Skip to content

What is the difference between a feeding tube and a NGT?

4 min read

According to the Cleveland Clinic, a feeding tube provides liquid nutrition when oral intake is insufficient. This encompasses various devices, but what is the difference between a feeding tube and a NGT? The primary distinction lies in their purpose, duration, and method of insertion.

Quick Summary

A nasogastric tube (NGT) is a specific, temporary type of feeding tube inserted via the nose, while 'feeding tube' is a broader term for various devices, including long-term options that are surgically placed.

Key Points

  • Broad vs. Specific Terminology: 'Feeding tube' is a general category, while 'nasogastric tube' (NGT) refers to a specific type of temporary feeding tube.

  • Placement Method: NGTs are inserted non-surgically through the nose and into the stomach, whereas long-term feeding tubes require a surgical or endoscopic procedure through the abdominal wall.

  • Duration of Use: NGTs are for short-term nutritional needs (under 4-6 weeks), while surgically placed feeding tubes like PEGs are designed for long-term support.

  • Comfort and Visibility: NGTs can cause nasal discomfort and are more visible. Long-term tubes are often better tolerated and can be low-profile and discreet.

  • Risks and Complications: NGTs have a higher risk of dislodgement and aspiration, especially if the patient is supine. All enteral feeding carries risks like infection, clogging, and GI distress.

  • Decision-Making: The choice of feeding method depends on the patient's medical condition, prognosis, and the anticipated length of nutritional support.

In This Article

Understanding the Broader Term: What Is a Feeding Tube?

A 'feeding tube' is a general term for any device used to provide enteral nutrition, fluids, or medication directly into the gastrointestinal (GI) tract. This route of administration, known as enteral nutrition, is used when a person cannot safely chew or swallow, or is unable to consume enough calories and nutrients orally. The type of feeding tube a person receives depends on the anticipated duration of use, the underlying medical condition, and the level of GI tract function.

Feeding tubes vary significantly in their placement and design. For instance, some are temporary and placed through the nose, while others are more permanent and inserted directly into the stomach or small intestine through a surgical procedure. This range of devices is what makes 'feeding tube' a broad, encompassing term.

A Specific Device: What Is a Nasogastric Tube (NGT)?

An NGT, or nasogastric tube, is a specific type of feeding tube. As its name suggests, 'naso' (nose) and 'gastric' (stomach), it is a thin, flexible plastic tube that is inserted through a nostril, passes down the throat and esophagus, and ends in the stomach. This procedure is relatively non-invasive, performed at the bedside, and does not require surgery.

Because NGTs are placed through the nasal passage, they are generally intended for short-term use, typically less than four to six weeks. Extended use can lead to complications such as nasal irritation, sinusitis, and potential damage to the throat or esophagus. After this period, if nutritional support is still needed, a healthcare provider will recommend a more permanent option.

NGTs are often used for a variety of temporary medical needs, including:

  • Providing nutrition and medication to patients who have difficulty swallowing, such as after a stroke.
  • Decompressing the stomach to relieve pressure from gas or fluid blockage.
  • Removing stomach contents in cases of poisoning or overdose.
  • Resting the bowel after certain surgeries.

The Many Types of Feeding Tubes

Beyond the NGT, several other feeding tubes exist, primarily categorized by their insertion method and intended duration of use. This highlights why an NGT is a specific type within a much larger category:

  • Gastrostomy (G-tube) / Percutaneous Endoscopic Gastrostomy (PEG) Tube: Inserted directly into the stomach through a small incision in the abdominal wall. These are for long-term use and require a minor surgical or endoscopic procedure for placement.
  • Jejunostomy (J-tube) Tube: Inserted through the abdominal wall directly into the jejunum (part of the small intestine). This bypasses the stomach and is useful for patients with gastric motility issues or a high risk of aspiration.
  • Nasojejunal (NJ) Tube: Similar to an NGT but extends past the stomach into the jejunum. This is still a temporary solution, but is used when gastric feeding is not suitable.

