Skip to content

Which whey protein is better, Body Fortress or Six Star?

4 min read

With thousands of reviews online, the popularity of budget-friendly proteins like Body Fortress and Six Star is undeniable. This guide will help you decide which whey protein is better, Body Fortress or Six Star, by comparing their nutritional content, ingredients, and overall value.

Quick Summary

This detailed comparison examines Body Fortress and Six Star whey protein, breaking down nutritional profiles, price points, and third-party certifications. An analysis of consumer feedback and formulation differences reveals which brand offers the best value for budget-conscious fitness enthusiasts.

Key Points

  • Body Fortress is NSF Certified: This certification is a key advantage for competitive athletes, ensuring the product is tested for banned substances.

  • Six Star Often Includes Creatine: Its 'Plus' formula typically contains creatine and glutamine, offering a convenient all-in-one pre- and post-workout formula.

  • Both are Budget-Friendly: Both brands are widely recognized for their affordable price points and are competitive in the budget supplement market.

  • Taste and Mixability Vary: Six Star generally receives better marks for taste and mixability, while Body Fortress has more mixed reviews, particularly concerning its updated formula.

  • Formulation is the Main Difference: The core decision lies in whether you prefer Body Fortress's immune-support blend and third-party testing or Six Star's inclusion of creatine and higher BCAAs.

In This Article

Body Fortress Whey Protein: A Closer Look

For nearly two decades, Body Fortress has established itself as a go-to option for affordable protein, earning a reputation for delivering large scoops at a low cost. The current formula, known as Super Advanced Whey Protein, has undergone changes over the years but continues to feature a blend of whey protein concentrate and isolate.

Key Features and Formulation

  • High Protein Count: A standard one-scoop serving delivers 30g of protein, while a two-scoop serving provides a substantial 60g.
  • Immune Support Blend: Post-2021, the formula was updated to include an Immune Support Blend, featuring vitamins C and D, and zinc.
  • Third-Party Certified: Body Fortress is NSF Certified for Sport, a key advantage for competitive athletes who need reassurance against banned substances.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Excellent value for a budget-friendly option.
  • Contains 30g of protein per scoop.
  • Includes an immune-support vitamin blend.
  • NSF Certified for Sport, offering peace of mind for athletes.

Cons:

  • Mixed consumer reviews on taste and mixability, especially after formula changes.
  • Some versions may contain a higher cholesterol and sodium content.
  • Reliance on whey concentrate, which is less pure than isolate.

Six Star Whey Protein: What You Need to Know

Six Star is another popular, budget-focused protein brand, often lauded for its robust formula and affordability. The brand's products, particularly the 100% Whey Protein Plus, are designed to appeal to those seeking performance enhancements beyond just protein.

Key Features and Formulation

  • Enhanced Formula: The 'Plus' formula includes a generous dose of creatine and added amino acids like glutamine. A two-scoop serving provides 13.4g of BCAAs.
  • Quality Protein Source: Uses ultra-pure 100% whey protein, which is microfiltered for quality and absorption.
  • Taste and Mixability: Generally receives positive customer feedback for flavor and mixability, even with just water.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Often includes performance-enhancing ingredients like creatine and glutamine.
  • Higher BCAA content per two-scoop serving than Body Fortress.
  • Widely praised for good taste and easy mixing.
  • Excellent value proposition for the ingredients offered.

Cons:

  • Some versions may contain higher sugar or carb counts, depending on the formula.
  • Added ingredients like creatine may not be desirable for every user.
  • Some older customer feedback cited nitrogen additives to artificially boost protein claims, though these issues seem less prevalent now.

Body Fortress vs. Six Star: Head-to-Head Comparison

To make an informed decision, a direct comparison of the most popular offerings from both brands is essential. This table highlights key differences in their formulation and features.

