Poppi vs. Olipop: A Taste Test Showdown
Poppi and Olipop offer the fizz of soda, but their flavors differ. Poppi's apple cider vinegar (ACV) base delivers a lighter, fruit-forward taste. Olipop uses plant fibers and botanicals for a richer, more classic soda-like taste.
Flavor Face-Off: Popular Flavors
Here's a comparison of some popular flavors from each brand:
- Cola: Olipop's Vintage Cola often tastes most like traditional cola. Poppi's version has a flatter or cinnamon-forward taste.
- Cream Soda: Poppi's Cream Soda is often preferred for its authentic vanilla flavor. Olipop's may have a botanical aftertaste.
- Fruity Flavors: Poppi shines with its fruit flavors like Strawberry Lemon. Olipop's fruit flavors can taste candy-like.
- Root Beer: Both offer root beer. Olipop's is similar to traditional root beers. Poppi's may have a less classic root beer taste.
The Ingredients Behind the Taste
Poppi's Recipe
Poppi contains sparkling water, organic cane sugar, and apple cider vinegar, with prebiotic fiber from agave inulin and cassava root fiber. ACV provides a tangy finish. Sweetness comes from organic cane sugar and stevia.
Olipop's Blend
Olipop uses its "OLISMART" blend of plant fibers from multiple sources, along with cassava root syrup, fruit juice, allulose syrup, and stevia. These ingredients create a creamy mouthfeel and botanical notes.
Comparison Table: Poppi vs. Olipop
| Feature | Poppi | Olipop |
|---|---|---|
| Core Prebiotic | Apple Cider Vinegar and Inulin | "OLISMART" Blend of Plant Fibers |
| Flavor Profile | Crisp, fruit-forward, tangy | Classic soda-like, richer, sweeter |
| Aftertaste | Subtle ACV or stevia tang | Botanical or stevia-forward |
| Sweeteners | Organic Cane Sugar, Stevia | Cassava Root Syrup, Fruit Juice, Allulose, Stevia |
| Mouthfeel | Lighter, cleaner | Creamier, richer |
| Fiber Content/Can | Approx. 2-3g | Up to 9g |
Which Soda Tastes Better? The Verdict
Which soda tastes better depends on personal preference. If you like lighter, fruitier tastes with a tang, Poppi is a good choice. For a more traditional soda experience, Olipop may be preferable. Olipop is the better choice for maximizing prebiotic intake.
Taste-test both to find your favorite. You may enjoy flavors from both brands. Whether you're switching from regular soda or trying prebiotic drinks for the first time, exploring both can help you find your favorite fizzy drink.
For more information on prebiotic sodas, see this Bon Appétit guide to prebiotic and probiotic sodas.
Conclusion
Poppi and Olipop are top prebiotic sodas, appealing to different tastes. Choosing between them comes down to your personal taste. Some prefer Poppi's tang, while others prefer Olipop's sweetness. The best choice satisfies your craving for a healthy, flavorful soda.
