Skip to content

What type of lettuce tastes bitter?

4 min read

According to agricultural researchers, the bitterness in lettuce is often caused by a natural compound called lactucarium, which increases as the plant matures or experiences stress. Knowing exactly what type of lettuce tastes bitter, whether by nature or circumstance, can help you choose the right greens for your salad.

Quick Summary

Lettuce can taste bitter due to the compound lactucarium, which is naturally present in some varieties like chicory and radicchio and can also intensify from environmental factors. Younger leaves and cooler temperatures typically result in milder flavors.

Key Points

  • Naturally Bitter Greens: Chicories, including radicchio, endive, and frisée, are intentionally bitter and provide a sharp, earthy flavor to dishes.

  • Accidental Bitterness: Mild lettuce varieties can turn bitter due to environmental stresses like heat and drought, which trigger the production of a milky, bitter sap called lactucarium.

  • The Cause is Bolting: High temperatures can cause lettuce to 'bolt' or send up a flower stalk, dramatically increasing the bitter lactucarium content.

  • Reduce Bitterness: Methods to temper the bitter taste include soaking the leaves in cold water, cooking the greens, or balancing the flavor with sweet or acidic ingredients.

  • Harvest in the Morning: For home gardeners, harvesting lettuce during the cool morning hours can prevent the development of bitterness from afternoon heat.

  • Health Benefits: The bitter compounds in these greens, like glucosinolates, offer significant health benefits, including supporting digestion and detoxification.

In This Article

Naturally Bitter Lettuce: The Chicory Family

Not all bitter greens are a mistake; many are prized for their pungent, peppery, or nutty notes. Most of these intentionally bitter varieties belong to the chicory family, Cichorium. While not technically lettuce (Lactuca genus), they are staples in many salad mixes and often mistakenly identified as such.

Radicchio

Radicchio is one of the most recognizable and intensely bitter greens, known for its deep red or purple leaves with bright white veins. The most common round head variety is Chioggia, but other types like the elongated Treviso also exist. The bitterness of radicchio mellows significantly when cooked, such as by grilling or roasting.

Belgian Endive

Belgian endive, also known as witloof or chicon, has a mild to moderate bitterness. Its small, tightly packed, torpedo-shaped heads and pale leaves are a result of being grown in darkness to prevent chlorophyll development and reduce bitterness. Both white and red varieties are available.

Escarole and Frisée

These are other members of the chicory family, often referred to as 'endive' in the US. Escarole features broad, curly, crisp leaves that grow in a head, with a pleasantly bitter taste. Frisée, or curly endive, has delicate, frilly leaves and a more pronounced bitterness, contributing texture and flavor to mesclun salad mixes.

When Mild Lettuce Turns Bitter

Many classic lettuce varieties, like romaine or butterhead, are known for their mild, sweet flavor. However, they can develop a strong, bitter taste due to environmental stress or poor harvesting practices. This is caused by an increase in the production of lactucarium, the milky sap found in the plant's stem.

Bolting and Heat Stress

One of the most common reasons for bitterness is bolting, which is the process where a lettuce plant sends up a flower stalk to produce seeds. This is triggered by heat and signals the end of the plant's life cycle, causing a surge in bitter compounds. Warm weather, especially sudden heat waves, can quickly induce bolting, even in young plants.

Poor Growing Conditions

Inconsistent watering, lack of nutrients, or crowded conditions can also stress lettuce plants and cause them to become bitter prematurely. Lettuce thrives in cool, moist soil, so proper irrigation and soil fertility are crucial for sweet-tasting greens.

Harvesting Practices

The age of the plant and the time of harvest also play a role. Older leaves tend to be more bitter than young, tender ones. Furthermore, harvesting lettuce in the heat of the day can result in a more bitter taste. It is best to harvest leafy greens in the cool of the morning.

