What is the highest calorie cookie in the US?

November 7, 2025 •

4 min read

According to reports from late 2024 and mid-2025, Crumbl Cookies is responsible for some of the highest-calorie treats on the market, with limited-time offerings exceeding 1,200 calories each, which begs the question, what is the highest calorie cookie in the US?. This oversized phenomenon has drawn significant attention, alarming health experts and surprising customers.

Quick Summary

An exploration of the most calorically-dense cookie available in the US market, identifying the main contenders and explaining the factors contributing to their high-calorie counts. This overview details the nutritional facts and context surrounding these treats.

Key Points

Crumbl Cookies often holds the title: The bakery chain is frequently cited for producing some of the highest-calorie cookies and desserts in the US, often with limited-time flavors exceeding 1,200 calories.
Limited-time offerings are the most caloric: Specific seasonal or promotional flavors, like the S'mores Brownie (1,240 calories) or Jimmy Fallon's Candy Cane Brownie (1,200+ calories), are often the most extreme examples.
Size and ingredients are the main factors: The high calorie count is a result of cookies being oversized (around 6 ounces) and packed with rich ingredients like frosting, ganache, and excess sugar.
Serving sizes can be misleading: Many companies, like Crumbl, state their cookies contain multiple servings, which can cause consumers to underestimate the total calories in one sitting.
Other contenders exist, but often fall short: While chains like Costco and Panera offer high-calorie cookies, they typically do not reach the extreme levels seen in some specialty bakery items.
Health experts express concern: The Centers for Science in the Public Interest and other health professionals have raised alarms about the caloric and nutritional density of these oversized desserts.
Moderation is critical: Enjoying these decadent cookies occasionally and mindfully is the best approach for maintaining a balanced diet, given their significant impact on daily caloric intake.

The Crown of Calories: Crumbl's Record-Breaking Offerings

For anyone searching for the most calorically-dense cookie in the US, the answer almost always circles back to Crumbl Cookies, a viral sensation known for its giant, 6-ounce cookies and rotating flavor menu. The company has become notorious not only for its creative desserts but also for their hefty nutritional profiles. While many flavors regularly approach 1,000 calories, limited-time special editions have pushed the boundaries even further.

Notable High-Calorie Crumbl Cookies

S'mores Brownie (Summer 2025): This limited-time dessert was reported to be one of the highest ever, at 1,240 calories, confirming the company's penchant for pushing the limits.
Jimmy Fallon "Candy Cane Brownie" (Holiday 2024): This seasonal brownie-cookie hybrid was reported to be over 1,200 calories, causing an uproar on social media and highlighting Crumbl's high-calorie offerings.
Biscoff® Pie (Variable): Another contender for the most caloric cookie, this flavor has been cited as reaching 1,130 calories per cookie, a testament to its rich ingredients.

These numbers illustrate that Crumbl's weekly menu often includes creations that can constitute a significant portion of an average adult's daily caloric intake. This is particularly concerning as the company's serving size, which is one-quarter of a cookie, is often overlooked by consumers.

Fast Food and Bakery Cookie Competition

While Crumbl is a dominant force in the high-calorie cookie space, other players also offer remarkably decadent options. Fast food chains and warehouse stores sometimes release equally large and indulgent cookies that compete for the title of the highest-calorie treat.

A Look at the Competition

Panera Kitchen Sink Cookie: With 820 calories, this fast-food cookie includes multiple sweet and salty ingredients, contributing to its high-energy density.
Costco's Double Chocolate Chunk Cookie: The warehouse giant made waves in early 2024 with the introduction of its new food court cookie, which boasts 750 calories per cookie, much to the surprise of its customers.
Other Fast Food and Bakery Items: Brands like Subway and Chick-fil-A have cookies, but they generally fall into a much lower calorie range (220-350 calories), showing a stark contrast to the gourmet or specialty bakery cookies.

Comparison Table: High-Calorie Cookies in the US


Cookie Item	Calories (Approx.)	Type	Noteworthy Features
Crumbl S'mores Brownie	1,240	Gourmet Bakery	Limited-time dessert, extremely high fat and sugar
Crumbl Biscoff® Pie	1,130	Gourmet Bakery	Rich Biscoff cookie butter, filling, and toppings
Panera Kitchen Sink	820	Fast-Food	Loaded with caramel, chocolate, and pretzels
Costco Double Chocolate	750	Warehouse Food Court	Large, dense chocolate chunk cookie
Subway Chocolate Chip	220	Fast-Food	Standard, smaller-sized cookie

Why Are These Cookies So High in Calories?

