Skip to content

Which drink has the most added sugar in it? An investigation into the surprising culprits

5 min read

According to Action on Sugar, some fast-food milkshakes contain up to 39 teaspoons of sugar, far exceeding the recommended daily intake. This shocking reality prompts the crucial question: which drink has the most added sugar in it, and where are these sugary landmines hiding in plain sight?

Quick Summary

This article uncovers the beverages with the highest levels of added sugar, from fast-food shakes to energy drinks. It compares the sugar content of various popular options and details the associated health risks of excessive sugar intake.

Key Points

  • Fast-food milkshakes can be the worst offenders: Some 'freakshakes' contain upwards of 35 teaspoons of sugar in a single serving.

  • Energy drinks are loaded with added sugar: Brands like Monster and Rockstar have some of the highest sugar content, often exceeding a full day's recommended limit in one can.

  • Hidden sugar is prevalent in fruit juices and smoothies: Despite appearing healthy, many fruit juices and smoothies contain concentrated sugars that can be just as problematic as soda.

  • Excessive sugar intake is linked to serious health issues: Consuming high amounts of sugary drinks is associated with increased risk of type 2 diabetes, heart disease, and obesity.

  • Reading nutrition labels is crucial: Always check the 'Added Sugars' line on the Nutrition Facts label, and pay close attention to serving sizes, which can be misleading.

  • Healthier alternatives exist: Options like water, unsweetened teas, and homemade fruit-infused water are excellent, low-sugar alternatives to most commercial beverages.

In This Article

The Shocking Truth About Sugary Beverages

Many consumers believe sodas are the primary source of excess sugar in their diet, but the truth is more complex. A wide range of drinks, often perceived as treats or energy boosters, are packed with alarmingly high levels of added sugar. The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends limiting daily sugar intake to around 6 to 10 teaspoons, but as this investigation reveals, many popular drinks blow past this recommendation in a single serving.

The 'Freakshake' Phenomenon

Among the most sugar-laden contenders are elaborate fast-food milkshakes, often called 'freakshakes'. These monstrous creations, loaded with syrups, creams, and candy, represent some of the highest single-serving sugar amounts on the market. In a 2018 survey by Action on Sugar, the Toby Carvery 'Unicorn Freakshake' was found to contain an astounding 39 teaspoons of sugar. Similarly, the Five Guys Banana and Chocolate Shake was reported to have 37 teaspoons, the equivalent of over four cans of cola. Even some vanilla shakes from major chains can contain over 80 grams of sugar. These drinks deliver a massive and unnecessary sugar and calorie payload with little nutritional value.

Energy Drinks: A High-Sugar Jolt

Energy drinks are another major category of high-sugar beverages. While they promise an energy boost, they often deliver it via a sugar rush that leads to an inevitable crash. Research from Vidrate showed a 500ml can of Rockstar Punched Energy has an immense 83.5 grams of sugar, or 21 teaspoons. Even a Monster Energy can (500ml) contains 14 teaspoons of sugar, a staggering amount that exceeds the WHO's recommended daily limit in one serving. The combination of caffeine and excessive sugar can have multiple negative health effects, including an increased risk of heart disease and type 2 diabetes.

Sugars in 'Healthy' Juices and Smoothies

Many people swap sodas for fruit juices or smoothies, assuming they are a healthier option. While 100% fruit juice contains natural sugars, these are still high in concentration and can affect blood sugar levels similarly to added sugar. Research highlighted by Dental Review News showed that grape juice, in a relatively small 250ml serving, could contain as much as 9 teaspoons of sugar, constituting a significant portion of the daily sugar threshold. Similarly, store-bought smoothies can be loaded with added sweeteners. A 450ml green smoothie cited in the same research contained 42 grams of sugar, exceeding the WHO's daily limit. It's crucial to differentiate between whole fruits, which contain fiber, and juices or concentrated forms, which deliver a concentrated dose of sugar.

A Deeper Look at Popular Sodas and Other Beverages

Even standard carbonated soft drinks, while widely known for their sugar content, can be underestimated. A 375ml can of Mountain Dew, for example, contains 46.1 grams of sugar, or 11.5 teaspoons. Old Jamaican Ginger Beer has an even higher sugar density, with nearly 16 grams per 100ml. Beyond sodas, specialty coffee drinks from popular chains, often laden with flavored syrups, whipped cream, and sugary toppings, can pack a punch. A single Frappuccino can contain 34 grams of added sugar. Even iced teas and sports drinks, marketed for hydration, are often sweetened with dozens of grams of sugar.

