The term “chews” encompasses a wide range of products, from chewable vitamins for humans to dental chews for dogs and rubber aids for orthodontics. The effectiveness of any chewable product is highly dependent on its specific application, formulation, and quality. While many offer convenience and improved adherence, especially for those who struggle with swallowing pills, they can come with notable drawbacks, including added sugars and potentially lower nutrient density. This article will explore the evidence for common types of chewable products to determine where they truly work and where they fall short.
Chewable Nutritional Supplements: Gummies and Tablets
Chewable vitamins are popular with both children and adults, largely due to their pleasant taste and ease of consumption. They are particularly beneficial for individuals with dysphagia or difficulty swallowing pills. However, their effectiveness in delivering nutrients compared to traditional tablets or capsules is a subject of debate.
Bioavailability vs. Nutrient Concentration
Some research suggests that chewable and gummy vitamins might offer superior bioavailability for certain nutrients. A 2019 study, for instance, found that vitamin D3 gummies had greater bioavailability than tablets, leading to higher blood concentrations. This improved absorption might be due to the dissolution process beginning in the mouth, assisted by saliva.
However, this potential advantage is often offset by other factors. To achieve a pleasant, candy-like taste and texture, manufacturers must add ingredients like sugar, syrups, and gelling agents. To make room for these fillers, the concentration of active vitamins and minerals is often lower than in conventional pills. For example, one comparison found that a chewable tablet had significantly more vitamin C and a broader range of vitamins than a gummy counterpart. Furthermore, certain crucial nutrients, like iron, are often excluded from gummies because their metallic taste is difficult to mask.
Stability and Overdosing
Chewable vitamins, especially gummies, are also more susceptible to moisture and degradation over time, leading to a shorter shelf life and a loss of potency. Some manufacturers compensate by adding more nutrients than listed on the label at the time of production, which can result in inconsistent dosages and the risk of overconsumption, particularly for fat-soluble vitamins like A, D, E, and K. The appeal of gummies can also encourage taking more than the recommended dose, which is especially dangerous for children who might mistake them for candy.
Pet Dental Chews
Many pet owners use dental chews to help maintain their dog's oral hygiene. These products work through a combination of mechanical abrasion and specific additives designed to combat plaque and tartar buildup.
How They Work
- Mechanical Action: The act of chewing scrapes plaque and tartar from the tooth surface, which is a primary mechanism for cleaning.
- Saliva Stimulation: The chewing process increases saliva production. Saliva contains antibacterial properties that help control plaque.
- Active Ingredients: Some chews contain enzymes or other ingredients aimed at breaking down bacteria in the mouth.
Efficacy and VOHC Approval
While dental chews can be a helpful supplement to regular brushing, they are not a replacement for comprehensive oral care. To assess their effectiveness, pet owners can look for the Veterinary Oral Health Council (VOHC) seal of approval. The VOHC is an independent body that certifies products that meet its rigorous standards for reducing plaque or tartar buildup. Chews without this seal lack evidence backing their dental health claims.
Orthodontic Chewies
For those undergoing clear aligner therapy, orthodontic chewies are small, soft rubber cylinders used to ensure aligners fit snugly against the teeth.
How They Help
Chewing on these tools helps to close any small gaps between the aligner and the teeth, which ensures consistent pressure and more predictable tooth movement. However, advances in clear aligner technology, such as more flexible materials, have made chewies less critical for some modern treatments. For older, stiffer aligner materials, chewies were essential, but with newer designs, their necessity may vary. It is important to follow the orthodontist's specific instructions regarding their use.
Comparison: Pills vs. Chewables
| Feature | Conventional Pills/Capsules | Chewable Supplements (Gummies/Tablets) |
|---|---|---|
| Nutrient Concentration | Generally higher; less room for inactive fillers. | Often lower to accommodate flavorings and sweeteners. |
| Bioavailability | Depends on formulation; some low-quality versions may not break down properly. | Can have better initial absorption for certain nutrients (e.g., Vitamin D3) due to oral dissolution. |
| Convenience | Can be difficult for people with dysphagia or children to swallow. | Easy to take and popular due to pleasant taste, increasing adherence. |
| Added Ingredients | Fewer added sugars, flavors, and dyes. | Contains added sugars, corn syrup, artificial colors, and sweeteners, which can impact overall health. |
| Shelf Stability | More stable and less prone to degradation from moisture over time. | More susceptible to moisture, leading to quicker loss of potency. |
| Taste | Can have a neutral or unpleasant taste/smell. | Generally sweet and fruity to mask the taste of active ingredients. |
Conclusion: The Final Verdict on Chews
The question “Does chews really work?” has no single answer because effectiveness varies dramatically by product type. For nutritional supplements, chewables are a convenient option, particularly for people with swallowing issues, and may offer improved bioavailability for some nutrients like vitamin D. However, this is often balanced by lower nutrient concentrations, added sugars, and faster potency loss compared to traditional pills. The decision should involve weighing convenience against nutritional density and potential health implications from added sugars.
For pets, dental chews can be an effective part of a dental hygiene routine, but they do not replace regular brushing or professional cleanings. Looking for the Veterinary Oral Health Council seal is the best way to ensure a product's efficacy. Lastly, orthodontic chewies are effective tools for ensuring clear aligners seat correctly, though their necessity depends on the aligner material and the orthodontist’s recommendation. Ultimately, understanding the specific purpose and limitations of each type of chewable is key to determining if it’s the right choice for you or your pet. For human supplement use, always seek third-party testing certification like USP to verify what you're actually consuming.
Potential Issues with Gummies
One of the most significant downsides of gummy vitamins is their high sugar content, which can contribute to negative health outcomes. Even 'sugar-free' versions often use citric acid, which can erode tooth enamel. The delicious, candy-like taste also poses a high risk of accidental overdose, especially among children.
Sources:
