Which Myprotein Flavour Is Best With Water? A Definitive Guide

December 19, 2025 •

4 min read

According to extensive user reviews, some Myprotein flavours perform exceptionally well with water, dissolving smoothly to create a refreshing drink rather than a watery, bland one. Finding the right flavour is crucial for anyone who prefers the lower calorie count and quicker absorption that water-based shakes provide, making the choice of which Myprotein flavour is best with water a key decision.

Quick Summary

This comprehensive guide explores the top Myprotein flavours best suited for mixing with water, categorizing them by taste profile to help you find an enjoyable and lump-free shake. It covers both creamy Impact Whey and lighter Clear Whey options, providing a detailed comparison to match your hydration and protein goals.

Key Points

Clear Whey is ideal for refreshing shakes: The Clear Whey range, with flavours like Vimto® and Orange Mango, is designed specifically for water and provides a light, juice-like consistency.
Classic Impact Whey flavours work well: For a thinner, milk-style drink, try Impact Whey in Chocolate Smooth or Vanilla, which dissolve smoothly in water.
Use cold water and proper technique: Always add cold water to your shaker first, then add the powder and shake vigorously to avoid lumps.
Dessert-like vs. fruity tastes: Flavours like Chocolate Brownie and Cookies and Cream can be sweeter with water, while fruity options like Cranberry & Raspberry offer a lighter, more hydrating feel.
Mixability depends on the product line: Clear Whey generally produces a clearer, smoother liquid with less foam, whereas Impact Whey may retain a slightly milkier consistency.
Adjust sweetness with flavour drops: If you opt for an unflavoured protein, or just want to fine-tune the taste, sugar-free flavour drops provide total customization.
Consider goals for best results: Water-mixed shakes are best for lower-calorie intake and fast digestion, making them great for weight loss or quick post-workout refuels.

Finding Your Ideal Myprotein Flavour for Water

When it comes to mixing protein powder with water, the texture and taste are everything. A bad flavor or poor mixability can make your daily protein shake a chore rather than a pleasure. Myprotein offers a vast array of flavours, but not all are created equal when combined with water. Your primary goal—whether it's weight loss or post-workout recovery—will often dictate whether you opt for a milky or a juice-like consistency. Lighter, fruit-based flavours are a clear winner for those wanting a refreshing post-workout drink, while classic, sweeter options can still work well if you manage your expectations.

Top Impact Whey Flavours for a Water-Based Shake

Impact Whey is Myprotein's flagship whey protein concentrate, known for its wide range of flavours. While many are designed for milk, several stand out when mixed with water, offering a surprisingly pleasant experience without the added calories or fat of dairy.

Chocolate Smooth: A universally popular choice, this classic mixes exceptionally well with water to create a satisfying, cocoa-like drink. It's not overly sweet or artificial, and blends smoothly without grittiness.
Chocolate Brownie: Slightly richer than Chocolate Smooth, this flavour can still perform well with water, offering a more decadent, dessert-like experience. For best results, use a shaker bottle and let it settle for a minute to achieve a creamy texture.
Vanilla: As a versatile base, Vanilla is a reliable choice for water. It creates a simple, clean vanilla flavour that's not overwhelming. It's also perfect for adding other ingredients like a splash of flavour drops or a handful of berries.
Natural Strawberry: For a simple, fruity option, Natural Strawberry mixes cleanly with water and provides a fresh taste. It avoids the artificial sweetness that can plague some fruit flavours, making it a refreshing alternative.
Chocolate Mint: If you enjoy the classic chocolate-mint combination, this flavour works surprisingly well with water. The mint adds a refreshing lift that can cut through any mild aftertaste, making it easy to drink, especially on warmer days.

Top Clear Whey Flavours for a Water-Based Shake

For those who prefer a truly light, juice-like experience, Myprotein's Clear Whey is the ideal choice. It is specifically formulated to be mixed with water, providing a refreshing and easily digestible alternative to thicker, milky shakes.

Orange Mango: A top-rated Clear Whey flavour, Orange Mango is a tropical favourite that mixes into a clear, vibrant, and incredibly refreshing drink. It's perfect for sipping during or after a workout.
Vimto®: This limited-edition flavour captures the iconic taste of the classic Vimto berry drink. It mixes easily and provides a light, fruity protein boost that’s a welcome change from traditional milky shakes.
Cranberry & Raspberry: Offering a tart and juicy berry combination, this is another fan favourite from the Clear Whey line. Its crisp, fruity flavour tastes similar to a squash drink and is perfect for post-workout hydration.
Peach Tea: If you’re looking for a flavour that tastes like a summer holiday, Peach Tea Clear Whey delivers. It's refreshing and not overly sweet, with a distinct tea note.
Mojito: This flavour provides a sweet lime and hint-of-mint profile, offering a truly unique and refreshing experience. It's especially popular for those who enjoy mocktail-inspired drinks.

