Is brown resveratrol bad? Factors influencing color
There are several key reasons your resveratrol may appear brown, and not all of them indicate a bad or expired product. Understanding the source and the potential for degradation is crucial for interpreting the color change.
Natural vs. Synthetic Resveratrol
One of the most common reasons for a brownish tint is the supplement's origin. Resveratrol is available in two primary forms: a natural extract and a high-purity, synthetic powder.
- Natural Extracts: Many resveratrol supplements are derived from plant sources, most notably Japanese knotweed (Polygonum cuspidatum). This root extract naturally contains various other compounds and pigments, which give the powder its characteristic brownish color. This is a normal and expected color for such a product and does not indicate a loss of efficacy. In fact, some prefer these whole-plant extracts for the potential synergistic effects of other phytochemicals.
- High-Purity Synthetic Resveratrol: In contrast, high-purity (e.g., 98% or higher) synthetic resveratrol powder is typically white or off-white. If a product that was originally white or off-white turns brown, it is a definitive sign of degradation, as the high level of purity means there are no other plant materials to cause discoloration.
Oxidation and Isomerization
Resveratrol is an antioxidant, and its very nature makes it susceptible to degradation. As an antioxidant, it donates electrons to neutralize free radicals, and this process can cause it to oxidize. The oxidized molecules then undergo further chemical reactions that lead to a visible color change.
- Exposure to Oxygen: Resveratrol is a polyphenol, and like many compounds in this class, it is sensitive to air. A bottle that is not sealed tightly, or a powder exposed to open air, will oxidize over time and turn brown.
- Heat and Light: Resveratrol is notoriously unstable when exposed to heat and ultraviolet (UV) light. UV irradiation, in particular, causes the degradation of the beneficial trans-resveratrol isomer into the less active cis-resveratrol. This photoisomerization is a chemical change that can also cause discoloration.
- Oxidizing Metals: Even trace amounts of oxidizing metals like iron or copper can act as catalysts to accelerate the discoloration and degradation process.
How to tell if your resveratrol has degraded
It can be difficult to know for certain if your resveratrol has lost potency without laboratory testing. However, some key indicators can help you assess your product's condition.
- Check the original color: If you remember the powder or capsule content being a light off-white color and it has since darkened to a deep reddish-brown, it is highly likely that oxidation has occurred.
- Examine the storage conditions: If you've been storing your supplement in a bathroom cabinet, on a kitchen countertop, or near a window where it's exposed to heat, humidity, or sunlight, degradation is very probable.
- Consider the source: If your supplement is a whole-root extract and has always been brownish, the color is likely normal. It is the color change of a high-purity product that is cause for concern.
Comparison of resveratrol supplement types
To clarify the difference between product types, the following table summarizes the typical characteristics of natural extracts versus high-purity synthetic versions.
| Feature | High-Purity Synthetic Resveratrol | Natural Japanese Knotweed Extract |
|---|---|---|
| Starting Color | White or off-white powder | Light to darker brown powder |
| Source | Laboratory synthesis | Extracted from Polygonum cuspidatum roots |
| Purity | Often 98% or higher trans-resveratrol | Lower percentage, typically 50% |
| Degradation Indicator | Turns visibly brown from initial light color | Color is consistently brownish; change is harder to detect |
| Stability | Very sensitive to light, heat, and oxygen | Contains other plant compounds which may offer some stability, but still susceptible to degradation |
Proper storage to prevent degradation
To ensure your resveratrol remains as potent as possible, follow these best practices for storage:
- Store in a cool, dark place: Keep your supplements away from heat sources and out of direct sunlight. A cabinet or pantry is a much better location than a kitchen counter or bathroom shelf.
- Keep it dry: Humidity can also affect supplement stability. A cool, dry environment is ideal.
- Seal tightly: Always ensure the lid is screwed on tightly after each use to minimize exposure to oxygen.
- Consider refrigeration: Some manufacturers recommend refrigeration after opening, especially for liquid formulations, to maximize shelf life. If your container specifies this, be sure to follow the instructions. However, unless indicated, the fridge's humidity can also be detrimental.
- Note the expiration date: Always check the expiration date and use the product within the recommended timeframe. Although a color change may not always signify total degradation, it can be a warning sign as the product nears its shelf life.
Conclusion
Seeing a brown color in your resveratrol supplement is not an automatic cause for concern, but it does warrant investigation. If your product is a natural extract, a brownish color is likely normal. However, if you purchased a high-purity, white or off-white supplement and it has since turned brown, it has likely degraded due to oxidation or isomerization, resulting in a loss of potency. By understanding the causes of discoloration and implementing proper storage techniques, you can ensure your antioxidant supplement remains fresh and effective. Always review the product label and manufacturer recommendations to understand your specific supplement's characteristics.
For more detailed scientific information on resveratrol's properties and stability, consult authoritative sources like the National Institutes of Health (NIH) library. PMC. Resveratrol—A Promising Therapeutic Agent with Problematic Properties