Skip to content

Which drink is better for cough and cold?

4 min read

According to Mayo Clinic, drinking plenty of fluids is one of the most effective ways to combat coughs and colds, helping to loosen congestion and prevent dehydration. This raises the question: which drink is better for cough and cold symptoms, hot or cold?

Quick Summary

This guide examines the benefits of both warm and cold beverages for soothing cold and cough symptoms, including how they affect mucus and throat irritation. It compares popular options like honey and lemon tea, chicken broth, and cold water, providing insights to help you choose the best drink for your specific needs.

Key Points

  • Warm liquids soothe and loosen: Hot beverages like honey and lemon tea, herbal teas, and broth help coat the throat, reduce irritation, and thin mucus to ease congestion.

  • Cold drinks numb and reduce inflammation: For a painful, inflamed throat, cold drinks, popsicles, or ice chips can provide temporary numbing relief.

  • Hydration is paramount: Regardless of temperature, drinking plenty of fluids is the most important step for speeding up recovery and preventing dehydration.

  • Avoid dehydrating and irritating drinks: Steer clear of alcohol, caffeine, and high-sugar drinks, as they can worsen symptoms and weaken the immune system.

  • Check symptoms for best choice: Match your beverage choice to your primary symptom: warm for cough and congestion, cold for sore throat pain.

In This Article

Hydration: The Foundation of Recovery

Regardless of temperature, staying hydrated is the most important rule when you are sick. When your body is fighting a virus, it uses more fluids, and common symptoms like fever, sweating, and a runny nose can lead to dehydration. Drinking plenty of fluids ensures your body has the resources it needs to function optimally and clear out mucus.

Warm Drinks to Soothe and Loosen

Many traditional remedies for colds and coughs involve warm beverages, and for good reason. Warm liquids can be incredibly soothing for a sore throat and can help alleviate congestion.

  • Honey and Lemon Tea: A classic remedy, this combination offers multiple benefits. Honey coats the throat, reducing irritation and acting as a natural cough suppressant. Lemon adds a dose of vitamin C and has antibacterial properties. Ginger can also be added for its anti-inflammatory effects.
  • Herbal Teas: Specific herbal teas can offer targeted relief. Peppermint tea, for example, contains menthol, which can help clear airways and act as a natural decongestant. Chamomile tea is known for its calming properties, which can help with sleep, a crucial component of recovery. Thyme tea contains flavonoids that may relax throat muscles and reduce inflammation.
  • Broth: Clear broths, such as chicken or vegetable, provide hydration along with essential nutrients. The warmth helps increase mucus flow, easing stuffiness and congestion.

Cold Drinks to Numb and Reduce Inflammation

While warm drinks are great for loosening congestion, cold drinks can provide immediate relief for a painful, inflamed sore throat.

  • Ice Water: Sipping on ice water can provide a numbing effect that dulls throat pain.
  • Popsicles and Ice Chips: These frozen treats are a simple way to stay hydrated and soothe an irritated throat, especially when swallowing is difficult.
  • Smoothies: A cold smoothie made with non-dairy milk and low-acid fruits like bananas or pears can be gentle on the throat while providing a boost of vitamins and calories when appetite is low.

Comparison: Warm vs. Cold Drinks for Cough and Cold

Symptom Best Drink Temperature Reason Popular Examples
Sore Throat Pain Cold Numb and reduce inflammation. Ice water, popsicles, cold smoothies
Cough Warm Soothe the throat and thin mucus. Honey and lemon tea, ginger tea, broth
Congestion Warm Increase mucus flow and provide moisture. Herbal tea, broth, warm water
General Hydration Both Any fluid helps prevent dehydration, which is key for recovery. Water, juice, herbal tea
Irritation Warm Coating properties can soothe an irritated throat lining. Honey and lemon tea
Inflammation Cold Can help decrease swelling and pain. Ice water, frozen treats

Important Considerations and What to Avoid

To maximize the benefits of your chosen drink, consider these additional points. You should also be mindful of certain beverages that can worsen symptoms.

