Comparing AG1 and Green Vibrant: An In-Depth Look
When exploring the world of greens powders, two names consistently stand out: AG1 (previously Athletic Greens) and Vibrant Health's Green Vibrant. Both are comprehensive superfood supplements, but a closer look reveals key distinctions that can influence which is the better choice for your lifestyle and health objectives. While AG1 often gets attention for its marketing, Green Vibrant has been a long-standing product in the market, first introduced in 1992.
Ingredient Transparency and Formulation
A major difference is ingredient disclosure. Green Vibrant uses a fully transparent label, detailing the exact amount of each of its over 70 plant-based ingredients. AG1, on the other hand, utilizes proprietary blends, grouping ingredients without listing individual dosages, which can be a concern for those wanting precise information.
- AG1: Contains 75+ ingredients in proprietary blends, including adaptogens. Specific dosages for many ingredients are not disclosed.
- Green Vibrant: Features a transparent label showing exact quantities of 70+ ingredients categorized by function. It contains significantly more probiotics with 25 billion CFUs from 12 strains, compared to AG1's 7.2 billion CFUs from two strains.
Third-Party Testing and Quality Assurance
Third-party testing verifies supplement quality and safety. AG1 is NSF Certified for Sport, testing for banned athletic substances, making it suitable for athletes. Green Vibrant currently lacks third-party certifications, which may be a drawback for some consumers.
Cost and Value Proposition
Cost per serving is a significant factor. AG1 is more expensive, ranging from approximately $2.63 to $3.30 per serving. Green Vibrant is more affordable, costing around $1.45 to $1.65 per serving on subscription, roughly half the price of AG1.
Taste and Palatability
Taste impacts daily use. AG1 is generally found to be more palatable with hints of pineapple and vanilla, masking the typical grassy flavor. Green Vibrant is often described as having a strong, earthy, and grassy taste.
Comparison Table
| Feature | AG1 | Green Vibrant |
|---|---|---|
| Cost per serving | High ($2.63–$3.30) | Lower ($1.45–$1.65) |
| Ingredient Transparency | Proprietary blends hide specific dosages | Fully transparent, shows exact quantities |
| Third-Party Testing | NSF Certified for Sport | None currently reported |
| Probiotics (CFUs) | 7.2 billion (2 strains) | 25 billion (12 strains) |
| Adaptogen Content | High | Lower |
| Taste | More palatable, slightly sweet | Strong, grassy, earthy |
Which is right for you?
The choice depends on your priorities. AG1 is better for competitive athletes needing third-party certification and those preferring a more palatable taste or higher adaptogen content. Green Vibrant is ideal for budget-conscious consumers who prioritize ingredient transparency and a high probiotic count.
Conclusion
Both AG1 and Green Vibrant are quality greens powders. AG1 offers third-party testing and better taste, while Green Vibrant provides value through transparency and more probiotics. Consider your budget and priorities to decide which is best for you. For more on AG1's ingredients, check out reviews on BarBend.
