Skip to content

How Unhealthy Are 5 Guys Fries? A Nutritional Breakdown

5 min read

According to a study conducted by PlushCare in 2024, Five Guys fries were deemed the least healthy of major fast-food chains, scoring significantly higher in unhealthiness metrics. So, how unhealthy are 5 Guys fries, and what exactly does that mean for your diet? A closer look at the nutritional data reveals surprisingly high levels of calories, sodium, and fat, making them an occasional treat rather than a regular staple.

Quick Summary

A detailed analysis of Five Guys' nutrition facts shows their fries are a caloric and fatty indulgence. The unhealthiness stems from large portion sizes, generous salting, and the use of peanut oil. Consumers should be mindful of the significant fat and sodium content, especially in larger servings.

Key Points

  • High Calorie Count: A large order of Five Guys fries contains over 1,300 calories, making it one of the most calorie-dense fast-food fries available.

  • Significant Fat Content: Generous portion sizes and cooking in peanut oil result in a large fry order having 57 grams of fat.

  • Excessive Sodium: The heavy salting means even a regular-sized fry has nearly 1,000 mg of sodium, approaching daily recommended limits.

  • Peanut Oil Allergen: All fries are cooked in 100% peanut oil, making them unsafe for individuals with peanut allergies.

  • Portion Control is Key: To mitigate the unhealthy aspects, sharing a 'little' portion is the most sensible way to enjoy these fries.

In This Article

The Unpacking of Five Guys Fries Nutrition

When you order Five Guys fries, you are getting hand-cut, fresh-cooked potatoes fried in 100% peanut oil. While the freshness and cooking method contribute to their delicious taste, they also contribute to a surprisingly high nutritional load. The nutritional breakdown of Five Guys fries varies significantly by portion size, with even the 'little' size packing a substantial amount of calories, fat, and sodium.

The Calorie and Fat Content Shock

The most prominent factor contributing to the unhealthiness of Five Guys fries is their calorie and fat count. As portions increase, so does the caloric density. For instance, a 'large' serving can contain well over 1,300 calories and 57 grams of fat, far exceeding a person's needs for a single meal. This is largely due to the copious amount of peanut oil used for frying, and the 'extra' scoop of fries often added to the bag. While peanut oil can be a decent option for frying due to its high smoke point, the sheer volume used adds to the fat content.

Here is a closer look at the different portion sizes:

  • Little Fries: A seemingly modest order, yet it contains approximately 526-530 calories and 23 grams of fat.
  • Regular Fries: This is where the numbers become more startling, with about 953 calories and 41 grams of fat.
  • Large Fries: An order that truly embodies the concept of 'unhealthy,' providing 1,314 calories and a massive 57 grams of fat.

High Sodium Levels

Salt is another key ingredient that makes Five Guys fries so craveable but also raises health concerns. The company is known for its heavy-handed salting, and a regular serving of Five Guys Style fries can contain nearly 1,000 milligrams of sodium. For individuals monitoring their sodium intake, especially those with high blood pressure, this amount can be problematic. A large order pushes sodium to over 1,300 milligrams, approaching the American Heart Association's ideal daily limit of 1,500 mg in just one side dish. For context, the entire recommended daily max for many adults is 2,300 mg. The Cajun style fries are even higher in sodium due to the added seasoning.

Comparing Five Guys Fries to the Competition

To put the nutritional impact of Five Guys fries into perspective, it helps to compare them to other fast-food offerings. The generous portions and cooking method place Five Guys at a different level of nutritional density than most competitors. While the freshness of the ingredients is a selling point, it doesn't translate to a healthier product due to the cooking method and portion size.

Fast Food Chain Serving Size Calories (approx.) Fat (grams, approx.) Sodium (mg, approx.)
Five Guys Regular 953 41 962
McDonald's Large 490 24 260
In-N-Out Regular 395 18 245
KFC Regular Secret Recipe 310 15 1100

As the table clearly illustrates, a regular serving of Five Guys fries contains significantly more calories, fat, and sodium than equivalent large portions from McDonald's and In-N-Out. The caloric difference alone is staggering, with Five Guys fries having nearly double the calories of McDonald's large fries.