Drinks to Avoid

  • Caffeinated Drinks: Coffee and regular tea can be dehydrating, which is counterproductive when you need to stay hydrated.
  • Alcohol: Like caffeine, alcohol dehydrates the body and can weaken the immune system.
  • Sugary Drinks: Soda and other high-sugar beverages can suppress the immune system and promote inflammation.
  • Dairy Products (for some): For many people, dairy can thicken mucus, making phlegmy coughs more bothersome. It is best to avoid it if you notice this effect.

Additional Drink-Related Tips

  • Adjust to your comfort: Some people prefer warm drinks for a soothing effect, while others find cold drinks more relieving for throat pain. Experiment to see what feels best for you.
  • Children and Honey: Never give honey to children under 1 year of age due to the risk of infant botulism.
  • Don't Overlook Water: While specialty drinks are helpful, plain water remains an excellent choice for hydration.

Conclusion

Ultimately, there is no single "best" drink, and the ideal choice depends on your specific symptoms and personal comfort. For soothing a cough and loosening congestion, warm drinks like honey and lemon tea, herbal teas, and broth are often most effective. If your main concern is throat pain and inflammation, cold liquids, popsicles, or smoothies can provide better relief. The most crucial factor for a speedy recovery is staying well-hydrated, so focus on drinking plenty of fluids, and avoid dehydrating substances like caffeine and alcohol. For further reading on safe natural remedies, refer to the resources from reputable health organizations like the Mayo Clinic, which emphasizes rest and fluids.

Natural Drink Recipes

Honey-Ginger Tea

  • Ingredients: 1-inch piece of ginger, thinly sliced; 1 cup of boiling water; 1-2 teaspoons of honey; 1 slice of lemon.
  • Instructions: Add ginger to hot water, steep for 10 minutes, strain, and stir in honey and lemon.

Soothing Turmeric Milk

  • Ingredients: 1 cup warm milk (dairy or alternative); 1 teaspoon turmeric; a dash of black pepper; 1 teaspoon of honey (optional).
  • Instructions: Combine ingredients and warm on the stove. Black pepper increases curcumin absorption.

Cool Cucumber & Mint Refresher

  • Ingredients: Handful of mint leaves; several cucumber slices; water.
  • Instructions: Mix ingredients in a pitcher and chill. The coolness helps with throat pain.

Apple Cider Vinegar & Honey Mix

  • Ingredients: 1 tablespoon apple cider vinegar; 1 tablespoon honey; 1 cup warm water.
  • Instructions: Mix and sip slowly. Apple cider vinegar has antimicrobial properties and may help with mucus.

Disclaimer: Always consult with a healthcare provider before trying new remedies, especially if you have an underlying health condition or are on medication.

Mayo Clinic recommends drinking plenty of fluids and getting rest for cold relief.

Frequently Asked Questions

Warm water is generally better for a cough as it helps to thin mucus, making it easier to cough up, and soothes an irritated throat.

For a sore throat, both warm and cold drinks can help. Warm liquids like herbal tea with honey are soothing, while very cold drinks or ice chips can provide a numbing effect to dull the pain.

Yes, honey and lemon water is an effective remedy. Honey acts as a cough suppressant and soothes the throat, while lemon provides vitamin C and antibacterial properties.

For some people, milk can thicken existing mucus, making a phlegmy cough feel more congested. It is best to avoid it if you find it worsens your symptoms.

Herbal teas with ingredients like ginger, peppermint, echinacea, or thyme are excellent for colds. They can help soothe a sore throat, ease congestion, and provide anti-inflammatory benefits.

When you are sick, your body uses more fluids to fight infection, and symptoms like fever can cause fluid loss. Staying hydrated helps your body's immune system function properly, thins mucus, and speeds up recovery.

Avoid drinks that can dehydrate you or worsen inflammation, such as alcohol, caffeinated beverages (coffee, sodas), and high-sugar drinks.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.