Blue Smartwater vs. Black Smartwater: A Detailed Comparison
For years, Smartwater has been a staple in the bottled water market, known for its vapor distillation and added electrolytes. The brand, however, has expanded its line to include specialized products, most notably the alkaline version. The key distinction between blue and black smartwater comes down to their purification process and the final product's properties, which are targeted at slightly different consumer preferences.
The Original: Blue Smartwater
The blue-labeled Smartwater is the original, classic offering from the brand. Its purification process is unique and heavily marketed as "inspired by the clouds".
- Vapor Distillation: This process involves boiling water and collecting the resulting steam, which is then condensed back into water. This method removes a vast majority of impurities, contaminants, and minerals, resulting in an exceptionally pure water base.
- Added Electrolytes: After distillation, Smartwater adds a blend of electrolytes back into the water. These are primarily added for taste, giving the water its signature crisp and pure flavor. The electrolytes include calcium chloride, magnesium chloride, and potassium bicarbonate.
- Neutral pH: The original blue Smartwater has a neutral pH, similar to standard drinking water, making it a straightforward, clean hydration option for everyday consumption.
The Upgrade: Black Smartwater
The black-labeled Smartwater represents an evolution of the brand's offerings. It is marketed as an enhanced hydration option for those with active lifestyles.
- Alkaline Water: The most significant difference is that the black Smartwater is ionized to achieve a pH level of 9+. This makes it alkaline, which some consumers believe can help neutralize acidity in the body, though scientific evidence for this claim is limited.
- Added Antioxidants: In addition to the electrolytes found in the blue version, the black alkaline Smartwater is infused with the antioxidant selenium. Antioxidants help combat oxidative stress in the body.
- Same Pure Base: The black smartwater also starts with the same vapor-distilled process as the original, ensuring a clean and pure water base before the ionization and antioxidant steps.
Side-by-Side Comparison Table
| Feature | Blue Smartwater (Original) | Black Smartwater (Alkaline with Antioxidant) |
|---|---|---|
| Package Color | Royal Blue | Black |
| Purification Method | Vapor Distilled | Vapor Distilled |
| Added Electrolytes | Yes (for taste) | Yes (for taste) |
| pH Level | Neutral (approx. 7) | Ionized for 9+ pH |
| Antioxidants | No | Yes (contains selenium) |
| Best For | Everyday hydration | Active lifestyles, alkaline-conscious consumers |
| Price Point | Standard premium water | Often a slightly higher price point |
Which Should You Choose?
Choosing between blue and black smartwater depends on your hydration priorities. If you are simply looking for a clean, crisp, and pure water experience for daily hydration, the classic blue smartwater is an excellent choice. It provides a reliable product without any functional additives beyond the electrolytes for taste.
For those who are health-conscious and follow trends in functional beverages, the black alkaline smartwater might be more appealing. The 9+ pH level and added antioxidants cater to consumers who prefer alkaline products. It's important to remember that the scientifically proven benefits of alkaline water are still debated, but many people enjoy the perceived benefits and the taste profile.
Ultimately, both products offer a high-quality, vapor-distilled base with electrolytes. Your decision comes down to whether you prefer a neutral pH or are willing to pay a slight premium for the added alkalinity and antioxidant properties of the black-labeled version.
Conclusion
The difference between blue and black smartwater is not a matter of quality, but of enhanced features. While both start as vapor-distilled water with added electrolytes for a fresh, crisp taste, the black-packaged version goes a step further by being ionized to a higher pH of 9+ and infused with the antioxidant selenium. The blue bottle is for those who seek the pure, classic hydration experience, while the black is for those interested in the potential benefits of an alkaline beverage. As with any wellness product, consumers should consider their personal hydration needs and preferences when making a choice.
An interesting perspective on bottled water, including its sourcing and environmental impact, can be found in discussions about water filtration and purity from sources like Fountain Filters, which suggests that home filtration systems can be a smarter, more sustainable option than relying solely on bottled products.
