Understanding Bottled Water Regulations
In the United States, bottled water is regulated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), while tap water falls under the jurisdiction of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). This regulatory difference is a key point in the bottled water vs. tap water debate. The FDA considers bottled water a food product and has its own set of standards for purity, source, and good manufacturing practices. However, a growing body of evidence suggests that despite regulation, potential issues still exist. For example, some studies have detected contaminants in bottled water that are not disclosed to consumers, unlike the annual water quality reports provided by municipalities for tap water. For those concerned about safety, examining the source and treatment methods of bottled water is crucial.
Types of Bottled Water: A Breakdown
The bottled water aisle offers a variety of choices, each with a different profile. Understanding these types is the first step toward determining the safest bottled water to consume.
-
Purified Water: This water, which can originate from a municipal source, has been treated to remove most dissolved solids and impurities. Common purification methods include reverse osmosis, distillation, and deionization. Purified water typically has a low Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) content and a neutral taste. For parents preparing baby formula, purified or distilled water is often the recommended option due to its lack of contaminants and mineral content variations. Brands like Aquafina and Dasani use reverse osmosis, though Dasani adds minerals back for taste.
-
Spring Water: Sourced from an underground formation from which water flows naturally to the surface, spring water retains naturally occurring minerals that give it a distinct flavor. Since it is minimally processed, it can be an excellent, natural choice, provided the source is protected from pollutants. However, the mineral content can vary depending on the geological region, and it's essential to research the brand to ensure a high-quality source.
-
Mineral Water: Similar to spring water, mineral water is sourced from a mineral spring but must contain a specific amount of naturally occurring minerals. These minerals, such as magnesium and calcium, can contribute to its flavor and are often marketed as beneficial. The mineral content is not absorbed as efficiently by the human body from water as it is from food, and excess inorganic minerals can potentially lead to issues over time.
The Problem with Plastic Packaging
One of the most significant concerns surrounding bottled water is the packaging itself. Most bottled water is sold in single-use plastic made from polyethylene terephthalate (PET). This plastic can leach chemicals, including antimony, bisphenols, and phthalates, into the water, particularly when exposed to heat or over a long storage period.
How Microplastics Affect Bottled Water
Recent studies have brought attention to the widespread presence of microplastics and even smaller nanoplastics in bottled water. These tiny plastic particles, shed from the bottles and caps, have been detected in significant quantities and their long-term health effects are still being studied. For individuals seeking the highest level of purity, this finding is a major deterrent for choosing plastic-bottled products.
The Dangers of Chemical Leaching
Beyond microplastics, chemical compounds from the plastic itself can leach into the water. Chemicals like PFAS, also known as "forever chemicals," have been detected in some bottled waters. The risk of chemical leaching increases with heat exposure, making it inadvisable to leave plastic water bottles in a hot car.
Safest Packaging Alternatives
To avoid the risks associated with plastic leaching, opting for safer packaging is the most effective solution. Glass and aluminum containers are excellent alternatives because they do not leach chemicals into the water.
-
Glass Bottles: Many premium spring and mineral water brands, such as Mountain Valley Spring Water, are available in glass bottles, which are inert and prevent any chemical transfer. Glass is also endlessly recyclable and preserves the water's natural flavor profile. The downside is that it is heavier and more expensive.
-
Aluminum Cans: Brands like Liquid Death have capitalized on this trend, offering mountain spring water in aluminum cans. Aluminum is easily recyclable and creates an airtight seal that protects the water's purity. It is an excellent choice for avoiding plastic entirely.
Comparison of Bottled Water Options
| Feature | Purified (Plastic Bottle) | Spring (Plastic Bottle) | Spring/Mineral (Glass Bottle) | At-Home Filtered (Tap Water) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Purity | Very high, low TDS | Variable, can contain trace minerals | Generally high, preserves source purity | High, dependent on filter technology |
| Contaminants | Low chemical risk initially; microplastic concern from bottle | Low risk from source; microplastic concern from bottle | Lowest risk from packaging; contains trace minerals | Low risk; effectively removes many contaminants |
| Packaging Leaching | High potential for microplastics, PFAS, and chemical transfer | High potential for microplastics, PFAS, and chemical transfer | Virtually zero | N/A (requires a reusable bottle) |
| Taste Profile | Neutral, clean taste; sometimes re-mineralized for flavor | Unique flavor based on mineral content | Unique flavor based on mineral content | Clean taste, can be customized with mineral filters |
| Environmental Impact | High, from plastic production, transportation, and waste | High, from plastic production and transport | Better, especially if recycled; transport cost still a factor | Lowest, reduces single-use waste and transport emissions |
| Cost | Low to moderate | Low to moderate | High | Lowest long-term cost for daily use |
What to Look for When Buying Bottled Water
When purchasing bottled water, follow these guidelines to make the safest choice:
- Check the source: Read the label to understand where the water comes from. Is it a protected spring, a municipal source, or a well? A natural, protected source is preferable.
