Skip to content

Which company has the healthiest pizza?

4 min read

With Americans eating an average of 46 slices of pizza per year, finding the healthiest option is key for diet-conscious individuals. Knowing which company has the healthiest pizza and how to customize it can transform a greasy guilty pleasure into a more balanced meal.

Quick Summary

This guide analyzes and compares the healthiest pizza options from popular chains, focusing on crusts, toppings, and customization to make informed nutritional choices.

Key Points

  • Customization is Key: Blaze Pizza offers the most control, allowing you to choose from a variety of healthier crusts and fresh toppings.

  • Low-Carb Options: Papa Murphy's offers a completely crustless pizza, while Blaze provides keto and cauliflower crusts for carb-conscious diners.

  • Thin Crust is Better: For traditional chains like Domino's and Pizza Hut, the thinnest crust available is the most nutritious starting point.

  • Veggies over Processed Meats: Loading up on vegetables and opting for lean proteins like chicken is the best strategy for lowering calories and fat.

  • Moderate the Cheese and Sauce: Asking for light cheese and sticking to a tomato-based sauce can significantly reduce saturated fat and sodium.

  • Portion Control Matters: Regardless of the brand, mindful portion sizing and pairing with a side salad can help balance your meal.

  • Blaze and Papa Murphy's Stand Out: For those seeking the healthiest commercial options, Blaze and Papa Murphy's offer the best flexibility and specific low-carb alternatives.

In This Article

Most people associate pizza with unhealthy, high-calorie food, but the truth is far more nuanced. The health profile of a pizza depends heavily on its ingredients and preparation, which can vary significantly between companies. While a definitive single 'healthiest' brand is difficult to declare, certain companies stand out for offering more nutritionally sound and customizable options than others. The key lies in understanding which choices at popular chains lead to a more balanced meal.

Blaze Pizza: The Leader in Customization

Blaze Pizza is often cited as a top contender for the healthiest pizza, primarily because of its assembly-line, fast-casual model that gives customers complete control over their pizza's composition. This level of customization allows for healthier ingredient selections that are simply not available at traditional chains.

Build-Your-Own with Healthy Ingredients

At Blaze, you start with a choice of crust, sauce, and toppings, building your pizza exactly as you want it. This means you can opt for nutrient-dense, vegetable-heavy options while minimizing less healthy components. For example, using a keto or cauliflower crust and loading up on vegetables is a significant step towards a healthier meal.

Keto and Cauliflower Crusts

Blaze offers specialized crust options like the Keto Crust and Cauliflower Crust, which drastically alter the nutritional profile. A slice of a customizable Blaze pizza on a Keto Crust can have as few as 7 grams of carbohydrates and 10 grams of protein, especially when topped with smart ingredient choices like ricotta and veggies. This flexibility makes it a frontrunner for those following low-carb diets.

Papa Murphy's: Best for Take-and-Bake Control

Papa Murphy's is a unique player in the pizza market because it's a take-and-bake service, giving you control over the final bake and, crucially, offering a crustless option. This empowers you to make healthier choices at home.

Crustless and Thin Crust Options

The most significant healthy offering from Papa Murphy's is its Crustless Keto-Friendly Pizza, which comes in a tray and is topped with sauce, cheese, and your choice of protein and vegetables. This completely eliminates the refined carbs from the dough. For those who still want a traditional base, the thin crust is another excellent, lower-calorie alternative to their original dough. Filling these options with lean proteins like grilled chicken and ample vegetables makes for a very healthy, satisfying meal.

Domino's and Pizza Hut: Healthier Standard Options

While not as customizable as Blaze or offering the unique take-and-bake benefits of Papa Murphy's, traditional chains like Domino's and Pizza Hut still provide healthier menu items if you know what to look for.

Customizing Thin Crusts

The thin-crust veggie pizza is consistently the most recommended healthy choice at these restaurants. A thin crust significantly cuts down on carbs and calories compared to hand-tossed or stuffed crusts. By ordering a veggie-focused pie with light cheese, you can create a surprisingly balanced fast-food meal.

