechanically Altered Diet (NDD Level 2 / IDDSI Level 5)
Navigating a dysphagia diet requires careful meal planning and preparation to avoid unsafe food textures. Here is a list of recommended and prohibited foods for a Mechanically Altered diet.
Foods to Enjoy
- Grains: Moist, soft pancakes or bread with syrup; cooked cereals like oatmeal; moistened dry cereals with little texture.
- Meats and Protein: Moistened ground or finely chopped meat, poultry, or fish with gravy; tuna or egg salad without large chunks; soft-cooked eggs.
- Vegetables: Well-cooked, soft vegetables that are diced or mashed and served with sauce.
- Fruits: Canned, drained fruits without seeds or skin; ripe banana; fruit pies with only a soft bottom crust.
- Dairy: Pudding, custard, yogurt with no chunky fruit, cottage cheese, and soft cheeses.
- Other: Soups with small, soft pieces of meat and vegetables (less than 1/2 inch); sauces, gravies, and dressings.
Foods to Avoid
- Grains: Dry, crusty breads; tough crackers; rice; cereals with seeds or dried fruit.
- Meats and Protein: Tough, dry meats; sausages, hot dogs, or bacon; cheese cubes or slices.
- Vegetables: Raw or undercooked vegetables; corn; peas; fibrous vegetables like broccoli and asparagus.
- Fruits: Raw, fibrous fruits; pineapple; fruits with skins or seeds; coconut; dried fruits.
- Other: Sticky foods like peanut butter; nuts; seeds; tough or chewy candies.
Comparison of NDD Level 2 and IDDSI Level 5 Standards
| Aspect | NDD Level 2 (Mechanically Altered) | IDDSI Level 5 (Minced and Moist) |
|---|---|---|
| Terminology | Older, U.S.-based terminology. Sometimes called "mechanical soft." | Newer, internationally standardized term. More specific and descriptive. |
| Food Particle Size | Food pieces generally no larger than 1/4 inch. | Adult size: particles up to 4mm wide and 15mm long. Pediatric size: 2mm particles. |
| Moisture Requirement | Requires added moisture (gravy, sauce) to keep food cohesive. | Explicitly requires food to be soft, moist, and cohesive throughout. |
| Testing Method | No standardized bedside testing method for texture consistency. | Uses a fork pressure test: food should squash easily and leave clear fork marks. |
| Mixed Consistencies | Often discouraged due to increased aspiration risk. | Strongly discouraged, as a mix of thin liquid and solids is unsafe. |
Important Considerations for Managing Level 2 Dysphagia
Living with dysphagia requires more than just dietary changes. Following proper eating techniques and managing your environment can significantly reduce risks.
- Swallowing Techniques: Your SLP will teach you specific techniques, such as the chin-tuck position, to facilitate a safer swallow.
- Positioning: Always sit fully upright when eating and drinking. Remain in an upright position for at least 30 minutes after your meal to aid digestion and prevent reflux.
- Oral Hygiene: Good oral hygiene is vital to prevent aspiration pneumonia. Poor swallowing can leave food particles in the mouth, which can lead to bacterial growth.
- Hydration: Pay close attention to hydration levels. Thicken liquids according to the level prescribed by your healthcare provider. Thickened water, juice, or milkshakes can help meet fluid needs.
- Caregiver Education: If you are a caregiver, it is important to understand the recommended diet and techniques. Attending medical appointments and helping with exercises can improve outcomes.
- Watch for Red Flags: Be alert for signs of swallowing difficulty, such as coughing, choking, or a gurgly voice after eating. Report any new or worsening symptoms to a healthcare provider.
Conclusion: Navigating Your Dysphagia Journey
Understanding what does level 2 dysphagia mean is a vital step toward managing this condition safely and effectively. Whether following the NDD or IDDSI guidelines, the focus is on creating a soft, moist, and cohesive food texture to minimize the risk of choking and aspiration. Regular consultation with a healthcare team, including an SLP and a dietitian, is essential to tailor a plan that meets individual needs. By adhering to dietary modifications, practicing safe swallowing techniques, and managing hydration, individuals can maintain proper nutrition and a higher quality of life.