The Truth About the Lemon Lime Dum Dum's Color
For many years, Dum Dums have been a staple of candy dishes and treat bags. However, with increasing scrutiny over food additives, many consumers now question the contents of their favorite sweets. Specifically, regarding the bright green and yellow lollipop, the ingredients clearly indicate the use of artificial colors. A review of the ingredient list for the Lemon Lime Dum Dum from Spangler Candy confirms the presence of both Yellow 5 and Blue 1. These two synthetic dyes are combined to create the distinct color of this popular flavor.
What are Yellow 5 and Blue 1?
Yellow 5, also known as Tartrazine, and Blue 1, also known as Brilliant Blue FCF, are two of the most commonly used artificial color additives in the United States. Both are derived from petroleum and have been approved for use by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). While deemed safe for consumption by the FDA, concerns have been raised by consumer groups and some studies linking artificial dyes to issues like hyperactivity in children and occasional allergic reactions. Spangler Candy, the maker of Dum Dums, has defended its continued use of these dyes, citing customer demand and potential issues with taste and supply if they were to switch entirely to natural alternatives.
Spangler Candy’s Stance on Artificial Dyes
Amid a rising trend of food companies transitioning to natural colorings, Spangler Candy has remained firm on its position regarding artificial dyes. The company’s CEO, Kirk Vashaw, has publicly defended the use of synthetic colors, stating they are integral to the product's identity and appeal. He has voiced concerns over the taste alteration and potential allergen issues associated with some natural colors, such as those derived from algae or flower petals. The company has, however, made a concession to the demand for cleaner ingredients by introducing a separate product line.
The Dye-Free Alternative: Dum Dums Orchard Mix
For consumers who wish to avoid artificial dyes, Spangler Candy has released a product line called the "Orchard Mix." This alternative offers several flavors colored with natural ingredients, such as watermelon, cherry, and lemon. This gives consumers a choice while allowing the company to continue producing its classic lineup with the original recipes and vibrant colors. The existence of both options can cause confusion, so it is always recommended to check the specific packaging to determine if a product contains artificial dyes. The availability of these distinct lines shows the company's attempt to satisfy both traditional and health-conscious consumer bases.
Comparing Original vs. Dye-Free Dum Dums
| Feature | Original Dum Dums (e.g., Lemon Lime) | Dye-Free Orchard Mix Dum Dums |
|---|---|---|
| Artificial Colors | Yes (Yellow 5, Blue 1) | No (Naturally colored) |
| Artificial Flavors | Yes | No |
| Vegan | Yes (Contains no animal products) | Yes (Contains no animal products) |
| Common Allergens | Free of top common allergens | Free of top common allergens |
| Taste Profile | Traditional, long-standing formula | Specifically formulated with natural flavors |
| Availability | Widely available in original assorted bags | Available in specialized 'Orchard Mix' bags |
Concerns and Allergen Information
While the use of artificial dyes in Lemon Lime Dum Dums is not an allergen concern for most people, some individuals may have sensitivities. The good news for those with specific dietary restrictions is that Dum Dums are generally considered safe from the most common allergens, including peanuts, tree nuts, milk, eggs, fish, shellfish, wheat, and gluten. The lollipops are also certified OU kosher. Vegetarians and vegans can also rejoice, as the standard recipe contains no animal-derived ingredients. The main consideration for the Lemon Lime flavor remains the artificial dyes, and this is where individual preference and health considerations come into play.
For comprehensive information, including other flavors and products, consumers can always visit the official Spangler Candy website. The site provides detailed ingredient lists and information on all their products, including the dye-free options.
The Final Word
Ultimately, whether you prefer the classic, brightly colored Lemon Lime Dum Dum or the naturally colored Orchard Mix version is a personal choice. Spangler Candy has made efforts to offer options that cater to different consumer preferences while remaining transparent about the ingredients in all their products. For those asking the specific question, the answer is a straightforward "yes," the Lemon Lime Dum Dum contains artificial dyes.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the Lemon Lime Dum Dum does contain artificial dyes, specifically Yellow 5 and Blue 1, which create its distinctive color. While the manufacturer, Spangler Candy, has defended its use of these additives, it also offers a dye-free alternative in its Orchard Mix for consumers who prefer naturally colored and flavored candies. Aside from the dyes, the candy is free of major allergens, kosher, and vegan.