General Rules for Healthier Pizza

No matter which company you choose, a few general rules can guide you toward a healthier pizza.

The Power of Your Toppings

  • Load up on vegetables: Increase fiber and nutrients by adding mushrooms, onions, bell peppers, spinach, and olives.
  • Choose lean protein: Opt for grilled chicken or turkey pepperoni over high-fat processed meats like traditional sausage or pepperoni.
  • Be smart with sauces: Stick to a tomato-based sauce instead of creamy alfredo or high-sugar BBQ sauces. Ask for less sauce to reduce calories and sodium.
  • Request light cheese: Cheese is a major source of saturated fat and sodium. Requesting light cheese can cut these significantly without sacrificing the flavor entirely.

How to Order Smarter

  • Portion control: Consider a personal pan size or split a larger pizza. A healthy meal can include 1-2 slices with a side salad.
  • Order thin crust: This is one of the most effective ways to lower the overall calorie and carb count.
  • Go half-and-half: If you're with someone who prefers meat, get half veggie and half meat-lover's to reduce your intake of processed meat toppings.
  • Add a side salad: Pairing your pizza with a side salad adds valuable fiber and nutrients and helps you feel full faster.

Fast Food Pizza Nutritional Comparison

Company Menu Item (Serving Size) Calories Total Fat Carbs Protein Sodium
Blaze Pizza Build-Your-Own Keto Crust w/ Ricotta & Veggies (1/8 pizza) 110 kcal 4 g 7 g 10 g 100 mg
Papa Murphy's Crustless Gourmet Veggie (1/8 tray) 100 kcal 7 g 4 g 6 g 300 mg
Papa Murphy's Thin Crust Garden Veggie (1/8 pizza) 220 kcal 9 g 26 g 6 g 570 mg
Domino's Thin Crust Pacific Veggie (1/4 small) 217 kcal 12.3 g 17 g 8.5 g 463 mg
Pizza Hut Thin 'N Crispy Veggie Lover's (1/8 small) 100 kcal 3 g 14 g 4 g 250 mg

Conclusion: Finding Your Healthiest Pizza

In the final analysis, there is no single 'healthiest' pizza company, as the best option depends on your dietary needs and preferences. However, Blaze Pizza offers the most flexibility for building a genuinely healthy meal from the ground up, especially with their low-carb crusts. Papa Murphy's provides the most innovative solution with its crustless keto options, perfect for those avoiding carbs completely. For traditional pizza lovers, customizing a thin-crust veggie pie at Pizza Hut or Domino's is the best route. Ultimately, the healthiest pizza is the one you customize with care, emphasizing vegetables, lean protein, and portion control, regardless of the brand. Making smarter ingredient choices is the most effective way to enjoy pizza and stay on track with your health goals.

For more in-depth nutritional guidance, consider visiting authoritative sources like the Cleveland Clinic's breakdown on healthy pizza modifications.

Frequently Asked Questions

For those on a keto diet, Blaze Pizza offers customizable keto crusts, and Papa Murphy's provides an excellent crustless pizza option, both of which are very low in carbohydrates when topped appropriately.

Yes, thin crust pizzas are almost always healthier because they contain less dough, which means fewer calories and carbohydrates compared to hand-tossed or thick-crust varieties.

The best healthy toppings include vegetables like spinach, mushrooms, onions, and bell peppers. For protein, opt for lean grilled chicken or turkey pepperoni to reduce unhealthy fats.

Yes, requesting light cheese is a highly effective way to reduce the amount of saturated fat, sodium, and total calories in your pizza, making it a healthier choice.

Making your own pizza at home gives you maximum control over all ingredients, including using whole-grain or vegetable-based crusts, low-sodium sauce, and fresh toppings. This generally results in a healthier meal than fast-food options.

Both Blaze Pizza and Papa Murphy's explicitly offer vegan cheese options, such as Violife dairy-free cheese at Papa Murphy's and a vegan cheese alternative at Blaze.

To avoid high sodium, stick to thin crusts, load up on vegetables instead of processed meats like pepperoni or sausage, request light cheese, and avoid extra salty dipping sauces.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.