Comparison Table: Impact Whey vs. Clear Whey with Water


Feature	Impact Whey Protein with Water	Clear Whey Protein with Water
Texture	Thinner than with milk, but retains a slightly creamy or milky mouthfeel.	Light, thin, and juice-like. No milky residue.
Best For	Lower-calorie version of a traditional protein shake. Good for those used to milk-based shakes.	A hydrating, refreshing drink, especially post-workout or on a hot day.
Dissolving	Mixes well, but some thicker flavours may leave minor residue. Best shaken vigorously.	Dissolves almost perfectly. A few seconds of settling may be required for foam to dissipate.
Top Flavours	Chocolate Smooth, Vanilla, Chocolate Mint, Natural Strawberry.	Orange Mango, Vimto®, Cranberry & Raspberry, Peach Tea.
Taste Profile	Classic dessert-like flavours that can be less intense with water.	Fruity, vibrant, and tangy flavours that mimic squash or juice.

Expert Tips for the Perfect Water-Mixed Protein Shake

To get the best out of your water-based Myprotein shake, follow these simple tips:

Use Cold Water: Always use very cold water. The cooler temperature significantly enhances the taste and makes the shake feel more refreshing. For Clear Whey, some users recommend preparing it ahead of time and refrigerating overnight for the best result.
Add Water First: Pour the water into your shaker bottle before adding the protein powder. This simple step helps prevent the powder from clumping and sticking to the bottom, ensuring a smoother mix.
Shake Vigorously, Then Wait: Shake your bottle enthusiastically for at least 15-30 seconds. For Clear Whey, a little patience is needed as the natural foaming will settle to leave a clear, refreshing drink.
Try Flavour Drops: For unflavoured protein powder or to enhance a lighter flavour, Myprotein's sugar-free Flavour Drops can be an excellent addition. This allows for total control over the intensity of your shake.
Consider a Blender: For thicker, creamier Impact Whey flavours like Chocolate Brownie, a blender can guarantee a super-smooth texture, although a good shaker bottle is usually sufficient.

Conclusion

Choosing which Myprotein flavour is best with water ultimately depends on your personal preference for either a light, juice-like drink or a thinner, milky-style shake. For a refreshing and hydrating option, the Clear Whey range—with flavours like Orange Mango and Vimto®—is specifically designed to be mixed with water and delivers an excellent, fruity taste. If you prefer a more classic, creamy taste profile without the calories of milk, Impact Whey flavours like Chocolate Smooth and Vanilla are your best bet and mix surprisingly well. By using cold water and mixing correctly, you can ensure a delicious and lump-free shake every time, helping you meet your protein goals efficiently and enjoyably.

Frequently Asked Questions

Mixing with water is ideal for lower-calorie intake and faster absorption, such as post-workout. Mixing with milk adds extra calories, protein, and fat, making for a creamier, more filling shake that is better for muscle mass gain or as a meal replacement.

Yes, mixing protein powder with water will result in a less creamy and less intense flavour compared to mixing with milk. Some dessert-based flavours may taste watery or artificial, while fruity flavours often work better.

For Impact Whey, Chocolate Smooth and Vanilla are consistently recommended. For Clear Whey, fruity options like Vimto®, Orange Mango, and Cranberry & Raspberry are specifically designed for a water-based mix.

For a better taste, use very cold water, and shake vigorously. You can also add flavour drops, mix it with ice, or blend in some fruit. Some users also find that preparing Clear Whey and leaving it in the fridge overnight improves the flavour and texture.

Yes, Clear Whey is specifically formulated to be mixed with water to create a light, juice-like drink. Impact Whey is designed for both water and milk, but its creamy flavours often taste best with milk. For a truly refreshing and non-milky drink, Clear Whey is the better choice.

Your shake might be clumpy if you add the powder before the water. The best practice is to always pour the water into your shaker first, then add the powder. This technique helps the powder dissolve more evenly.

No, a standard shaker bottle is sufficient for most water-based protein shakes. For Clear Whey, some users find that letting the foam settle for a minute after shaking provides a better result, and you can remove the mixing ball as it's not needed for the fine powder.