Feature Body Fortress Super Advanced Whey Six Star 100% Whey Protein Plus
Protein per Scoop 30g 30g
BCAAs per Scoop ~6g ~6.7g (calculated from 13.4g/2 scoops)
Add-ins Vitamins C, D, and Zinc Creatine and Glutamine
Third-Party Testing NSF Certified for Sport None explicitly mentioned as widespread
Taste/Mixability Mixed reviews Generally praised
Best For Budget shoppers, NSF certification seekers Budget shoppers, those wanting creatine

Key Differences and Considerations

The choice often comes down to your specific fitness needs and preferences.

Creatine vs. Vitamins

This is perhaps the most significant distinction between the two. Six Star often formulates its Whey Protein Plus with creatine, a proven performance enhancer for strength and muscle growth. Body Fortress, meanwhile, has moved towards an immune-support blend with vitamins, forgoing creatine in its current formula. If creatine is a priority, Six Star offers convenience. If you prefer a simpler protein profile, Body Fortress may be better.

Third-Party Testing

For competitive athletes or those with strict supplement purity standards, Body Fortress's NSF Certified for Sport status is a major selling point. This certification ensures the product has been tested for banned substances and label accuracy. While Six Star products are also generally considered reliable, they lack this specific, high-level certification.

Taste and Mixability

Based on widespread customer reviews, Six Star often gets the edge in flavor and mixing ease. However, taste is highly subjective. Body Fortress has received mixed feedback, particularly after its formula update, though some users still enjoy it. If a delicious, easily-mixed shake is a top priority, Six Star may be the safer bet.

Price Point

Both are considered budget-friendly options, but their pricing can fluctuate. For the average user, the price per serving for both products is often very competitive, especially when purchased in larger tubs. It's recommended to compare the current cost-per-serving at retailers like Walmart or Amazon before purchasing.

Making Your Choice: Which One is Right for You?

  • Choose Six Star if: You are looking for an all-in-one budget solution that includes creatine for performance. The generally positive reviews for taste and mixability also make it a reliable choice for daily consumption.
  • Choose Body Fortress if: You are a competitive athlete who requires NSF Certified for Sport supplements. It's also an excellent option for those who simply want a high-protein, budget-friendly product without added performance ingredients like creatine.

Ultimately, both products offer solid nutritional value for their price point, so it depends on your specific needs and priorities. For comprehensive information on product changes and testing, reputable sources like Garage Gym Reviews provide detailed analyses.(https://www.garagegymreviews.com/body-fortress-whey-protein-review)

Conclusion

When comparing Body Fortress and Six Star, there is no single 'better' option, but rather a better fit for individual needs. Body Fortress excels with its NSF certification, providing competitive athletes with a high degree of confidence. Six Star offers a potentially more complete performance formula for casual lifters by including creatine. For most budget-conscious consumers, both provide a significant protein boost at a competitive price. Your decision should be guided by whether you prioritize third-party certification and immune-support vitamins or prefer an all-in-one formula with creatine included.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, Body Fortress is generally considered a good quality supplement, especially given its low price point. It is NSF Certified for Sport and provides a substantial 30g of protein per scoop, though some customer reviews cite concerns over taste and mixability.

Yes, Six Star's popular 100% Whey Protein Plus formula is often enhanced with 2.5g of creatine per serving, alongside additional amino acids like glutamine.

Based on widespread consumer reviews, Six Star is more consistently praised for its taste and easy mixability, even in plain water. However, taste is subjective, and customer opinions on Body Fortress are more mixed.

Yes, Body Fortress can be effective for muscle building when combined with a proper diet and strength training. Its 30g of protein and 6g of BCAAs per scoop support muscle growth and recovery.

Body Fortress is NSF Certified for Sport, a reputable third-party certification ensuring products are free of banned substances and accurately labeled. While Six Star is a reliable brand, a similar third-party certification is not widely noted.

For pure weight gain, your overall calorie intake is most important. While both offer a similar high protein content, Six Star's inclusion of creatine could indirectly support weight gain through increased strength and muscle mass. Neither is a true 'mass gainer' unless multiple scoops are used.

At a standard one-scoop serving, Six Star offers slightly more BCAAs than Body Fortress. For those using the brand's recommended two-scoop serving, Six Star's 13.4g of BCAAs significantly surpasses Body Fortress's 6g per scoop.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.