The Story Behind the Discontinuation
For many American consumers, the Mars bar was a beloved chocolate-covered confection featuring a core of nougat, almonds, and later, a layer of caramel. This version differed significantly from the international Mars bar, which contained nougat and caramel, but no almonds. In 2002, citing low sales and potential trademark issues, Mars, Inc. made the tough decision to remove the American Mars bar from store shelves. This created a nostalgic gap for those who grew up with the nutty, chewy candy, sparking a long-running search for its true successor.
The Official Replacement: Snickers Almond
To fill the void left by the discontinued American Mars bar, Mars, Inc. introduced the Snickers Almond in 2003. This new bar closely matched the flavor profile of its predecessor, featuring a combination of nougat, almonds, caramel, and milk chocolate. While the ingredients are nearly identical, some aficionados claim there are slight differences, such as the size of the almond pieces. Despite these minor tweaks, Snickers Almond is widely regarded as the closest thing to the classic American Mars bar and is considered its official replacement.
Finding the Other Mars Bar: The UK vs. US Milky Way
The confusion surrounding the Mars bar is compounded by the fact that the international version is still available in many parts of the world, including the United Kingdom. This version is made with a fluffy nougat and a layer of smooth caramel, covered in milk chocolate—but notably, it contains no almonds. Americans craving this particular combination don't need to look for an imported Mars bar. They can simply reach for a Milky Way bar, which offers the same caramel and nougat experience. This is because the US Milky Way is essentially the same product as the UK Mars bar, a fact stemming from the brand's international history.
A Table of Mars Bar Replacements and Equivalents
| Bar Name | Key Ingredients | Regional Availability | Notes | 
|---|---|---|---|
| US Mars Bar | Nougat, almonds, caramel, milk chocolate | Discontinued in 2002 | Briefly revived in 2010 and 2016 for limited runs. | 
| Snickers Almond | Nougat, almonds, caramel, milk chocolate | United States | Official replacement for the US Mars bar. | 
| UK Mars Bar | Nougat, caramel, milk chocolate | International | Still widely available outside the US. | 
| US Milky Way | Nougat, caramel, milk chocolate | United States | Equivalent to the international Mars bar. | 
Other Notable Discontinued Mars Inc. Products
Beyond the American Mars bar, the company has discontinued other popular products over the years, further fueling candy nostalgia. Understanding these changes helps complete the story of Mars's evolving product line.
What was the Marathon bar?
In the United Kingdom, what is now known as a Snickers bar was originally called a Marathon. The name was changed in 1990 to standardize the brand globally. Like the Mars bar, the Marathon/Snickers rename initially caused an outcry among loyal fans. Since then, Mars has capitalized on the nostalgia by re-releasing the Marathon bar for limited periods.
The Brief Return of the Mars Bar
The story of the American Mars bar doesn't end with its 2002 discontinuation. The company made two notable attempts at reintroduction. In January 2010, Walmart stores briefly sold the bar. It was then relaunched again in September 2016 by Ethel M Chocolates, a Mars subsidiary, with the original recipe that did not include caramel. These limited-time appearances offered a fleeting taste of the past but did not result in a permanent return.
Recreating the Taste
For those who miss the distinctive flavor of the American Mars bar, the Snickers Almond is the most convenient option. However, dedicated bakers and candy enthusiasts have developed homemade recipes to replicate the experience. These recipes often involve combining nougat, caramel, and chopped almonds, allowing for a personalized revival of the classic confection.
Conclusion: It's All About Which Bar You Missed
The question of what replaced the Mars bar depends entirely on which bar you're asking about. If you are a U.S. consumer missing the nutty, almond version, then the Snickers Almond is your modern-day substitute. If you're reminiscing about the simple caramel and nougat confection, the standard Milky Way is the candy you seek. The international Mars bar continues to thrive, while its American counterpart lives on through limited returns and close approximations. The candy world is full of these regional and historical quirks, making the story of the Mars bar a classic example of candy lore. Read more about the history of the Mars bar on Wikipedia.