Skip to content

What's the Difference Between Active O2 and Regular Water?

4 min read

According to scientific studies, the human body's primary oxygen intake comes from breathing through the lungs, not from absorbing oxygen dissolved in water via the digestive tract. This fundamental physiological fact sets the stage for a crucial discussion regarding the purported benefits of beverages like Active O2 compared to ordinary water.

Quick Summary

Active O2 is an oxygenated mineral water with added oxygen and flavor, marketed with enhanced performance and energy claims. Regular water is plain H2O that provides basic hydration, the primary function of both beverages. The added benefits of oxygenated water remain largely unsubstantiated by robust scientific evidence.

Key Points

  • Claim vs. Reality: Active O2 is marketed for enhanced performance and energy, but scientific evidence indicates these benefits are insignificant compared to regular water.

  • Oxygen Absorption: The human body absorbs oxygen primarily through the lungs, not through the digestive system from drinking water.

  • Flavor and Electrolytes: Active O2's distinct features are added flavors and electrolytes, which contribute to taste and can aid athletes, respectively, but don't validate its core oxygenation claims.

  • Cost Difference: Active O2 is more expensive than regular water, making plain water the more economical choice for daily hydration.

  • Placebo Effect: Any perceived energy boost from Active O2 is most likely a placebo effect, as scientific studies show no physiological improvements.

  • Superior Hydration: When it comes to basic hydration, regular water is just as effective and scientifically sound as oxygenated water.

In This Article

Active O2 and Oxygenated Water Explained

Active O2, produced by Adelholzener, is a brand of oxygenated mineral water that includes added oxygen, electrolytes, and flavorings. The manufacturer claims that this extra oxygen can provide health benefits beyond simple hydration, such as boosting energy and improving athletic performance. The process, often called aeration, involves infusing water with a higher concentration of dissolved oxygen than naturally occurs. While this creates a unique, sometimes described as 'crisper' taste, its physiological impact on the human body is a point of contention among experts.

The Science (or Lack Thereof) Behind the Claims

Multiple controlled studies have investigated the effects of oxygenated water on physical performance and have consistently found no significant difference between subjects who consumed oxygenated water and those who consumed regular water. These studies measured factors like maximal oxygen uptake, blood lactate levels, and time to exhaustion, showing that the minute quantities of extra oxygen are physiologically insignificant.

Experts point out that the human body's respiratory system is highly efficient at absorbing oxygen through the lungs, and the amount of oxygen that can be absorbed through the gastrointestinal tract from water is negligible. One breath of fresh air contains more oxygen than a litre of hyperoxygenated water, putting the purported benefits into stark perspective. Marketing tactics often leverage the general knowledge that oxygen is vital for life to imply that 'more is better,' even if the delivery method is ineffective.

Why the Flavoring and Electrolytes?

Unlike plain tap or bottled water, Active O2 is often a flavored beverage, with options like apple, citrus, and orange. The pleasant taste makes it a more appealing option for some consumers who might otherwise find plain water boring. Additionally, some versions include electrolytes, which can be beneficial for athletes needing to replenish lost minerals after intense exercise. For the average person, a balanced diet is sufficient for electrolyte intake, making the added cost of flavored, oxygenated water potentially unnecessary for daily hydration.

Comparison: Active O2 vs. Regular Water

Feature Active O2 (Oxygenated Water) Regular Water (Tap or Bottled)
Composition Mineral water with added oxygen, flavors, and electrolytes Plain H₂O, may contain naturally occurring minerals
Oxygen Content Infused with a higher concentration of dissolved oxygen Contains naturally dissolved oxygen, significantly less than in Active O2
Cost Significantly more expensive due to processing and marketing Affordable and widely accessible
Taste Flavored options available, often described as crisp Tasteless, though can vary slightly depending on the source
Proven Benefits Primarily offers hydration and flavor. The effects of added oxygen are not substantiated Provides essential hydration for proper bodily function
Target Audience Marketed towards fitness enthusiasts and health-conscious consumers Universal for all hydration needs

The True Verdict on Active O2 vs. Regular Water

Ultimately, the choice between Active O2 and regular water boils down to personal preference for taste and willingness to pay for unproven benefits. Scientific evidence overwhelmingly suggests that the extra oxygen infused into Active O2 does not provide a meaningful physiological advantage over regular water. Your respiratory system, not your digestive system, is responsible for meeting your body's oxygen demands. While Active O2's flavors can make hydration more enjoyable for some, plain water remains the most effective, economical, and scientifically validated choice for staying hydrated.

Can Oxygenated Water Boost Athletic Performance?

No, robust scientific research shows that drinking oxygenated water does not significantly enhance athletic performance or recovery. The quantity of oxygen provided is miniscule compared to what is absorbed through breathing.

Is the Added Oxygen in Active O2 Absorbed?

While a minimal amount may be absorbed through mucous membranes, the majority of the added oxygen is not effectively absorbed through the digestive system and does not significantly impact blood oxygen levels.

Is Active O2 Just Flavored Water?

In essence, for the average person, it functions much like flavored water. The primary difference from plain flavored water is the inclusion of extra dissolved oxygen, the benefits of which are scientifically unproven.

Is Active O2 Hydrating?

Yes, like any water-based beverage, Active O2 is hydrating. However, it is not more hydrating than regular water, as the extra oxygen does not improve the body's hydration processes.

Why Do People Report Feeling More Energetic?

Reported energy boosts are likely due to the placebo effect or simply the act of rehydrating. If a person believes a product will enhance their performance, their perception and effort can sometimes reflect that belief.

Are There Any Risks to Drinking Active O2?

For most people, drinking Active O2 is generally safe. The primary risk is financial, as you are paying a premium for a product whose key health claims are not supported by science.

What About the Electrolytes in Active O2?

Some varieties of Active O2 contain electrolytes, which can be helpful for those who have sweated heavily. However, for everyday hydration, a balanced diet provides sufficient electrolytes. For serious athletes, a more specifically formulated sports drink may be more effective.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, scientific research has found no significant difference in performance or recovery between athletes who drink oxygenated water versus regular water.

The human body is not designed to absorb oxygen through the digestive tract. Any absorption is minimal and does not impact blood oxygen levels in a meaningful way.

The higher cost of Active O2 is due to the added processes for oxygen infusion, flavoring, and marketing, not because it provides superior hydration or health benefits.

Yes, regular water is equally effective for basic hydration, which is the primary proven benefit of both beverages.

The primary difference is that Active O2 is mineral water infused with extra oxygen and flavor, while regular water is plain H₂O. The extra oxygen, however, provides no scientifically backed health advantage when ingested.

Any feeling of increased energy from drinking Active O2 is most likely a result of the placebo effect or general hydration, not the minimal added oxygen.

The infusion process gives oxygenated water a unique, 'crisper' taste and texture that some people prefer. Additionally, Active O2 is available in various flavors.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.