Comparing the Alcohol Content
At first glance, hard seltzers like High Noon and White Claw appear quite similar, with their low calorie counts and refreshing fruit flavors. However, a key distinction lies in their alcohol by volume (ABV) and the source of that alcohol. Understanding these differences can help you make a more informed choice based on your preferences.
High Noon: Made with Real Vodka
High Noon has carved out a niche for itself as a vodka-based seltzer, a major departure from many of its competitors. This ready-to-drink cocktail uses real vodka, real fruit juice, and sparkling water for a cleaner, crisp taste. The standard High Noon product line has an ABV of 4.5%, which is slightly lower than a typical White Claw.
- Alcohol Source: High Noon is made with distilled vodka.
- Standard ABV: 4.5%.
- Typical Calories: 100 calories per 12oz can.
- Ingredients: Real vodka, real fruit juice, and sparkling water.
White Claw: Fermented Alcohol Base
White Claw's original hard seltzers are brewed with a gluten-free fermented alcohol base, typically from fermented cane sugar. While the taste is light and crisp, the source of the alcohol differs significantly from High Noon. For its standard line, White Claw contains 5% ABV, a half-percent higher than a standard High Noon. White Claw has also introduced other product variations, including the higher-potency White Claw Surge.
- Alcohol Source: Fermented gluten-free sugar or malt base.
- Standard ABV: 5%.
- White Claw Surge ABV: 8%.
- Typical Calories: 100 calories per 12oz can for standard versions.
Comparison Table: High Noon vs. White Claw
| Feature | High Noon (Standard) | White Claw (Standard) |
|---|---|---|
| ABV (Alcohol by Volume) | 4.5% | 5% (US & Canada) |
| Alcohol Source | Distilled Vodka | Fermented Gluten-Free Base |
| Typical Calories (12oz) | 100 | 100 |
| Typical Carbs (12oz) | <3g | 2g |
| Ingredients | Real vodka, real juice, sparkling water | Purified carbonated water, alcohol, natural flavors, cane sugar |
Factors to Consider When Choosing
When deciding between High Noon and White Claw, several factors can influence your choice beyond just the basic alcohol content. Your preference for taste, ingredients, and alcohol type plays a significant role.
- Alcohol Source: Do you prefer the taste and feel of a drink made with a distilled spirit like vodka (High Noon), or are you perfectly fine with a hard seltzer from a fermented sugar base (White Claw)? Some drinkers report a cleaner, less lingering aftertaste with spirit-based beverages like High Noon.
- ABV Levels: Consider the slight difference in ABV. If you are watching your intake, the 0.5% difference can add up over multiple cans. Conversely, if you want a bit more potency, a standard White Claw has a slight edge, and its Surge line offers significantly more alcohol.
- Ingredients: High Noon explicitly markets the use of real fruit juice, a feature that may appeal to consumers who prefer more natural ingredients in their beverages. White Claw uses natural flavors and juice concentrate.
- Flavor Profile: The flavor profile of High Noon can feel more like a light, canned cocktail due to the vodka and real juice, while White Claw has a classic, straightforward hard seltzer taste.
- Gluten: Both High Noon and White Claw's standard products are gluten-free, so this is not a major differentiating factor for most people with a gluten sensitivity.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the choice between High Noon and White Claw boils down to a matter of personal preference regarding the alcohol base and flavor. While High Noon offers a slightly lower 4.5% ABV made from real vodka, White Claw provides a standard 5% ABV from a fermented sugar base. Both deliver a low-calorie, low-carb experience in a convenient can. For those seeking higher alcohol content, White Claw Surge is an option with 8% ABV. The best way to find your favorite is to try both and see which one's taste and profile you prefer for your next casual drink or social gathering. For more information on units of alcohol and responsible drinking, consult reliable health resources like Drinkaware.
Drinkaware: How many units and calories are in hard seltzer?