Understanding the Need for Kids' Vitamins
Providing children with a balanced diet rich in vitamins and minerals is a priority for many parents, but it's not always easy. Picky eating is a common challenge, with some reports indicating that nearly 40% of children aged two to eleven are selective eaters. This can lead to nutritional gaps that a multivitamin may help address. However, with the market flooded with options, choosing the right supplement requires careful consideration of ingredients, dosages, and safety. Among the most popular modern options are Hiya and First Day, two brands known for their 'clean' formulations that contrast with many traditional, sugar-laden gummy vitamins.
Hiya Vitamins: A Deeper Look
Hiya's flagship product is a daily chewable multivitamin designed for children aged two and up. A key differentiator for Hiya is its commitment to being sugar-free, using monk fruit and mannitol for sweetness instead of added sugars, which pediatric dentists often caution against due to the risk of cavities.
- Comprehensive Nutrient Profile: Each Hiya chewable tablet contains over 15 essential vitamins and minerals, often providing more potent doses than competitors. Some age groups may even see certain nutrients, like vitamin A and D, exceeding 100% of the Daily Value. This can be a major plus for parents of very picky eaters who have significant nutritional gaps.
- Eco-Friendly Design: Hiya stands out for its sustainable approach, shipping the first order with a reusable, child-resistant glass bottle and subsequent refills in recyclable pouches.
- Ingredient Transparency: The brand emphasizes clean, non-GMO, and vegan ingredients, free from common allergens, gluten, dairy, and artificial additives.
- Taste and Texture: Customer reviews are mixed on Hiya's taste. Some children love the fruit-flavored chewable tablets, while others find them chalky or sour.
First Day Vitamins: A Comprehensive Overview
First Day markets its vitamins as a daily enrichment for kids aged four and up, focusing on a curated list of nine key micronutrients commonly lacking in childhood diets. Unlike Hiya's tablet form, First Day uses a gummy format, which can be a double-edged sword.
- Moderate Nutrient Philosophy: First Day's formulation follows a 'more isn't always better' philosophy, with nutrients staying below the Tolerable Upper Intake Level. For parents concerned about excessive vitamin intake, this approach can offer reassurance.
- Palatable Gummy Form: Many customers praise the flavor of First Day's gummies, which are described as pleasant and not overly sweet. The gummies contain 2g of organic cane sugar per serving, a trade-off for taste but significantly less than many conventional gummy options.
- Taste and Potential Issues: While the taste is generally well-received, reviews and testing have noted that First Day gummies can melt and clump together, requiring refrigeration to maintain their form.
- Subscription Management: First Day offers a more user-friendly cancellation policy compared to Hiya's, which is a major convenience point for many users.
Hiya vs. First Day: A Comparison Table
| Feature | Hiya | First Day |
|---|---|---|
| Format | Chewable Tablet | Gummy |
| Added Sugar | 0g (sweetened with monk fruit/mannitol) | 2g (sweetened with organic cane sugar) |
| Nutrient Count | 15+ essential vitamins and minerals | 9 key micronutrients |
| Age Range | 2 years and up | 4 years and up |
| Age-Specific Dosing | Yes, nutrient facts differ for ages 2-3 and 4+ | No, single formula for kids 4+ |
| Packaging | Reusable glass bottle with recyclable refill pouches | Reusable bottle with eco-friendly pouches, but gummies can melt |
| Cost | Typically around $30/month for multivitamin | Pricier, but occasional discounts available |
| Cancellation | Reported as difficult, requires emailing customer service | Easy, can be done online |
| Key Benefit | Comprehensive, sugar-free formula for younger kids | Tasty, moderate nutrient gummy for older kids |
Picking the Right Vitamin for Your Child
When comparing Hiya and First Day, the right choice ultimately depends on your child's specific needs, age, and dietary habits. Consider the following factors:
For Picky Eaters and Younger Children
Hiya's more potent, comprehensive formula may be more suitable for the pickiest of eaters, especially those aged two to three, since First Day is not recommended for this age group. The zero added sugar content is also a major benefit for oral health. However, parents should consult a pediatrician, as the higher doses of certain vitamins for the 2-3 age group could be a concern if their diet is not extremely limited.
For Older Children Who Need Consistency
If your child is over four and consistently refuses non-gummy forms, First Day might be the more practical choice. The pleasant gummy taste and texture can encourage a consistent daily habit, even with the small amount of added sugar. For children with less severe nutritional gaps, First Day's moderate nutrient approach can be a good 'insurance policy' supplement.
Form and Oral Health
Hiya's chewable tablet form is a significant advantage for dental health over sticky gummies, which can contribute to cavities. While First Day’s gummies contain a minimal amount of sugar, the sticky texture is a consideration, especially if not followed by brushing.
Convenience and Preferences
For eco-conscious parents, Hiya's refillable glass bottles are a major selling point. If you prefer an easy-to-manage subscription and don't mind the gummy format, First Day's quick online cancellation is a plus.
The Final Verdict
Ultimately, there is no single vitamin that is better for every child; the best option depends on your priorities. Hiya excels in delivering a potent, sugar-free formula for a broader age range, prioritizing dental health and sustainable packaging. First Day offers a palatable gummy with a more modest nutrient profile, which can be an easier transition for kids who prefer candy-like textures. Before starting any supplement regimen, it is crucial to consult with a pediatrician or registered dietitian to determine the best choice for your child's individual nutritional needs. Healthline provides a helpful guide on finding the best vitamins for kids, which is a great resource.
Conclusion
Both Hiya and First Day are reputable brands that offer high-quality, targeted nutritional support for children, but their differences are notable. Hiya’s sugar-free, comprehensive, and sustainable approach may appeal to parents prioritizing dental health and higher nutrient potency, especially for toddlers. First Day's tasty, low-sugar gummies might be a better fit for older children who are resistant to tablets, with a simpler nutrient philosophy and easier subscription management. Making a choice involves weighing these factors against your family's lifestyle and consulting a healthcare professional to ensure your child gets exactly what they need.
Best Kids’ Multivitamins, 2025: We Reviewed 9 Brands and Found a Clear Winner