Key Differences Between a Feeding Tube and a NGT

The fundamental distinction is that an NGT is a type of feeding tube. The term 'feeding tube' is the general category, while an NGT is a specific example within that category, typically defined by its short-term nature and nasal placement. The most significant differences become apparent when comparing an NGT to the more permanent, surgically placed feeding tubes, like a PEG or G-tube.

Comparison Table: NGT vs. Other Feeding Tubes

Feature Nasogastric Tube (NGT) Long-Term Feeding Tube (e.g., PEG/G-tube)
Typical Duration Short-term (typically < 4-6 weeks) Long-term (months to years)
Placement Method Non-surgical, inserted through the nose Surgical or endoscopic procedure through abdominal wall
Patient Comfort Can cause nasal irritation and discomfort Generally better tolerated, with less impact on the nasal cavity
Visibility Prominent tubing from the nose to the feeding pump Discreet tubing connected to a low-profile button on the abdomen
Dislodgement Risk Higher risk, especially with coughing or confusion Lower risk, as it is securely anchored within the body
Cost & Logistics Lower initial cost, minimal preparation needed Higher initial cost, requires operating room time and specialist
Aspiration Risk Higher risk if not properly positioned, especially when supine Lower risk, especially with proper care and positioning

Benefits and Risks of Enteral Feeding

Enteral feeding via any tube, including an NGT, offers vital benefits for patients who cannot receive adequate nutrition orally. These include:

  • Ensuring adequate nutrition: Provides necessary calories, protein, fluids, and micronutrients.
  • Maintaining hydration: Supplies fluids without the need for intravenous (IV) hydration.
  • Safe medication administration: Allows medications to be delivered directly to the GI tract.
  • Reduced aspiration risk: For patients with certain swallowing difficulties, it can be a safer alternative than oral feeding.

However, all enteral feeding methods carry risks and potential complications. Common risks include:

  • Mechanical complications: Tube obstruction, dislodgement, or damage.
  • Infections: At the insertion site (for surgically placed tubes) or aspiration pneumonia from misplaced tubes or regurgitation.
  • Gastrointestinal issues: Nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, cramping, and bloating.
  • Insertion-related trauma: Although rare, improper NGT placement can cause injury to the esophagus or respiratory tract.

Conclusion

In the realm of nutrition diet and medical care, understanding the nuance between a general term like 'feeding tube' and a specific device like an NGT is crucial. An NGT is a temporary, non-surgical option for short-term nutritional support, typically lasting weeks. A feeding tube is the overarching category, including the NGT and long-term devices such as surgically placed PEG or G-tubes. The choice of device is determined by the patient's medical condition, prognosis, and the expected duration of nutritional intervention. Ultimately, the correct device and proper care are critical for ensuring a patient receives the necessary nutrients to recover and heal. For more information, you can visit the Cleveland Clinic on Tube Feeding.

Frequently Asked Questions

The main difference is that an NGT is a specific type of feeding tube. The term 'feeding tube' is broad and can refer to many devices, while an NGT is specifically defined by its short-term use and placement through the nose into the stomach.

An NGT is inserted non-surgically by a healthcare provider, who guides a thin, flexible tube through one of the nostrils, down the throat and esophagus, and into the stomach.

NGTs are designed for short-term use, typically lasting no more than four to six weeks. If longer-term nutritional support is needed, a different type of feeding tube will be considered.

A gastrostomy tube (G-tube), including a PEG tube, is a feeding tube that is surgically inserted directly into the stomach through the abdominal wall. Unlike an NGT, it is intended for long-term use and is more discreet and comfortable for long-term patients.

A nasogastric tube (NGT) is clearly visible coming out of the nose. However, surgically placed feeding tubes, like a low-profile gastrostomy button, are more discreet and are only visible at the small insertion site on the abdomen.

The primary risks associated with NGTs include accidental dislodgement, nasal and throat irritation, and a higher risk of aspiration pneumonia, especially if the tube is misplaced or the patient is lying flat.

Initial placement of any feeding tube is typically confirmed by an X-ray. Before each use of an NGT, placement is checked by observing the tube's external markings and sometimes testing the pH of gastric aspirate, though X-ray is the most definitive method.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.