Skip to content

Which fiber is the strongest?

3 min read

Fifteen times stronger than steel on a weight-for-weight basis, Dyneema® (a brand of UHMWPE) is widely considered to be among the strongest fibers in the world. The reality, however, is that the title of "strongest" depends on the specific metric used and whether you are comparing natural or synthetic materials. For many applications, a fiber's specific strength—its strength-to-weight ratio—is a far more important metric than its absolute tensile strength.

Quick Summary

This article explores the contenders for the strongest fiber, detailing the immense strength of synthetic options like Dyneema® and carbon fiber, as well as surprising natural champions like spider silk. The key differences in tensile strength, specific strength, and practical applications for each fiber are compared to determine which comes out on top for various uses.

Key Points

  • Dyneema® (UHMWPE): Widely considered the strongest fiber based on its extraordinary strength-to-weight ratio, making it up to 15 times stronger than steel.

  • Carbon Fiber: Boasts extremely high absolute tensile strength, with some variants reaching up to 7,000 MPa, though it is more brittle than other fibers.

  • Aramid (Kevlar®): Excels in impact and abrasion resistance, making it essential for ballistic protection, but is susceptible to UV degradation.

  • Spider Silk: The benchmark for natural materials, demonstrating a remarkable combination of high toughness (strength and elasticity) and biodegradability.

  • Strength-to-Weight Ratio: The concept of "strongest" often refers to specific strength, where Dyneema® is a leader, rather than just absolute strength.

  • Natural vs. Synthetic: Synthetic fibers generally surpass natural fibers in overall strength, though natural fibers like abaca and spider silk offer unique advantages.

  • Creep and Environmental Factors: Fibers like UHMWPE can experience creep under constant load and degrade from UV exposure, unlike more durable alternatives.

In This Article

Comparing the strongest synthetic fibers

When examining synthetic fibers, a few contenders consistently rise to the top of the strength-to-weight category. While absolute tensile strength varies, their specific strength is what truly sets them apart from traditional materials like steel.

Ultra-High-Molecular-Weight Polyethylene (UHMWPE)

UHMWPE, known commercially as Dyneema® and Spectra®, is a thermoplastic polymer. Produced through gel-spinning, it achieves exceptional properties due to aligned polyethylene chains. Key characteristics include a high strength-to-weight ratio, making Dyneema® up to 15 times stronger than steel by weight, significant chemical and water resistance, low moisture absorption, and buoyancy. However, UHMWPE is prone to creep under sustained load and has a lower melting point.

Carbon Fiber

Carbon fiber is a lightweight and rigid material with a crystalline structure of carbon atoms. Its tensile strength varies by grade, with some reaching up to 7,000 MPa. It offers high stiffness and excellent fatigue resistance, important for structural uses. A drawback is its brittleness and lower compressive strength compared to its tensile strength.

Aramid Fiber

Aramid fibers, like Kevlar®, are synthetic fibers known for high strength and heat resistance. Para-aramids such as Kevlar® and Twaron® have an excellent strength-to-weight ratio, making them suitable for body armor. Aramid fiber provides good impact and abrasion resistance but degrades when exposed to UV light.

The strongest fibers in nature

Nature also produces remarkably strong fibers, with spider silk being a prime example.

Spider Silk

Spider silk is noted for its impressive toughness and elasticity, surpassing Kevlar® on a weight-for-weight basis. It is also biodegradable and possesses unique properties like reversible super-contraction.

Other Natural Fibers

Although generally not as strong as synthetics, plant fibers can offer significant durability. Sisal and hemp are used for ropes, while Abaca fiber, from the banana plant, is considered one of the strongest plant fibers.

Comparison of fiber properties

Material Type Tensile Strength (MPa) Specific Strength (Pa m³/kg) Key Advantages Key Disadvantages
Dyneema® (UHMWPE) Synthetic up to 2,400 ~8x Steel Extremely high strength-to-weight, floats, low stretch Low melting point, creep, vulnerable to friction heat
Carbon Fiber Synthetic 3,500–7,000 ~50x Steel High stiffness, high strength, fatigue resistance Brittle, low compressive strength, high cost
Aramid (Kevlar®) Synthetic 3,600 High High tensile strength, impact and abrasion resistance UV sensitive, absorbs moisture, low compressive strength
Spider Silk Natural ~1,290 Superior to Kevlar on toughnes Incredible toughness, elasticity, biodegradable Cannot be mass-produced, variability
Abaca (Musa Textilis) Natural High (for a natural fiber) Lower than synthetics Very strong for natural applications, durable Lower absolute strength than high-performance synthetics
Steel Metal 400-500 Low High strength in absolute terms, common material High weight, lower specific strength, can rust

Applications of the strongest fibers

The optimal fiber choice is dictated by the specific application's demands.

High-performance outdoor gear

Dyneema® is favored for ultralight outdoor equipment like backpacks and climbing gear due to its strength-to-weight ratio and water resistance. Its low stretch is also beneficial for non-dynamic climbing slings.

Ballistic and protective equipment

Aramid fibers such as Kevlar® are primary materials for ballistic protection, including bulletproof vests, due to their ability to absorb impact.

Aerospace and automotive composites

Carbon fiber's stiffness and tensile strength make it ideal for composites in aerospace, high-end bicycles, and automotive parts where weight reduction is crucial. Fiber orientation can be tailored for specific stiffness requirements.

Industrial and marine ropes

UHMWPE ropes are a lighter and safer substitute for steel wire ropes in winching and marine uses. Their high strength, low stretch, and buoyancy are advantageous for applications like ship moorings.

Conclusion: Which fiber is the strongest?

The designation of "strongest fiber" is multifaceted. While Dyneema® excels in strength-to-weight, carbon fiber offers higher absolute tensile strength. Aramid fibers provide a balance of strength and impact resistance, and spider silk stands out in toughness (strength and elasticity). The best fiber depends on the specific requirements, highlighting that strength involves various physical properties. Ongoing material development continues to expand possibilities in diverse fields.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, on a weight-for-weight basis, Dyneema® is generally considered to have a higher tensile strength than aramid fibers like Kevlar®. However, Kevlar® offers superior resistance to heat and certain types of abrasion and impact.

Spider silk is often cited as the strongest natural fiber due to its exceptional toughness, which is a combination of high tensile strength and elasticity. Among plant fibers, Abaca fiber, derived from the banana plant, is considered the strongest.

Carbon fiber is extremely strong and lightweight but is also very stiff and brittle, meaning it can fail catastrophically under stress concentrations. It also has a high cost, limiting its use to specialized applications where weight reduction is a primary concern, such as in aerospace and high-end sporting goods.

For ropes, UHMWPE fibers like Dyneema® are considered the strongest due to their high tensile strength and buoyancy, which makes them ideal for marine and heavy-duty industrial applications.

Dyneema® is manufactured using a gel-spinning process. This process involves dissolving UHMWPE polymer in a solvent and then spinning the solution into a fiber. The solvent is then removed, and the fiber is stretched and heated to align the molecular chains, which gives it its high strength.

While researchers can produce small quantities of bio-engineered spider silk proteins, and some companies have developed materials inspired by it, mass production of natural spider silk is not commercially viable due to the territorial and cannibalistic nature of spiders, which prevents farming them.

Specific strength is a material's strength-to-weight ratio. It is calculated by dividing the material's tensile strength by its density. This metric is crucial for applications where weight is a critical factor, such as in aerospace or ultralight equipment.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.