Comparison: Bitter vs. Mild Greens

Characteristic Bitter Greens (Chicories) Mild Greens (Butterhead, Iceberg)
Flavor Profile Pungent, peppery, earthy, or nutty notes. Mild, sweet, and refreshing.
Texture Firm, crisp, and sturdy leaves. Tender, delicate, and watery leaves.
Common Uses Salads, cooking (braising, grilling), balancing rich foods. Salads, sandwiches, wraps, garnishes.
Bitterness Source High levels of lactucarium and other compounds inherent to the variety. Heat stress, bolting, improper harvesting, or plant age.

How to Reduce the Bitterness in Lettuce

If you find your lettuce is too bitter, there are several methods you can use to salvage it:

  • Soak in Cold Water: Submerging lettuce leaves in very cold or ice water for 10-15 minutes can help draw out some of the bitter compounds and restore crispness.
  • Cook the Greens: Applying heat through braising, sautéing, or grilling will mellow the bitterness and can even bring out a natural sweetness. This works well for chicories and tougher leafy greens.
  • Balance with Flavor: Pair bitter greens with other ingredients that contrast the flavor. Sweet fruits like pears or oranges, creamy dressings, salty cheeses (like goat cheese), or acidic vinaigrettes can all create a more balanced dish.
  • Blanching: For very bitter greens, a quick dip in boiling water followed by an ice bath can significantly reduce the bitter taste. This is best for cooking, not for fresh salads.
  • Harvest Earlier: For home gardeners, the best prevention is harvesting younger leaves or selecting heat-tolerant, slow-bolting varieties.

The Health Benefits of Bitter Greens

Despite their sharp flavor, bitter greens are nutritional powerhouses. They are rich in vitamins K, A, and C, as well as minerals like potassium and calcium. The bitter compounds that we taste, such as glucosinolates, have potent antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties that can support liver detoxification and aid digestion. Eating bitter foods stimulates digestive enzymes, promoting healthier nutrient absorption. This makes these greens a valuable addition to a balanced diet.

Conclusion

Understanding what type of lettuce tastes bitter helps you make informed choices, whether you're seeking a specific flavor or trying to avoid an unpleasant surprise. While chicories are intentionally bitter, even mild lettuces can develop a sharp flavor due to stress. The key is knowing how to manage bitterness, from proper growing techniques to balancing flavors in the kitchen. For more information on different types of salad greens, check out this guide from Epicurious. By embracing or mitigating the bitter notes, you can enjoy a wider and more flavorful range of fresh vegetables.

This article is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional dietary or health advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

You can tell if wild lettuce is bitter by tasting a young leaf. Most wild varieties, especially prickly lettuce (Lactuca serriola), have a very intense bitter taste that increases as the plant matures and bolts. The milky sap that oozes from the stem is also a clear indicator of its bitterness.

Romaine lettuce can have a slightly bitter edge, especially in the outer leaves and thicker ribs. This bitterness becomes more pronounced when the plant is stressed by heat or left in the ground too long, causing it to bolt and produce more bitter compounds.

To make chicory less bitter, you can soak the cut leaves in cold water for a period of time to draw out some of the bitter-tasting compounds. Cooking chicory, such as braising or grilling, will also significantly mellow its bitterness and bring out a natural sweetness.

Iceberg lettuce is generally considered less likely to become bitter than other types, but like any lettuce, it can develop a bitter taste if it is grown in high heat, not watered properly, or left too long before harvesting.

The milky sap is called lactucarium, and it is a type of plant latex. It contains bitter-tasting compounds, primarily lactucin and lactucopicrin, which are responsible for the lettuce's bitter flavor.

Generally, butterhead varieties like Boston or Bibb lettuce, as well as young, tender looseleaf lettuces, are known for their mildest, sweetest flavor. These types are less prone to becoming bitter, especially when grown and harvested correctly.

Yes, bitter greens are very healthy. They are packed with vitamins A, C, and K, as well as important minerals. The bitter compounds also stimulate digestion, promote nutrient absorption, and have antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.