What to replace Pepsi Max with for a healthier, tastier alternative

November 17, 2025 •

3 min read

A growing trend away from diet sodas towards healthier beverages is supported by recent market data. Many consumers are seeking what to replace Pepsi Max with, especially since some versions and flavors have been discontinued. Numerous satisfying alternatives are available, regardless of whether you're cutting down on artificial sweeteners or caffeine, or just seeking variety.

Quick Summary

This guide covers several zero-sugar and healthier alternatives to Pepsi Max, such as classic zero-calorie sodas, gut-friendly prebiotic drinks, naturally sweetened beverages, and DIY options. A comparison of taste, ingredients, and health benefits is provided to help find the perfect substitute.

Key Points

Cola Competitors: Coca-Cola Zero Sugar offers a taste closer to classic Coke, while Pepsi Zero Sugar is the updated version of Pepsi Max in many regions.
Natural & Clean Sweeteners: Brands like Zevia use stevia leaf extract for zero-calorie sweetness, avoiding common artificial sweeteners like aspartame.
Gut-Healthy Options: Prebiotic sodas such as Olipop and Poppi contain fiber and botanical extracts to support digestive health while providing flavor.
Simple & Hydrating: For a no-fuss alternative, try flavored sparkling waters like Bubly or Spindrift, or create your own infusions with fresh fruit.
Caffeine Consideration: If reducing caffeine is a goal, alternatives like herbal teas and many sparkling waters are naturally caffeine-free, unlike Pepsi Max.
Flavor Profile: Choose between a flavor that closely mimics cola, offers a unique fruity twist, or provides a clean, mild taste depending on your preference.

Your Guide to Replacing Pepsi Max

The bold, zero-sugar taste of Pepsi Max is a habit for many. However, a new beverage is often in order due to concerns over artificial sweeteners, caffeine intake, or a desire for change. The market offers a variety of exciting and healthier options. The best choice on what to replace Pepsi Max with will likely depend on what you value most: taste similarity, health benefits, or a simple, natural ingredients list.

Zero-Sugar Cola Competitors

If the primary goal is to find a direct cola replacement with the same zero-calorie, high-caffeine characteristics, a few contenders stand out.

Coca-Cola Zero Sugar: Often cited as a top rival, Coca-Cola Zero Sugar is formulated to taste more like the original, full-sugar Coke than Diet Coke does. It uses a different blend of sweeteners, which many find results in a smoother finish and less of a diet aftertaste compared to traditional diet sodas.
Pepsi Zero Sugar: The rebranded version of Pepsi Max in many regions, Pepsi Zero Sugar aims to deliver a maximum flavor experience with zero calories. It is worth revisiting if you haven't tried it since the rebranding, as some formulas may have been adjusted.
Virgil's Zero Sugar Cola: For a more craft-style and natural take on cola, Virgil's offers a zero-sugar option sweetened with a blend of stevia, erythritol, and monk fruit. This is a great choice for those looking to avoid common artificial sweeteners like aspartame.

Health-Conscious and Gut-Friendly Alternatives

Beyond the major brands, a whole new category of functional beverages has emerged, often promoting better gut health.

Olipop: This prebiotic soda contains botanical extracts and plant fiber to support a healthy gut microbiome. It comes in a variety of unique flavors, including a 'Vintage Cola,' and has significantly less sugar than traditional sodas.
Poppi: Poppi, another popular prebiotic soda, offers a variety of vibrant fruit-flavored options. It's made with apple cider vinegar and fruit juice for a distinctive taste and has low calories and sugar content.
Zevia: This brand offers a comprehensive range of zero-calorie, naturally flavored sodas sweetened with stevia leaf extract. Zevia's line includes everything from traditional cola and root beer to cream soda and fruity options, all without artificial sweeteners or colors.

Simple and Hydrating Options

Sometimes the best alternative is a return to simplicity. These options provide fizz and flavor without complex ingredients.

Sparkling Water (Plain or Flavored): Brands like LaCroix, Bubly, Spindrift, and Waterloo offer a wide selection of flavored sparkling waters with no calories, sugar, or artificial sweeteners. Spindrift is unique in that it uses real fruit juice for flavor.
Infused Water: Create a refreshing beverage by adding fresh fruits (like lemon, lime, or berries) and herbs (like mint or basil) to still or sparkling water. This gives you total control over the ingredients and flavor intensity.
Herbal Tea: Brewed tea, especially herbal varieties like hibiscus or peppermint, offers a zero-calorie, zero-sugar alternative with its own unique flavor profile. It can be enjoyed hot or iced for a refreshing drink.

Comparison of Pepsi Max Replacements

To make your decision easier, here is a breakdown of popular alternatives.


Feature	Coca-Cola Zero Sugar	Olipop	Zevia Cola	Infused Sparkling Water
Sweetener	Aspartame & Ace-K	Stevia, fruit juice	Stevia leaf extract	None (Natural Fruit)
Calories	0	Low (varies)	0	0
Caffeine	Present	Varies by flavor	Varies by flavor	0
Health Benefits	None	Prebiotic fiber for gut health	None (clean ingredients)	Hydration, natural vitamins
Key Flavor	Mimics Classic Coke	Unique, layered fruit/cola	Stevia-based cola	Customizable with fruit/herbs
Best for	Direct cola taste	Digestive wellness	Avoiding artificial sweeteners	Pure, simple refreshment

Conclusion: Finding Your New Go-To

Choosing what to replace Pepsi Max with is a personal journey that depends on your palate and health goals. If the bold cola flavor is what you'll miss most, then trying Coca-Cola Zero Sugar or Pepsi Zero Sugar is the most straightforward option. For those seeking a more health-forward upgrade, the gut-friendly prebiotic sodas like Olipop and Poppi offer a modern twist on the classic fizzy drink. And for the purest, most customizable experience, nothing beats sparkling water infused with natural flavors. Experiment with a few options to discover the one that best satisfies your cravings while aligning with your overall wellness.

Shop for healthy soda alternatives

Frequently Asked Questions

While the name 'Pepsi Max' has been replaced by 'Pepsi Zero Sugar' in some markets like the U.S., the product is still sold under the 'Max' name in other regions, including the UK and Australia. In some instances, specific flavors, such as Pepsi Max Raspberry, have been discontinued to make way for new ones.

Plain or naturally flavored sparkling water is generally considered the healthiest alternative, as it offers hydration and fizz with no calories, sugar, or artificial ingredients. Options like prebiotic sodas (Olipop, Poppi) also offer additional health benefits for gut wellness.

According to many taste tests, Coca-Cola Zero Sugar is often cited as tasting closer to the original, full-sugar Coca-Cola than Diet Coke does. This is due to its specific blend of sweeteners designed to mimic the sugary taste more effectively.

For those avoiding aspartame, brands like Zevia are sweetened with stevia leaf extract. You can also opt for homemade fruit-infused sparkling water, which contains no sweeteners at all.

While the taste of gut-healthy sodas like Olipop and Poppi may be slightly different from traditional sodas, many people find the flavors to be complex and enjoyable. It may take a couple of tries to get used to the unique taste profiles.

Yes, you can easily create your own zero-sugar fizzy drink by combining sparkling water with natural fruit juices, fruit slices, or sugar-free flavor drops. This method allows you to control all the ingredients and avoid any artificial additives.

If you need a caffeinated alternative, you can consider unsweetened iced coffee, brewed iced tea, or some caffeinated sparkling waters. Check the product labels for specific caffeine content.