The Takeaway for Conscious Consumers

While the nutritional facts for Five Guys fries are certainly high, it's important to frame this information correctly. Occasional indulgence in a high-calorie, high-fat meal can fit within a balanced diet. The key is to practice moderation and be mindful of your other food choices throughout the day. Sharing an order of the 'little' fries with a companion is one of the most effective strategies to enjoy the taste without overdoing it.

For those with specific health concerns, such as high blood pressure or a peanut allergy, it is crucial to be fully informed. The high sodium content poses a risk for hypertension, and the use of 100% peanut oil means the fries are off-limits for individuals with severe peanut allergies. Ultimately, the freshness and flavor of Five Guys fries come at a nutritional cost that consumers should be aware of, enabling them to make informed choices that align with their health goals.

Conclusion

There is no getting around the fact that Five Guys fries are nutritionally dense, particularly when it comes to calories, fat, and sodium. While the hand-cut, fresh-fried approach and unique flavor are part of the brand's appeal, these very qualities contribute to a less-than-healthy nutritional profile. Compared to other major fast-food players, Five Guys fries are among the highest in calories and fat, requiring a strategic approach to consumption. The generous portion sizes and heavy salting mean that even a 'little' portion is a significant treat, and sharing is highly recommended. The use of peanut oil also makes them unsafe for those with allergies. In short, these fries are a delicious but decidedly unhealthy option, best enjoyed sparingly and with a full understanding of their high nutritional impact.

Summary of Findings

Key Nutritional Facts about Five Guys Fries

  • High in Calories: A large serving of Five Guys fries contains over 1,300 calories, which can constitute more than half of the daily calorie recommendation for many individuals.
  • Packed with Fat: The large fries contain 57 grams of fat, with a regular size having 41 grams, largely from being cooked in peanut oil.
  • Loaded with Sodium: A regular order has close to 1,000 mg of sodium, a substantial portion of the recommended daily intake.
  • Portion Sizes: The generous portion sizes, which often include extra fries in the bag, contribute to the high nutritional values.
  • Unhealthiest Ranking: Studies have ranked Five Guys fries as one of the unhealthiest fast-food options due to their caloric density.

Ingredients and Allergens

  • Peanut Oil: Five Guys exclusively uses 100% peanut oil to cook its fries, which is a major allergen concern for some customers.
  • Fresh Potatoes: The fries are made from fresh, hand-cut potatoes, which is a positive but doesn't outweigh the high fat and sodium from cooking.
  • Cajun Seasoning: The Cajun style adds further to the sodium content.

How to Enjoy Responsibly

  • Share Portions: Sharing a single order of 'little' fries is the best way to enjoy the flavor without the full nutritional cost.
  • Mindful Consumption: When paired with a burger, a meal with Five Guys fries can easily exceed daily calorie and fat recommendations.
  • Peanut Allergy Warning: The risk of severe allergic reaction means individuals with peanut allergies must avoid the fries and be cautious in the restaurant.

Outbound Link for Further Research

For more detailed nutritional information directly from the source, consumers can view Five Guys' official nutrition guide: https://www.fiveguys.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/five-guys-us-nutrition-allergen-guide-english-1-final.pdf

Frequently Asked Questions

A large order of Five Guys fries, Five Guys Style, contains 1,314 calories.

Yes, Five Guys cooks all of its fries in 100% pure, cholesterol-free, refined peanut oil.

The fat content varies by size, with a little order containing 23g, a regular order having 41g, and a large order packing 57g of fat.

According to several studies, including one by PlushCare, Five Guys fries have been identified as the least healthy fast-food fries due to their high calorie, fat, and sodium content.

Yes, a large serving of Five Guys Style fries contains 1,327mg of sodium, and a regular size has 962mg. The Cajun style is even higher.

The high calorie count is a combination of large portion sizes, the potatoes' natural carbohydrates, and the significant amount of peanut oil used for cooking.

The best way to make the fries a healthier choice is to order the 'little' size and share it with others to manage portion size and reduce overall calorie, fat, and sodium intake.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.