The high-calorie nature of these cookies isn't a secret but rather a consequence of a few key factors. Primarily, the oversized portions and generous use of high-fat, high-sugar ingredients contribute to the final energy count. For instance, a Crumbl cookie often weighs 6 ounces, which is significantly larger than a standard homemade cookie.

Second, gourmet and fast-food cookies are frequently loaded with indulgent additions like buttercream frosting, rich ganache, extra chocolate chunks, or various candies, all of which substantially increase the calorie count. For example, a single Crumbl cookie can contain a full day's worth of saturated fat and more than half a day's worth of added sugar, as noted by the Center for Science in the Public Interest.

Furthermore, the sheer density of the cookie dough itself contributes to the high numbers. Recipes for these decadent cookies are often heavy on butter and sugar, creating a rich texture but also a massive caloric load. This combination of size, ingredients, and toppings is what makes certain cookies stand out as exceptional calorie bombs.

Understanding the Nutritional Landscape

While the calorie counts of these cookies are eye-opening, it's essential to put them into context. The average daily caloric intake for an adult is around 2,000 calories, but many of these single cookies can represent nearly half or more of that amount. For individuals not paying close attention to portion sizes, this can lead to overconsumption and potential health issues. This is especially true for companies that obscure serving sizes on their menus, as Crumbl has been accused of doing.

Experts have raised concerns that without clear labeling and consumer awareness, it is easy to underestimate the nutritional impact of these oversized desserts. For instance, a person who buys a box of four Crumbl cookies and shares it might be completely unaware that eating just one cookie constitutes a massive dietary splurge.

Enjoying these cookies in moderation is key, and treating them as an occasional treat rather than a regular snack is crucial for maintaining a balanced diet. Ultimately, knowing the nutritional facts empowers consumers to make informed decisions about their food choices.

Conclusion: A Sweet but Hefty Indulgence

Ultimately, when asking what is the highest calorie cookie in the US, the answer is often found on the ever-rotating menu of gourmet bakery chains like Crumbl. With limited-time desserts occasionally surpassing 1,200 calories, these oversized and ingredient-heavy treats easily claim the top spot. While delicious, their caloric density and massive portions require consumers to exercise moderation and awareness. By understanding the nutritional impact of these cookies, people can better manage their health while still enjoying a sweet indulgence from time to time. This knowledge allows for a more informed and balanced approach to dessert consumption in a market full of increasingly decadent offerings.

Note: Specific caloric information for limited-time items can vary, and it's always best to check the manufacturer's nutritional information for the most current data. Check out Crumbl's nutrition page for current information.

Frequently Asked Questions

Crumbl Cookies is the company most frequently associated with producing some of the highest-calorie cookies in the US. Their rotating weekly menu often features oversized and decadent cookies with very high caloric counts.

While it varies by flavor, most standard Crumbl cookies contain between 700 and 1,000 calories each. The specific number depends on the ingredients and toppings for that week's menu.

Yes. According to multiple sources, Crumbl has released limited-time special items, such as the Jimmy Fallon 'Candy Cane Brownie' and a S'mores Brownie dessert, with calorie counts exceeding 1,200 calories per item.

These high-calorie gourmet cookies can easily contain more calories than a typical fast-food meal. For example, a 720-calorie Crumbl cookie has more energy than a McDonald's Big Mac (590 calories).

The high calorie count is primarily due to their large size, approximately 6 ounces per cookie, combined with rich, indulgent ingredients like excessive sugar, butter, and heavy frosting.

For nutritional purposes, many companies list the serving size as a fraction of the full cookie. For example, Crumbl often defines a single serving as one-fourth of a cookie, which many customers fail to realize.

Yes, other chains also offer high-calorie treats. For instance, the Panera Kitchen Sink Cookie is 820 calories, and Costco's Double Chocolate Chunk Cookie is 750 calories, though they tend to be lower than Crumbl's extreme limited-time offerings.