Comparison of Sugar Content in Popular Drinks

To put the sugar content into perspective, here is a comparison table of different sugary beverages, detailing their typical serving size and the estimated sugar content. This data is based on various surveys and reports from health organizations and news outlets. Note that formulations can vary by region and brand.

Drink Category Example Product Serving Size Sugar (g) Teaspoons (approx.) Primary Source
Milkshake Toby Carvery Unicorn Freakshake 1 serving 156g 39 Fast-food chains
Energy Drink Rockstar Punched Energy 500ml 83.5g 21 Brand/Survey
Sodas Mountain Dew 375ml 46.1g 11.5 Brand/Survey
Energy Drink Monster Energy 500ml 57g 14 Brand/Survey
Iced Tea Arizona Tea 23oz (680ml) 51g 12.7 Brand/Survey
Sports Drink Powerade Mountain Blast 600ml 34.8g 8.7 Brand/Survey
Fruit Juice 100% Apple Juice 15oz (440ml) ~49g 12.2 USDA/Survey

The Health Risks of Excess Sugar Consumption

High consumption of sugary drinks has been directly linked to numerous adverse health outcomes. These beverages provide a significant number of calories with little to no nutritional value, which can lead to weight gain and obesity. A new study highlighted on YouTube indicated that sugary drinks were responsible for an estimated 2.2 million new cases of type 2 diabetes globally in 2020 alone. Furthermore, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) cites frequent sugary drink consumption as a factor in heart disease and dental decay. These empty calories can displace more nutritious foods, contributing to nutrient deficiencies. The hidden sugar in many popular drinks makes it easy to exceed daily limits without realizing, putting long-term health at risk.

Making Informed and Healthy Choices

  • Read the label carefully: Always check the 'Nutrition Facts' panel. Look specifically at the 'Added Sugars' section to find out how much sugar the manufacturer put in the drink. Be mindful of the serving size; a large bottle often contains multiple servings, multiplying the stated sugar content.
  • Opt for water: Water, infused with fresh fruit, is the best and healthiest choice. It has zero calories and zero sugar, effectively quenching thirst and hydrating your body without harm.
  • Choose unsweetened options: Select unsweetened tea, coffee, or milk alternatives. Many brands offer low-sugar or sugar-free versions of their popular drinks.
  • Limit fast-food and specialty coffee: High-calorie, high-sugar specialty drinks from cafes and fast-food chains should be an occasional treat, not a regular indulgence. You can find healthier, lower-sugar alternatives by searching online for recipes, like this guide on making Homemade Vanilla Cream Soda.
  • Understand 'natural' isn't always better: Don't be fooled by the 'natural' label on fruit juices. The concentrated sugar can be just as harmful as table sugar when consumed in excess. Choose to eat whole fruit instead to get the beneficial fiber.

Conclusion: Navigating the Sugary Landscape

By carefully examining nutrition labels and understanding where the most added sugar in drinks is hiding, consumers can make more informed decisions. The high sugar content in many popular milkshakes, energy drinks, and even supposedly healthy options like smoothies and fruit juices poses a significant risk to health, contributing to obesity, diabetes, and other chronic conditions. Prioritizing water and unsweetened beverages, while making sugary treats a rare indulgence, is the best strategy for reducing sugar intake and improving overall well-being. By being vigilant and informed, you can navigate the complex world of beverages and protect your health from hidden sugar dangers.

Frequently Asked Questions

While it can vary by brand and product, elaborate fast-food 'freakshakes' often contain the most added sugar. The Toby Carvery Unicorn Freakshake was reported to have 39 teaspoons of sugar in one serving.

Yes, many energy drinks are extremely high in added sugar. Some brands, like Rockstar and Monster, can contain significantly more than a can of soda, often exceeding the WHO's recommended daily sugar limit.

Absolutely. Even 100% fruit juices are dense in sugar, and many commercial smoothies contain added sweeteners, making their sugar content comparable to, or even higher than, many sodas.

Excessive intake of sugary drinks is linked to weight gain, obesity, type 2 diabetes, and an increased risk of heart disease.

Always check the Nutrition Facts label. Look for the 'Added Sugars' line, which is usually listed below the 'Total Sugars' line. Remember to check the serving size, as a large bottle may contain several servings.

From a metabolic standpoint, consuming the concentrated sugar in juice, whether natural or added, can have a similar effect on the body. It causes a spike in blood sugar without the fiber found in whole fruit to slow absorption.

Yes. Healthier options include water, seltzer, unsweetened iced tea, black coffee, or water infused with fresh fruits like lime or orange.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.