The Crown for Most Calorie Brownie at Crumbl
For a time, the crown for the most calorie-dense brownie at Crumbl belonged to a seasonal item, specifically the Jimmy Fallon “Candy Cane Brownie,” which reportedly featured over 1,200 calories per serving. The extremely high number for this limited-run treat was attributed to its decadent layers, including a brownie base, a thick peppermint buttercream frosting, a ganache drizzle, and a generous sprinkling of candy cane pieces. The rotating nature of Crumbl's menu means that a new contender could always emerge, but the Candy Cane Brownie remains a notable example of the company's more indulgent offerings.
Current High-Calorie Brownie Options
While the Candy Cane Brownie was a limited-time special, other high-calorie brownies have made appearances on Crumbl's menu. For example, the Dubai Chocolate Brownie, a flavor that has popped up periodically, is a powerful contender, with nutritional data from some stores showing it contains around 1,010 calories per brownie. The Dubai Chocolate Brownie is characterized by its intense chocolate flavor and rich composition, contributing to its substantial calorie count. Another frequent flyer, the Brookie Cookie, which is part brownie and part cookie, is also a high-calorie item, consistently delivering hundreds of calories per serving.
Factors Contributing to High Calorie Count
Several factors contribute to the high calorie count of Crumbl's brownies and other treats. One of the most significant is the sheer size of the product; one brownie often constitutes multiple servings. Many brownies at Crumbl are also topped with rich, high-fat ingredients such as:
- Thick Buttercreams: Large amounts of butter, powdered sugar, and cream are used to create the decadent frosting layers.
- Chocolate Ganache: A rich mixture of chocolate and cream adds both intense flavor and significant fat content.
- Additional Mix-ins and Toppings: Extra components like candy pieces, cookies, and other sugary add-ons inflate the total caloric value.
- Higher Fat and Sugar Content: The base brownie itself is made with generous quantities of butter and sugar to achieve its signature rich, fudgy texture.
How to Verify the Most Calorie Brownie at Crumbl
Because the most caloric brownie can change from week to week, the best way for customers to confirm the current highest-calorie option is to check Crumbl's official nutritional information. This is typically available on their website, in-store, and on the Crumbl app. The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) has previously criticized Crumbl for displaying calories per serving rather than per whole cookie or brownie, which can be misleading. Always double-check the serving size to get an accurate picture of the total calorie count.
A Comparison of Calorie-Dense Crumbl Items
To put the brownies' calorie counts into perspective, here is a comparison with other notable high-calorie items from Crumbl's rotational menu. This table uses general figures from nutritional listings, but exact values can vary based on location and specific ingredients.
| Item | Estimated Calorie Count | Key Ingredients | Brownie Component? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Candy Cane Brownie | 1200+ | Brownie, peppermint buttercream, ganache, candy canes | Yes |
| Dubai Chocolate Brownie | 1010 | Brownie, fudge, chocolate glaze, chocolate | Yes |
| Biscoff® Pie | 1130 | Biscoff cookie base, creamy filling, Biscoff crumbs | No |
| Tres Leches Cake | 990 | Cake soaked in three milks, whipped cream | No |
| Peanut Butter Bar Cookie | 910 | Peanut butter cookie, peanut butter frosting, chocolate | No |
Note: Calorie counts for brownies can vary by batch and are based on a full-size item. Seasonal items like the Candy Cane Brownie may not always be available.
Health Considerations for Crumbl's Brownies
While delicious, the high calorie, fat, and sugar content of Crumbl brownies means they should be enjoyed as an occasional treat rather than a regular staple. The saturated fat and sugar levels in many of these items can be alarmingly high for a single serving, sometimes exceeding the recommended daily intake for an adult. For those monitoring their health, portion control is key. A single brownie is often enough to share, and even a quarter of a brownie can be a satisfyingly decadent portion.
The Crumbl Experience and Caloric Density
The appeal of Crumbl lies in its rotating menu of large, indulgent cookies and brownies. This variety and the sheer size of the treats contribute to their high caloric density, but also to the excitement of trying new flavors each week. The company's transparency regarding nutrition facts, albeit sometimes presented in a way that requires careful reading, allows consumers to make informed decisions about their purchases. Ultimately, enjoying a high-calorie Crumbl brownie is about making a conscious choice to indulge in a rich, flavorful dessert, not about making it a regular dietary habit.
Conclusion
While the specific most calorie brownie at Crumbl is subject to the bakery's ever-changing menu, past limited-edition items like the Candy Cane Brownie have been known to break the 1,200-calorie mark. Among more recurring offerings, the Dubai Chocolate Brownie is a strong candidate for one of the highest-calorie options, often exceeding 1,000 calories. The best way to know for sure is to check the most current nutritional information directly on Crumbl's website or app, keeping in mind the actual serving size.
For up-to-date nutritional information, visit the official Crumbl Cookies Nutrition page: https://crumblcookies.com/nutrition.
