The History and Controversy of MSG
MSG, or monosodium glutamate, has a controversial history often linked to Chinese restaurants. The term "Chinese Restaurant Syndrome" originated from a 1968 letter in the New England Journal of Medicine, where a doctor speculated MSG and other ingredients might have caused his symptoms after eating Chinese food. The media popularized the term, leading to unfounded public fear.
Extensive scientific research, however, including controlled studies, has since found no consistent evidence that MSG causes widespread adverse health reactions. Regulatory bodies like the U.S. FDA classify MSG as "generally recognized as safe" (GRAS) for most people. Experts suggest the negative stigma was influenced by anti-Asian xenophobia and a general distrust of food additives. Reported symptoms are often considered anecdotal or linked to other factors like high sodium or the nocebo effect.
Umami: The Science Behind the Flavor
MSG is closely related to umami, the savory fifth taste. Umami comes from glutamate, an amino acid found naturally in foods like aged cheese and tomatoes. MSG is the purest, most concentrated form of this flavor, an odorless white powder used to boost savory tastes in dishes without adding significant fat or calories.
How and Why MSG is Used in Restaurants
While many Chinese restaurants use MSG, it's also common in other cuisines and numerous packaged foods. Its use in Chinese cuisine increased in the mid-20th century to enhance umami flavors for American consumers. Critics point out that the stigma unfairly targeted Chinese food, while other cuisines rich in natural glutamate (like Italian food with parmesan) are not similarly viewed.
Common Uses of MSG in Chinese Restaurants
- Clear Sauces and Soups: Enhances milder broths and sauces.
- Stir-Fries: Boosts umami in vegetables and proteins.
- Marinades and Seasonings: Adds savory notes to meats.
- Buffet Dishes: Helps maintain flavor over time.
Comparison of MSG vs. Naturally Occurring Glutamates
| Feature | Added MSG | Naturally Occurring Glutamates |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Produced via fermentation of starches. | Found in various foods like mushrooms and tomatoes. |
| Chemical Composition | Monosodium salt of glutamic acid. | Free glutamic acid from protein breakdown. |
| Body's Metabolism | Processed identically to natural glutamate. | Digested and metabolized identically to added MSG. |
| Flavor Profile | Pure, concentrated umami. | Part of a broader flavor profile. |
| Consumer Perception | Historically negative. | Generally positive. |
Modern Practices and The 'No MSG' Trend
Some restaurants now state they don't use added MSG due to consumer concerns. However, they may still use ingredients high in natural glutamate, like soy sauce or yeast extracts, which provide a similar umami flavor. The body processes glutamate from all sources the same way. Diners can ask for dishes without added MSG, but should be aware that natural sources may still be present.
The decision to consume MSG is personal. Scientific evidence supports its safety for most people in typical amounts. The history of MSG is more about cultural bias and misinformation than proven health risks.
Conclusion
Many, though not all, Chinese restaurants use MSG, a practice common across the food industry. The negative stigma unfairly targeting Chinese cuisine is linked to historical xenophobia and unfounded fears. MSG is essentially a concentrated form of natural umami, processed by the body like glutamate from other foods. Diners can inquire about its use, understanding the facts rather than myths.
For more information on MSG and its safety, consult resources from organizations like the FDA.