The Surprising Truth Behind Traditional Winemaking
Many consumers are surprised to learn that their favorite wine may not be vegan. The issue doesn't lie with the fermented grapes themselves but with a post-fermentation step known as 'fining'. This process is used by winemakers to clarify and stabilize the wine, removing unwanted haze-causing particles like proteins, yeast, and phenolic compounds. If left alone, wine will often clarify naturally over time (a process called 'self-fining'), but this takes longer and commercial pressure often dictates a faster turnaround.
Common non-vegan fining agents
Traditional fining agents attract and bind to the suspended particles in the wine, creating larger clumps that can be easily filtered out. Many of these agents are derived from animals:
- Isinglass: A gelatin-like substance extracted from the swim bladders of fish. It is often used to clarify white and rosé wines.
- Gelatin: Derived from boiled animal parts, primarily bones and hides. It is used for both red and white wines.
- Casein: A milk protein, sometimes used in the form of skim milk. This is suitable for vegetarians but not vegans and is commonly used for white wines.
- Egg Albumen: Made from egg whites, this is a traditional fining agent for red wines to soften harsh tannins.
- Chitosan: A carbohydrate sourced from the shells of crustaceans.
Vegan-friendly fining alternatives
Fortunately, with the rising demand for vegan products, many wineries now use animal-free alternatives for fining. Some winemakers also choose to skip the fining process altogether, leaving the wine 'unfined' or 'unfiltered'. Vegan fining agents include:
- Bentonite clay: A volcanic clay that is negatively charged and binds to positively charged proteins, effectively clarifying white and rosé wines.
- Activated charcoal: A form of carbon used to remove off-odors and excess color.
- Vegetable proteins: Derived from peas, potatoes, wheat, or other plants.
- Poly-vinyl-poly-pyrrolidone (PVPP): A synthetic polymer that removes phenols and browning precursors.
Your guide to identifying vegan wine
So, how can you know for sure if a wine is vegan? It requires a bit of detective work, as many countries do not require fining agents to be listed on the label.
1. Look for vegan certification labels
This is the most straightforward method. Several organizations offer vegan certification, and their logos on the bottle provide a reliable guarantee.
- V-Label: The European Vegetarian Union certifies products with a plant-shaped 'V' symbol on a green or yellow background.
- The Vegan Society: Based in the UK, this international trademark uses a sunflower logo.
2. Search for 'unfined' or 'unfiltered' on the bottle
If a wine is bottled as 'unfined' or 'unfiltered,' it means no fining agents were used in its production, making it suitable for vegans. These wines may have a slightly cloudy appearance, but this does not affect the taste.
3. Use online resources and databases
Several online resources can help you verify a wine's vegan status if it's not listed on the bottle. The most well-known is Barnivore.com, a user-generated database that contacts manufacturers directly to confirm production methods. While a great resource, it is a volunteer effort and the information may not always be up-to-date.
4. Contact the winery directly
For the most definitive answer, especially for smaller or lesser-known vineyards, you can visit the producer's website or contact them via email. Most reputable wineries will readily share this information, and many now have dedicated vegan sections on their websites.
5. Be aware of other potential animal-derived products
While fining is the primary reason most wines are not vegan, other animal products can be used during production or bottling. Some corks might be sealed with beeswax or labels attached with animal-based glues. Some vegans also reject biodynamic wines where animal manure is used in the vineyard, though this is a more stringent interpretation.
Fining agent comparison: Traditional vs. Vegan-Friendly
| Traditional (Non-Vegan) Fining Agents | Sourced From | Typical Use | Vegan-Friendly Alternatives | Sourced From | Typical Use |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Isinglass | Fish bladders | Clarifying white and rosé wines | Bentonite Clay | Volcanic ash | Clarifying white and rosé wines, protein stabilization |
| Gelatin | Animal hides and bones | Clarifying red and white wines | Activated Charcoal | Carbon | Removing off-flavors and colors |
| Casein | Milk protein | Clarifying white wine, removing oxidative taint | Vegetable Proteins | Peas, potatoes, wheat | Clarifying wine, reducing tannins |
| Egg Albumin | Egg whites | Softening tannins in red wines | Poly-vinyl-poly-pyrrolidone (PVPP) | Synthetic polymer | Removing bitter compounds and browning precursors |
Conclusion
While identifying vegan wine can be more complex than many expect, there are clear strategies for making an informed choice. The use of animal-derived fining agents is the main reason a wine may not be vegan, but the growing demand for ethical products has led to a wider availability of vegan-friendly options. By checking for clear vegan certification symbols, looking for 'unfined' or 'unfiltered' labeling, consulting online resources, or reaching out to the producer, you can confidently select a wine that aligns with your dietary and ethical preferences.
Additional resources
-
Barnivore.com: A large online database that lists the vegan status of wines, beers, and spirits.
-
The Vegan Society: Provides information on their certification and list of approved products.
-
BeVeg: Certifies vegan products, including a comprehensive list of vegan wine brands.