- Evaluate the packaging: Opt for glass or aluminum to minimize the risk of plastic leaching and microplastic contamination. Avoid bottles that have been exposed to heat or sun.
- Check the date: Look for the "best-before" date and ensure the bottle is not stored long-term, as water can still become contaminated over time.
- Consider TDS: While high mineral content is not inherently unsafe, a lower TDS can indicate fewer dissolved inorganic compounds.
- Verify Certifications: Look for third-party certifications that ensure quality and safety. Industry standards and permits are mentioned by regulating bodies.
Safer Alternatives to Bottled Water
For regular, long-term consumption, a high-quality home water filtration system is arguably the safest and most eco-friendly option. Reverse osmosis systems, pitcher filters, and faucet-mounted filters can effectively remove a wide range of contaminants, including lead, arsenic, and PFAS, from tap water. Furthermore, using a reusable water bottle made of glass or stainless steel eliminates the risk of plastic leaching and reduces your environmental footprint. For those who travel or are often on the go, portable filtered water bottles from brands like Grayl or Clearly Filtered can provide excellent purification.
The Safest Bottled Water for Infants
When mixing baby formula, using distilled or purified water is often the safest route. Spring water's natural mineral content can be too high or vary too much, which can be problematic for an infant's developing system. While both distilled and purified water are excellent options for formula, they are not typically recommended for long-term daily consumption due to the lack of minerals. Always consult your pediatrician for specific recommendations regarding your infant's hydration needs.
Conclusion: Making the Safest Choice
While all bottled water sold commercially is required to meet certain safety standards, not all options are created equal. The safest bottled water to consume is one that comes from a pure, protected source and is contained in non-plastic packaging like glass or aluminum. For a consistently pure and affordable option, however, a home water filtration system used with a reusable bottle is the safest, most reliable, and most environmentally conscious choice. By understanding the differences in water types, purification methods, and packaging materials, consumers can make an informed decision that prioritizes both their health and the planet's well-being. For more information on environmental contamination and water safety, visit the Environmental Working Group (EWG) at www.ewg.org.
Summary of Safety Practices
Choose Non-Plastic Packaging: Select glass or aluminum bottles to avoid the leaching of microplastics, PFAS, and other chemicals from plastic.
Consider Home Filtration: For consistent purity and the lowest long-term cost, a reverse osmosis or multi-stage tap filter is the optimal solution for daily drinking water.
Understand Water Types: Purified water is highly processed for maximum cleanliness, while spring and mineral waters retain natural minerals from their source.
Mind Storage Conditions: Always store bottled water in a cool, dark place and avoid leaving it in direct sunlight or a hot car to prevent chemical leaching.
Filter for Infants: When preparing formula for infants, use distilled or purified water to ensure a consistent and safe mineral profile.
FAQs
Question: Is purified water or spring water safer? Answer: Purified water typically undergoes stricter processing to remove a wider range of contaminants, including potential impurities present in natural springs. However, spring water's safety depends heavily on the purity of its source and the packaging used.
Question: Are microplastics in bottled water dangerous? Answer: While the long-term health effects of microplastics are still under investigation, their presence in bottled water is a significant concern for many. Opting for non-plastic packaging eliminates this risk.
Question: Is it okay to reuse single-use plastic water bottles? Answer: No, it is not recommended to reuse single-use plastic water bottles, especially for extended periods. Repeated use can cause the plastic to break down further and increase the leaching of harmful chemicals into your water.
Question: How can I tell if bottled water is safe? Answer: Check the packaging for the source, filtration methods, and best-by date. Look for glass or aluminum packaging and confirm the bottle has been stored properly. Choosing a reputable brand known for its quality and safety standards is also wise.
Question: What about bottled water for babies? Answer: For preparing baby formula, distilled or purified water is the safest option because its mineral content is controlled and consistent, preventing issues for a developing infant.
Question: Is Fiji water really one of the safest options? Answer: Fiji is often highly rated for its taste and filtration process, which removes contaminants. However, it is important to remember it is packaged in plastic, which carries the risk of microplastic shedding over time, especially with transport.
Question: Does a home water filter make tap water safer than bottled water? Answer: Yes, in many cases, a high-quality home filtration system (like reverse osmosis) can make tap water safer and more consistent than many bottled options by removing specific contaminants, and it avoids the risks associated with plastic packaging.
