The Core Difference: How Water is Purified
At the heart of the matter lies the purification process. The method used to treat water fundamentally determines its final composition, taste, and use. Distilled water is the product of a specific, high-purity process, while bottled water can come from various sources and be treated in multiple ways.
The Distillation Process
Distillation is a purification process that mimics the natural hydrological cycle on a controlled scale.
- Boiling: Water is heated until it turns into steam, leaving behind virtually all non-volatile contaminants, such as minerals, salts, and heavy metals.
- Condensation: The clean steam is then collected and cooled, causing it to condense back into pure liquid water.
- Collection: This newly formed liquid is then collected in a separate, sterile container.
Because nearly all impurities and dissolved solids are left behind, the result is water that is close to 100% pure H₂O, with a Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) reading of 0 parts per million (PPM). This makes it ideal for industrial, laboratory, and medical applications where mineral-free water is essential.
Common Bottled Water Purification Methods
Bottled water, on the other hand, is processed using a range of methods depending on the source and desired outcome. Common techniques include:
- Reverse Osmosis (RO): A process where water is forced through a semi-permeable membrane at high pressure. This removes most dissolved solids and contaminants, but not all of them.
- Filtration: Water is passed through a series of filters, such as activated carbon, to remove impurities, improve taste, and absorb chlorine.
- Ozonation and UV Light Treatment: These are disinfecting steps used to kill microorganisms like bacteria and viruses without leaving behind chemical residues.
After these processes, minerals are often added back into the water by manufacturers. This serves two key purposes: to improve the flavor, which would otherwise be flat, and to market the water based on its added mineral content.
What's Really in Your Bottle? Types of Bottled Water
The label on a bottled water product is crucial for understanding its contents. The term “bottled water” is an umbrella that covers several distinct products.
- Spring Water: Sourced from an underground formation from which water flows naturally to the surface. It retains the minerals it absorbs from the rocks, giving it a unique taste.
- Mineral Water: Must contain at least 250 PPM of dissolved solids at the source and cannot have minerals added later. This is prized for its specific mineral composition and taste.
- Purified Water: Comes from either a tap water source or a protected well and has been demineralized through processes like reverse osmosis, distillation, or deionization. As noted, minerals are often reintroduced before bottling.
- Drinking Water: Often sourced from municipal tap water that has undergone some form of filtration and treatment before being bottled.
- Distilled Water: If a bottled water is truly distilled, the label will clearly state it. However, it is a niche product primarily used for specific applications, not for regular drinking.
Key Differences: A Comparison Table
| Feature | Distilled Water | Typical Bottled Water (Spring/Purified) |
|---|---|---|
| Purification Method | Boiling, evaporation, and condensation | Filtration, reverse osmosis, UV light, ozonation |
| Mineral Content | Virtually none (TDS near 0 PPM) | Present; levels vary depending on source and treatment |
| Taste | Flat or neutral due to lack of minerals | Crisp, fresh, or varied, due to mineral profile |
| Primary Use | Appliances (irons, humidifiers), laboratory use | Everyday drinking, cooking |
| Health Considerations | Safe to drink but lacks essential minerals | Provides hydration and trace minerals |
Taste, Health, and Practical Uses
The contrasting purification methods of distilled and bottled water lead to significant differences in taste and application. Distilled water's flat, neutral flavor is a direct result of having no dissolved minerals, which some people may find unappealing. Conversely, the presence of minerals like calcium, magnesium, and potassium in spring water creates the refreshing taste many consumers prefer.
From a health perspective, it's worth noting that while distilled water is perfectly safe to drink, it won't provide the nutritional benefits of trace minerals found in spring or mineral water. The World Health Organization has published research on the importance of minerals in drinking water, especially for those with marginal intakes from food. For most healthy individuals with a balanced diet, the mineral content in water is not a primary source of nutrients, but for some, like athletes or those with dietary deficiencies, mineralized water might be more beneficial.
Perhaps the most telling difference lies in their practical uses. Distilled water is highly aggressive and seeks to absorb minerals from its surroundings, making it the wrong choice for certain applications but the ideal choice for others. Its lack of mineral content prevents scale buildup, which is why it is recommended for use in household appliances such as steam irons, humidifiers, and CPAP machines. Using mineral-rich tap or bottled water in these devices would lead to mineral deposits over time, causing damage. In contrast, bottled drinking water is explicitly meant for consumption and is designed to provide a pleasant, familiar taste.
Conclusion
While some purified bottled water products may involve distillation as part of their treatment process, they are not the same as pure distilled water sold for specific applications. The key distinction lies in the final mineral content, which directly impacts taste and practical use. Distilled water is stripped of nearly everything, resulting in a flat taste and suitability for appliances and medical use. Bottled water, whether from a spring or treated via reverse osmosis, contains or has minerals added back for drinking enjoyment and some nutritional benefit. When deciding between the two, consumers should consider their specific needs: a pleasant, mineral-rich beverage for hydration or a mineral-free solution for sensitive equipment.
World Health Organization Report on Nutrients in Drinking Water